orlistat tablets side effects how to use advair 250 diskus what are the side effects of saw palmetto in women is there a generic for erythromycin Purchase doxycycline 100mg online how to get minocycline in australia drugs like paxil cr over counter zaditor noroxin new zealand generic avapro in viagra price in pakistan med cab cipro why has ortho tri-cyclen been discontinued all types eulexin pills can humans take cephalexin 500mg for dogs cleocin gel for men sale in uk can i get diclofenac gel what does it mean when diflucan doesn;t work order diflucan over the counter is clavamox safe for humans canadian pharmacy reglan malaseb shampoo instructions use shallaki coupon online pharmacy buy drugs zovirax buy levlen paypal low cost overnight arimidex flomax coupons printable correct dosage of valtrex for cold sores side effects of bactrim in dogs tetracycline for dogs uti calan discount medications buy prilosec online with no prescription furosemide generic name naprosyn without prescription canadian pharmacies no prescription needed pills for sale online cymbalta online purchase generic medicine adalat cc retin a micro gel 0.1 reviews biaxin canada no prescription what drug category is lopid comprar minocin original en madrid serevent tablets side effects best place buy benzac atarax compared to benadryl best site get malegra fxt zoloft dosage increase side effects wellbutrin sr tablets us online levoxyl reviews zyban reviews lasix fast canada ancient formulae brahmi amla herbal indian hair oil reviews cipla fieldcall plavix price india claravis dosage weight emsam price india how much will vytorin cost ortho tri cyclen missed 2 white pills online pharmacy leukeran cheap actos 15mg hydrochloride tardive dyskinesia abilify lawsuit yasmin rx number how long does it take for adalat to work viagra online order com ventolin tablets in pregnancy furosemide generic for lasix z pack 500 mg dose diclofenac sod. er 100 mg tab buy micronase 100 half price himcolin fluoxetine manufacturer usa generic drug for exelon patch buy suhagra online india acheter feldene pas cher levithyroxine buy from india can buy mircette online after accutane treatment side effects buy hyzaar forte billig finast online kaufen buy toradol without a subscription can order tadapox online suhagra for dogs buy finpecia mexico no prescription trandate online cheap red pill blue pill facebook african american lisinopril how can i use diclofenac to get a high where to buy doxycycline ointment evista overnight delivery how to get accutane cheap buy prednisone online overnight what are the side effects of citalopram 40 mg tablets zantac tablets online 1 guy 1 jar video interview raloxifene side effects cancer antabuse online usa no prescription xenical best price prednisone 5mg uses canadian pharmacy spam stop ginseng capsules walmart trazodone medication on line requip xl 8 mg price viagra by pfizer no prescription what is amlodipine 5mg stop receiving emails canadian pharmacy zerit to buy in england generic styplon buy canada long lasting sex pills uk donde comprar cardura can you order inhalers online adalat pas cher arthritis in dogs back legs coreg 100mg cheep tamoxifen and weight loss pills what is the medication doxycycline hyclate used for heart medicine cardizem baclofen where to purchase post cycle therapy etodolac order generic viagra online overnight cialis 30 day trial coupon buy brand advair diskus 15mg online to buy wellbutrin sr in uk viagra replacements over counter qual o melhor remedio viagra ou cialis promethazine pill usage combivent where to buy cymbalta non generic metronidazole side effects how long research grade ayurslim over the counter erection packs 2 cheap abilify 2mg canada west indies vs new zealand live 2012 canadian online meds no prescription buy brahmi plant sydney levitra on line no prescription strattera cheap use torsemide coupon online when to plant amaryllis bulbs in florida can you buy viagra over the counter in usa drugstore micronase tablets price generic seroquel cost premarin mist canada buy atorlip-20 cheap generic vasotec buy furosemide lowest price buy cheap terramycin moduretic medicine cheap cialis professional 20 mg costco pharmacy online pharmacists aldactone 25 mg efectos secundarios zofran uk online order zovirax cream online no prescription online pharmacy tramadol cost comparison prednisolone online prescription best viagra super prices active uk cutting lipitor pills in half brahmi for sale buy prevacid greece ventolin inhaler dosage uk buy pamelor inhaler canada geriforte generic reviews buying floxin for dogs nexium next day shipping buy moduretic greece viagra retail price walgreens zocor sales 2006 furosemide canada jelly viagra uk buy tenormin tablets hark a vagrant amazon canada buying lasix for dogs silagra 100 price in india order chloramphenicol no rx canadian pharmacy asacol hd cheap genuine mentat ds syrup best price tetracycline australia price lipitor over the counter mircette tablets for sale buy zetia tablets online zoloft generic australia can you use keflex for uti best otc diet pills for women where can i order kamagra gold buy zocor online usa unisom discontinued indian pharmacy phenergan hytrin dosage for sweating buy minocin boots drug market order promethazine buy eulexin mexican pharmacies topamax brand name versus generic indian generics online himplasia cheap lamisil india betapace uk next day delivery buy alphagan p 0.1 buy brand levitra visa buy protonix canada flagyl antibiotic type buy allegra with generic drug odds twins clomid iui indian jellyfish viagra online buy luvox mg online can order finast online synthroid from flint street value of seroquel 300 prilosec over the counter prescription drug diclofenac sodium celebrex sale canada canadian pharmacy online no prescription discount reminyl brands india use lisinopril coupon online best price for female viagra buy cheap amitriptyline online discount hrsa pharmacy support services center zestoretic generic 2013 drugs buy doxycycline without prescription paypal leukeran to buy from europe how long for toprol xl to take effect vytorin uses medication cheap genuine serophene online where do i buy apcalis sx cialis prescription prices healthy diet 40 year old man como usar serophene comprar tegretol pela internet diflucan medicine children do you need rx hyaluronic acid alli and low carb diet eat how long does it take for minocycline to clear acne health canada cefadroxil buspirone generic for buspar buy tinidazole tablets canada cardizem drugstore.com what is ventolin nebulizer used for sustiva costco neo blue pill red pill quote promethazine lawsuit settlements buy xeloda 10 didronel for sale uk viagra jelly cost in canada maximum metformin dose per day buy diamox us acetazolamide pharmacy albenza costco where can i buy dutasteride what is provera 10mg otc equivalent to hydrochlorothiazide de donde sale el aciclovir ampicillin medication what is zoloft used for in adults side effects of pariet tablets buy aleve capsules withdrawal from prednisone how long cialis e20 review terramycin without prescription amantadine mechanism influenza brand cialis comprare cost prescription without insurance rock hard erection pills what is the best natural alternative to viagra healthy mango chicken recipe is it safe to order nizoral buy glucophage fast shipping buy topamax from mexico online zero discount pharmaceuticals how long to take aciphex ramicomp gen zyvox suppositories buy ordering cytotec mexico can order dilantin canada cabgolin generico italiano generic for grifulvin v prevacid canada what are the side effects of benicar hct digoxin online order lanoxin levitra canada pharmacy online what is a zoloft high like can etodolac 300 mg get you high wellbutrin tablets identification purchase clonidine uk doxycline for horses lisinopril hctz overdose treatment nolvadex on line in the canada canadian pharmacy levitra professional 5 mg doxycycline over the counter sertraline hcl 100mg info www.cheapviagra.com.au proventil online store ceftin side effects elderly generic entocort ec top 10 online lynoral sites online buy lotrisone cheapest maxalt 10 mg. wafer can you get pregnant while taking celexa use himcocid coupon online get viagra prescription canada how do i get viagra from my doctor cheapest prazosin to buy overnight terramycin ginette-35 next day medicine that effects depo provera quinine pregnancy side effects eurax hydrocortisone cream inflammatory skin conditions nolvadex fda approved to buy without prescription symptoms of chlamydia in anus where can i buy the cheapest clomid generic for depakote 500mg is it safe to order claritin buy alli 121 bupropion over the counter usa suppliers of ciplox in us generic avalide cost buspar 10mg pills pak online jobs average cost of tamoxifen arjuna without script mexico pharmacies online that sell pariet alli side effects buy coreg online without a prescription generic phexin switzerland get ginette-35 las vegas what is thyroxine hormone lanoxin online uk us pharmacy online hyzaar no prescription olanzapine sale ortho tri cyclen online pharmacy effexor xr uk boots comprar pastillas alli baratas how to get off lexapro safely by james harper prednisolone canada prescription missed citalopram dose side effects of xeloda 500 mg japanese viagra pro benicar online sales what drug category is parlodel trimox mail order cytotec drugstore order adalat xl online canadian pharmacy what is minocin cheapest place to buy differin post cycle therapy medrol plavix discount no prescription generic nitrofurantoin macro trandate wanted online review order mevacor online no presctiption viagra or cialis which is better purchase lamictal i took 6 motrin pills walmart pharmacy four dollar drug list alesse birth control company nitrofurantoin contraceptive pills do you need rx grifulvin v where can i get acai max cleanse in stores buy cutivate no prescription discount betnovate cheap viagra in u.s. online pharmacy over counter retin-a 0,05 valtrex dosage suppressive therapy pregnancy aricept in the uk now trental 400 mg 20 retard draje buy perfume online and ship internationally what is gasex tablets citalopram online purchase pill identifier with pictures- m365 prilosec otc - 42 tablets post cycle therapy cleocin gel cheap kamagra.co.uk can you buy adalat cc blood geriforte syrup shoppers drug mart side effects of toprol xl 25 mg childrens motrin dosage zanaflex cheap australia pharmacy buy cheap naprosyn pills famciclovir price list best place to buy combivent in usa buy penegra greece retin a micro gel .04 for wrinkles seroquel roche precio argentina estrace no prescription compare prices overnight toradol propecia buy online uk extendaquin online usa lotensin tablets online detrol generic release date zestoretic precio mexico non prescription cytoxan buy 60 mg cymbalta online are there alligators in the gulf of mexico nizoral shampoo cvs pharmacy non persciption avapro haridra pill shortage pariet compresse costo valacyclovir hydrochloride vs. valtrex precio vytorin 10 20 mexico is mail order indocin safe lov cost imuran cialis jelly medication order alavert cheap price i want to pay some advair diskus nike air max leopard print buy colchicine 0.5 mg best price crestor what is bayer aspirin made of over counter keflex alternative medicine to diamox buy inderal singapore brand cialis cost prescription drug aceon comprar isoniazid portugal canadian online pharmacy for unisom blopress spain over counter where to buy zanaflex online uk indocin suppository side effects top 10 online januvia sites where do i buy rumalaya forte blood pressure medication losartan side effects russian pharmacy new york buy adderall no rx no membership order reglan online furp diclofenaco 50 mg canada erectile dysfunction pharmacy for sale uk buy ventolin inhaler usa where can i get isoniazid trim herbal slimming tablets can you only get remeron on prescription voltaren dose for gout cheapest place to buy albendazole retin-a ge max dose vigara desde canada cialis sublingual shipping overseas zyvox side effects tiredness tetracycline 500 mg better than styplon ditropan reviews hyperhidrosis blogs de viagra onde comprar crestor 10mg lexapro brand positioning the online drugstore hytrin flagyl er without insurance original cialis sale liv tablets for purchase buy astelin online with mastercard canada and januvia order birth control pills online canada cost of extendaquin without insurance is mail order minomycin safe order prescription drugs without prescriptions dosis de cicloferon pastillas get cheap cymbalta blopress online in us is it illegal to order generic ranitidine pharmaceutical prescription drug abuse renova energia balanc,o without prescriptions buy viagra how to import malegra fxt where can i get some flonase pharmacies amantadine mg buy cheap acivir pills from usa pharmacy tenormin 10 mg compresse depakote 20 mg cost of aciclovir saw palmetto australia price shop prozac 20 mg ovulation clomid calculators cipro prix en pharmacie en france zovirax cream boots hydrochlorothiazide suppliers in india cheap generic viagra sales in uk suppliers of pamelor in us order lipothin online uk mirapex medication dosage where can i get protonix from cytoxan comprare levaquin dosage for sinusitis cloridrato de ciprofloxacino dexametasona colirio buy imuran without rx levaquin cheap australia pharmacy where can i purchase arava generic for lipitor date for brand name albendazole online yasmin low dose pill is generic confido available in usa buy brand levitra without a subscription pyridium delivery london yasmin ben salem medrol rxlist premarin generic canada generic aceon overnite shipping buy geriforte syrup no prescription buy altace online reviews dove posso comprare bacche di acai dostinex 10 mg methotrexate legal us buy amlodipine 5mg online uk asacol enema dosage styplon doctors online ten thuoc medrol 16mg cheap wellbutrin sr free delivery viramune where can i buy it generic tablet aceon mg viagra online ordering reviews hyaluronic acid not generic generic flovent 220 mcg inhaler tegretol carbamazepine 200 mg proguanil and chloroquine cost pfizer viagra patent expiry mircette how to buy best price for real retin-a 0,05 side effects of stilnox sleeping tablets substitute for viagra uk accutane medication side effects most commonly abused non-prescription drugs pilex tablets from himalaya drug market order benadryl propranolol over the counter australia buy tinidazole 500mg ordering zetia low cost overnight venlor over the counter viagra tesco cymbalta perth australia buy altace uk ramipril side effects of zithromax antibiotics better than geriforte female viagra from usa generic 30 adalat cc actoplus met uk companies only caverta express canada buy elavil without a script 100 mg reglan cialis 2.5mg do you need rx roxithromycin fincar no rx buy meclizine in ireland can you benicar prescription buy olmesartan buy capoten medication digoxin online pay paypal parlodel online forum generic for abilify medication detrol shopping can diltiazem cause weight gain cloridrato de sertralina engorda ou emagrece cabgolin daily use reviews global discount drugs rumalaya forte 40 mg dose viagra patent extension 2011 voltaren gel online apotheke what types of pyridium are there dostinex sublingual dosage glucose insulin tolerance test canada buy meclizine without prescription can you buy viagra over the counter in france far lyclear dermal cream permethrin 5 w/w lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide doses etodolac free shipping seroflo 250 inhaler price india wellbutrin sr 100mg tablets yagara on line in the usa periactin costco azithromycin side effects in dogs purchase tadapox cheap impotency erectile dysfunction pills recommended dosage nolvadex pct roxithromycin prescription only ditropan store diclofenac cream over the counter uk stats counter screen resolution lamisil india cost how to get off pain pills fast buy glucotrol xl online with mastercard pill rx health order zetia products how to get brafix in australia what does a promethazine codeine high feel like over the counter emsam biaxin pills buy buy venlor visa cost of levlen without insurance zofran tablets price amitriptyline daily use reviews cheap levothroid buy online indian delivery alesse prescription naprosyn canada prescription resources for plendil levitra professional phone orders low dose amitriptyline sleep aid does prednisone cause panting in dogs advair buy usa buy alli diet pill online para que sirve la amantadina con clorfenamina y paracetamol how to order atorlip-5 chemical synthesis of nitroglycerin generic canada buy adalat vytorin 10 40 coupon online pharmacy chloramphenicol canadian online pharmacy phone calls how much is bentyl tablets buy floxin online india buy albendazole tablets pharmacy generic for minocin buy lamictal with a mastercard generic carbozyne buy canada ampicillin competitive inhibitor viramune online pay paypal cheap robaxin overnight delivery diclofenac mg safe buy hydrea online order betnovate online no prescription with a visa buy cafergot boots list of tesco stores selling arava cheap tegretol no prescription periactin dosage infant compare prices kamagra gold buy bactroban cream no prescription drug side effects of crestor statin hyzaar shop what is bupropion sr 150 mg used for eldepryl tablets purchase on line femcare generico italiano buy eldepryl 40 spanish pharmacies online zyrtec discount voucher buy cialis soft 20 what is the drug classification for aldactone acai capsules triple strength 1500mg review buy cystone online from usa what is strattera for uk drugs forum hcg clomid pct cycle aristocort canada prescription buyers of antabuse canada buy flomax online canada no prescription generic vytorin us order renagel tablets us pharmacy online zovirax cialis 20 mg tablet tetracycline online legally compazine cost comparison red ginseng reviews didronel cheap uk buy diltiazem bulk cialis prices at cvs paxil cr price is there a generic form of allegra us pharmacies online that sell vasotec lasix dosage for children inderal online overnight shipping popularpills-online.com power slim acai berry australia canada drug supply accutane missed zoloft dose side effects buy cheap lantus malegra fxt cheap uk online us buy antibiotics no prescription what is doxycycline hyclate 100mg tablets for cozaar discontinued best price for micardis hct lipitor atorvastatin ultimate acai max sale silagra mg uk side effects of cyproheptadine in cats proventil dosage information buy ranitidine inhaler canada order urispas online fucidin pills online in the usa lexapro from canada seroquel no prrescription xenical from usa pharmacy acquisto kamagra sicuro online fast zovirax delivery kamagra jelly review endep overnight pharmacy levitra canada no prescription how to order viagra in uk requip 100 review medrol dose pack discontinued amitriptyline tablets depression order metformin online without rx patient reviews on tegretol cytotec misoprostol buy diamox 20 mg buy cardura perth australia legit canadian pharmacy no prescription silagra drugs for sale premarin side effects hair loss buy isoptin 5 how much will pravachol cost why is there a shortage of brand cialis lanoxin buy online ireland western drug mentat tofranil nome generico how long does clomid take to work after steroids clomid uk no prescription order tretinoin 0,025 cheap buy kamagra fast how to get endep on line best unisom prices cheapo drugs atrovent online meds motilium 10 does it work florida hyaluronic acid half price rumalaya liniment cheap myambutol sale uk diamox us online buy drugstore waar kan ik cialis kopen what does lisinopril 20 mg look like what does a prevacid pill look like how to get augmentin drug can i order nitrofurantoin no prescription in the usa choline piracetam experience cephalexin drugstore com pletal buy canada canada buy zanaflex without prescription adalat cheap generic version of antivert side effect for zyrtec allergy medicine effexor xr generic release date drug what is periactin used for in children bentyl from india cafergot mg canada beconase aq order by phone dulcolax price nizoral from usa pharmacy generic for yasmin zarah adalat discount strattera health canada where to buy purim in canada safely clozaril online australia erythromycin tablets used for acne brand cialis cost canadian generic bactrim ds price pilex billig kaufen zestril 10 mg tab florida alligator hunting season 2010 dates robaxin for men in usa januvia for sale neurontin 300 mg price left superior parietal lobe function ivf drugs for sale alli over counter diet pills unprescribed clomid success stories buy acticin united states fda low price atrovent uk weight gain pills for men in india nexium shortage mail-order plendil coumadin billig kaufen donde comprar yagara remeron reviews what are the side effects of lamisil avodart 0.5 mg buy azithromycin and alcohol interaction lithium price forecast 2011 generic lipitor release date 2011 propranolol no prescription reviews viagra black market citalopram over the counter uk billig tretinoin 0,05 online kaufen donde comprar isoptin bystolic 40 mg what does amitriptyline make you feel like elocom krem ciaza elavil coupons retino-a cream 0,025 online legally buying toprol xl yasmin boland yahoo why has pariet been discontinued generic ginette-35 us cheap viagra online from india viagra sublingual discount naprosyn shipping overseas prevacid cheap mexico pharmacy discount cholestoplex prometh with codeine cough syrup online pharmacy no prescription needed india buy depakote online from australia generic zofran overnite shipping buy cialis no prescription online aciclovir tablets 800mg price of viagra in ireland etodolac lawsuit cleocin lawsuit canada purchase cymbalta 20 mg canadian lisinopril hctz side effects of long term use of prednisolone in dogs pyridium cost comparison mg buy cheap maximum dose of toradol im viagra super active shipping overseas clomiphene 50mg drug valtrex now trazodone insomnia dependence bactrim ds 800 160 what is it for buy isoptin online in usa bactrim sale online us sales buy cozaar cipla suhagra ethionamide lawsuit canada proscar india no prescription can you order advair diskus brand name effects estrace dose synthord rx without prescription order cytotec without prescription strattera side effects wiki single-dose tinidazole for the treatment of giardiasis does pfizer make generic lipitor what is the dosage of singulair for adults purchase abilify canadian pharmacy paroxetine price australia pletal echeck research grade danazol is oracea better than doxycycline what is aspen trazodone used for how old to buy benadryl order fml forte generic atacand hct available sumycin tablets from buy bupron sr medicine children lamisil prescription strength low price danazol uk how long does it take to get a liver biopsy back generic finast for sale on line best place buy bactroban generic cialis tadalafil 20mg from india non prescription ciplox buy endep in ireland combivent discount program best online pharmacy generic nexium buy cheap cialis sublingual using pay pal order luvox 120 mg hyzaar order online sinequan costco propranolol online from india best generic brand viagra review buy viagra soft tab deltasone 50mg tablets how to use paxil femara uk pharmacy buy vpxl quick caffe` ginseng dove comprarlo mexican pharmacies online oxycontin ezonlinepharmacy what does nexium cure zyprexa dosages zyrtec wanted online review order clomid 100mg uk cialis price herbal viagra women can you buy forzest over the counter bactrim forte dosage for uti pharmacies albendazole no rx ranitidine online half price remeron buy phenergan next day delivery what are fertility drugs side effects non prescription renagel natural anxiety medication gnc quibron-t in croatia what is the dose for tetracycline indian pharmacy seroquel buy nolvadex for daily use capoten doctors online buy diclofenac online overnight delivery buying aspirin in china what is the minimum dosage for viagra minomycin sublingual dosage flagyl 400mg over night shipping viagra pills uk where to buy diclofenac sodium gel accutane long term side effects medication voltaren mg tablet ciprofloxacin dose bnf order diakof canada effexor buy usa how much will chloromycetin cost prednisone withdrawal in dogs top online pharmacies no prescription order generic luvox cialis precio en mexico d.f what is cephalexin for erection packs ii drugs cialis generic clozaril usa buy plavix next day list of tesco stores selling minomycin what is robaxin side effects safe buy atorlip-10 online buy ceftin 15mg online metformin over counter us what is prazosin 1 mg used for generic name for yasmin nexium shipping overseas spc fenofibrate tablets what is voveran 50 buy zetia from india where requip diamox prescription information over the counter asthma inhalers rite aid probalan sale click here delivery we are david bailey free galaxy tab can i get live wallpaper on my pc where can i buy phenergan in uk cialis soft mg india pravachol shopping motilium 100ml prec,o without altace cheap phenergan pediatric dose mg kg can you buy benicar generic pharmacy can we trust benemid online como comprar viagra pela internet no brasil prinivil uk buy tetracycline antibiotics mode of action applications buy valtrex over the counter diclofenac sodium 50mg for sale best place buy levitra online promethazine codeine online drugstore how to order artane finast without prescription canada online pharmacy us where to buy etodolac ointment citalopram dosage 60mg speman lawsuit settlements anafranil dosage maximum lamictal and alcohol interaction ceftin ceftin generic cefuroxime motrin women buy best site to buy altace v-gel prices at costco can you get imuran mirapex coupon code accutane to buy in australia cipla finpecia complaints us online pharmacy no prescription erexin-v lipitor reviews wellbutrin anxiety go away cozaar tablets us online side effects of cialis overdose inderal patient reviews flagyl 500mg for dogs what is bupropion prescribed for best generic altace review will robaxin make you gain weight stromectol tablet sale how to get cheap accutane piracetam uk shop where can i get some olanzapine side effects of tamoxifen for breast cancer zyvox online discount bupropion ships from india does cozaar cause fatigue transdermal delivery of aspirin kamagra gold delivery prednisolone online no prescription purchase metoclopramide 10mg neurontin tablets 150 mg nomika minocycline 100 mg cheap hydrea no prescription drugstore makeup coupons 2012 what is ashwagandha used for rocaltrol dosage administration cymbalta withdrawal symptoms list discount prilosec generic how to use abortion pills misoprostol cytotec no prescription motilium sale orlistat prescription free coreg medicine side effects ramicomp genericon seroflo tablets price lamictal online pharmacy shipped to canada nitroglycerin dosage for chest pain non prescription dulcolax bupron sr online cheap buy brand advair diskus no prescription fast delivery nitrofurantoin prices usa glycomet online pay paypal hyaluronic acid legal in england canadian prescription valacyclovir hcl 1 side effects indocin dosage for pericarditis what are neurontin tablets used for how to take maxalt orally disintegrating chloramphenicol uk buy what does suprax treat baclofen prescription only colospa online shipping viagra 100mg uk price buy generic venlor online discount canadian pharmacy finpecia luvox on line in the india comprar hyaluronic acid original what does lithium and water make diclofenac sodium side effects drowsiness uk version of elavil buy protonix without a prescription from canadian pharmacy purchase alesse cheap can you get high off gabapentin 300mg order prednisone 5mg non prescription atorlip-20 allegra 60 mg price buy brand viagra singapore celexa order by phone recommended dosage of benadryl for dogs como comprar cialis en mexico canadian drug policy alliance azithromycin zithromax side effects best price for real femara no prescription lariam l-tryptophan prix en pharmacie en france what is clomiphene 50 mg requip order canada clomiphene citrate success stories testosterone lipitor discount card pfizer cost of keppra without insurance canadian alliance of student associations 2010 casa can you split imitrex tablets pfizer coupon zyvox online my cardizem coupons best place to buy tretinoin 0,025 how to get accutane without insurance order brand levitra online in usa can i buy allegra d over the counter lioresal sale where to buy liver detox furosemide brand name uk cheap proventil india purchase cozaar 50mg online terbinafine hydrochloride side effects buy flonase generic viagra 25mg vs 50mg aspirin for men in usa ortho tri cyclen pills buy purchase generic moduretic female viagra online canada ginseng mail order india cordarone direct pharmacy forzest 100mg cheap best online pharmacy generic neurontin viagra in canada online no prescription canadian pharmacy paypal purchase drugs online canada intermittent fasting insulin sensitivity acquisto diovan sicuro online medrol 4mg pak xeloda 500mg tablet purchasing rumalaya forte online uk stats group careers can i buy cialis over the counter uk acai in croatia what is urispas 200 how to order imuran pharmacy drugs that can kill health canada dutas order viagra sublingual generic equivalent for cardizem cd bactroban mg buy premarin in usa hoodia in the uk now where can i buy aciclovir half price voveran atacand pill shortage acheter levaquin how much will etodolac cost where to get nizoral in canada medication online without cheap cholestoplex side effects of cephalexin in breast milk zovirax legal us pfizer zithromax wiki lioresal 25 mg baclofen minocycline pills online in the usa buy eldepryl no prescription noroxin australia pharmacy erection packs 1 drugs where to buy cialis soft drugs online buying lisonopril no prescription maximum safe dosage of nexium purchase generic femcare seroflo inhaler 125 side effects antabuse rx ampicillin drug classification online pharmacy no prescription needed plavix cheap atacand 32mg baclofen usa buy hydrochlorothiazide next day generic lamictal paypal prednisone side effects in children hyperactivity nizoral birth control online australia zanaflex abuse vasotec refill pack buy viagra over the counter 2010 cheap mobic online prescription cheap prescription zyvox oxycodone online pharmacy no prescription needed zofran zydis what is actonel dr como se llama el viagra para mujer what does allopurinol contain viagra super active uk sale can u buy hoodia over the counter valtrex mg order what is apo-azithromycin 250 mg used for flomax dose for kidney stones generic lipitor release date november can you buy dipyridamole in ireland 100 mg voltaren is there a generic for hydrochlorothiazide lexapro weight gain studies flovent prix en pharmacie en france xenical generic canada pharmacy is lexapro generic the same as lexapro where to sinemet mail order diamox buy blopress online overnight online pharmacy zestril citalopram hydrobromide tablets and alcohol where to buy lincocin buying celadrin using paypal discount inderal mg advair diskus purchase in canada no prescription order innopran xl overnight tesco car insurance login where is the cheapest place to buy alli diet pills slimming can order diovan canada ponstel roche precio argentina generic from zofran buy malegra fxt paypal accepted digoxin to buy in the usa without a prescription allegra dosage for children by weight what does phenergan do to you piracetam dosage teaspoon ordering lopid usa cheapest place to buy zyrtec pharmacy buy gasex tablets online maxifort zimax sildenafil purchasing proscar online where to buy hoodia chaser in canada zyprexa from europe micardis generic for where can i get some furosemide finasteride generico espan~a 2010 fosamax shopping is zoloft generic protonix women buy buy imuran online reviews brahmi medicine tadapox online forum order bentyl from usa without prescription como comprar viagra en mexico buy grifulvin v discount prescription drug diovan zyvox lawsuit canada prednisolone buy without benzac ac cream price in india order silagra on line mexico order acivir pills medication by mail can we trust floxin online voltaren sr 75 mg 20 tablet doxycycline canada drug store cardura sale western drug himplasia geriforte syrup dose online forum cod buy prednisolone side effects of suhagra 50 pills aceon tablets from buy cabgolin prix en pharmacie en france bupron sr uk buy cicloferon spray dosis erexin-v reviews for men prescriptions from canada without scripts meds india review depakote brand vs generic weight gain with crestor use prescription without a doctor how long does accutane take to work generic lisinopril tablets best price for real risperdal is tricor generic available cheap presscription propecia canada where can i get levaquin pills donde puedo comprar lindeza orlistat lanoxin uk next day delivery what are the side effects of taking aspirin buy over the counter compazine online flonase from canada nitroglycerin spray india buy mobic mexican pharmacies buy gabapentin overnight purchasing effexor online what is glimepiride prescribed for overnight valtrex viagra cialis and levitra compare canadian family physician salary canadian pharmacy remeron methotrexate 2.5mg tablets cheap metformin no prescription malaria medication chloroquine side effects order cialis super active on line mexico cheap amaryllis for sale order plavix 75mg tablets buyers of depakote canada zovirax where can i buy it can you order beconase aq nasal polyps order citalopram medication by mail ranitidine 150 mg/10 ml oral solution buy brand advair diskus for daily use user reviews on zoloft kamagra gold online usa no prescription sildenafilo teva 100 mg naprosyn brands india non prescription fincar pharmacy clomiphene citrate for men fertility z pack 5 day dose pack instructions lasix now co uk viagra kgr 100 ap orlistat pharmacy medicine alli weight loss drug side effects online pharmacy with echeck lexapro 10mg for anxiety online buy alli diet pills kytril pills drugstore good drugstore makeup brands tenormin generic for how much does aricept 23 mg cost buy midamor bulk how to treat allopurinol rash diflucan reviews for men buy prednisone pills in the us buy lipitor boots line no prescription cheap levitra mexican pharmacy buy hoodia online no prescription united states buy tetracycline capsules bayer aspirin class action lawsuit us online pharmacy no prescription tadalis sx online pharmacy no prescription needed paxil order suprax 120 mg finasteride tablets ip 5mg for what cheap lisinopril india buy viagra 200 lipitor 10mg price usa can order nymphomax canada synthroid 40mg non prescription heartworm medicine for dogs neurontin capsules pictures keppra online overnight order amoxil from usa without prescription methotrexate pregnancy side effects albendazole to buy exelon low cost where do i buy water pills sleeping medication trazodone side effects costa allegra costa cruises buy orlistat online amazon florida acticin buy clomiphene citrate australia order apcalis sx overnight how to order online cheap robaxin average cost of detrol order tretinoin 0,025 online provera prescription only zovirax dosage recommended xeloda capsules buy over the counter detrol online what is the recommended dosage of viagra liv 52 sold over counter increasing libido women levitra sales online pill where is ranitidine metabolized buy zestoretic visa generic name for mestinon viagra boots manchester cipro antibiotic doxycycline purchase dilantin pills estrace order compare prices aricept prevacid discount card combivent canadian online mirapex side effects restless legs liv 52 discount vytorin medication where to buy buy eldepryl online order metformin 500 mg alesse review 2012 chloroquine purchase online pastillas para la ereccion prolongada norco sight 2 2013 buy revatio in singapore pradaxa coumadin cost buy aspirin with codeine discount order aceon pharmacy seroflo 125 mg keppra without rx over the counter geriforte where to buy generic zyrtec d prescription buying diclofenac gel is it legal to buy antibiotics from canada how long do champix take to work buy online differin generic where to get levaquin beat way to order chloroquine cheap diclofenac 40 mg 1 internet online drugstore cheap generic retin-a ge anafranil tablets side effects levitra sales uk cheap genuine mentat online retin a online uk on line pharmacy celebrex buy lopid 80 mg online antivert no prescription mail-order elimite metformin sale no prescription purchasing nymphomax online hytrin tablet sale dipyridamole ships from india comprar diltiazem gel best online pharmacy to buy phentermine proventil over the counter india septilin italiano no prescription mexico pharmacies aciclovir dosage recommended gyne-lotrimin reviews for men orlistat pills online does propecia help purchase abana online emsam 100mg buy buy beconase aq boots is neurontin over the counter how much motilium to take for breastfeeding list of top 50 pharmaceutical companies in india 2012 generic luvox for sale on line ginseng costco benicar hct price comparison generic lamisil paypal how to use bactrim ds cheap buy antivert overnight what is atrovent used for in asthma is prednisone for humans the same as prednisone for dogs canada pharmacies that sell sildenafil tetracycline 50mg tablets mexico viagra online order zovirax tablets safe to buy generic tenormin from canada ventolin from uk cheapest viagra melbourne side effects of alesse mood swings can clonidine hydrochloride get you high pom pomegranate juice cheap kamagra chewable uk hoodia online uk tv live in italia crestor rosuvastatin 20 mg tablets best avodart price nootropil 800 costo secure tabs customer reviews celebrex without insurance super active overnight delivery professional cialis soft buy prednisolone buy ceftin online uk no prescription brand levitra wanted online review abilify 10 mg tablets order diclofenac 50mg lov cost strattera paroxetine free shipping accutane dosage mild acne unisom sleepgels 50mg reviews diltiazem non perscription countries buy cheap evista pills what is keflex for dogs benicar hct without prescription flagyl er suppositories buy epivir-hbv uk next day delivery albendazole buy without proventil hfa package insert what kind of infections does biaxin treat dizziness medication antivert fluoxetine buy online mexico generic glycomet uk paypal kamagra gold shoppers drug mart cheap augmentin us topic generic lotrisone paypal purchase protonix on line in mexico online sale of robaxin qsymia uk tenormin no prescription needed side effects of blood pressure medication in men claritin online legally alesse tablets 40mg generic asacol usa gabapentin dosage rxlist canadian pharmacy without prescriptions cheap stromectol 6mg where to buy alligator clips for bow making online pharmacy uk crestor generic bactrim ds tablets can you buy omnicef over the counter paxil anxiety medication side effects is it illegal to order generic ethionamide buy permethrin cream 5 no prescription order valtrex no prescription what does a benicar tablet look like minocin dosage acne what does generic prilosec look like pfizer viagra 50mg price ciprofloxacin uses for orlistat from china buy tetracycline eye ointment lipothin reviews for men online pharmacy no prescription needed acivir pills roxithromycin how to buy minocin no prescription ordering viagra from online pharmacy ordering remeron here in canada ordering levitra professional pill 10mg does the rxrelief card really work glucophage from europe diovan medicine buy citalopram online amazon valacyclovir 1000 mg price natural viagra pills aristocort cream side effects thyroxine weight loss side effects diclofenac dosering zetpil buying zanaflex in manchester aceon shortage levothroid drugstore.com what is trental viagra professional shelf life why does maxalt cost so much can you get valtrex in the uk benzac dose buy himplasia in india online generic viagra best price tamoxifen mechanism of action powerpoint watch online cricket ind vs pak coumadin drug class alli 10 mg cost minocycline price india rank the intermolecular forces in order from weakest to strongest antivert tablets uk pharmacy buy drugs dostinex ashwagandha india organic how to buy cheap abortion pill online buy decadron from canada medrol online in uk artane no prescription canada erythromycin 250 mg dosage rosuvastatin drug schedule buy cymbalta online no prescription how to get cialis soft on line keppra bonus pills valsartan 80 mg in india asacol order canada cyclobenzaprine flexeril wiki buying anafranil from canada no prescription why has furosemide been discontinued paxil no prescription compare prices online casodex purchase decadron 0.5 mg-bula tetracycline 500mg side effects hydrochlorothiazide without prescription medication order prevacid overnight buy over the counter zantac online real viagra online canadian pharmacy can buy viagra tesco donde comprar alli mas barato discount canadian pharmacy asacol indian advair diskus generic buy alli uk boots pharmacy online buying metoclopramide using paypal birth control pills depakote can you buy viagra over the counter in china sildenafil how to use capoten glycomet gp1 price discount code for viagra plus neurontin 300 mg street price chloroquine cost comparison accutane before and after back buy tretinoin cream .1 online fluoxetine reviews for ocd prescription valtrex s patient reviews on remeron tetracycline 500 mg discontinued asacol mail order order generic retin-a 0,05 cipro peak sales buy mevacor online india new price of viagra in canada better than kamagra chewable torsemide for purchase baby aspirin uk what does viagra do to men who don;t need it cost of bupropion xl what is iv lasix for indications for florinef acetate buy viagra in shanghai cleocin weight gain reglan by mail how to buy zyvox in london order protonix cheap pill rx health nizagara products minocycline for sale australia canadian online pharmacy for betnovate buy duphalac boots pharmacy how to take zithromax tri pak acheter snovitra super power pas cher buy online cheap generic arimidex acai berry shelf life levitra to buy in the uk without a prescription buy generic viagra overnight shipping best price lasix what is colchicine used to treat aceon for sale usa cheap astelin uk flagyl and pregnancy side effects augmentin price in dubai strong vigra buy lortab 5 high casodex spc benicar in usa where to get live scan fingerprints suprax overnight order nizoral from mexico without prescription over the counter benadryl 25 mg order aspirin online with visa buy kamagra oral jelly without rx viramune refills where to buy cheap generic prednisolone meclizine generic 2013 drugs apcalis sx order canada non generic accutane colchicine costco chlamydia symptoms men abdominal pain quickest buy benicar delivery cvs pharmacy 1010 lake street adderall online pharmacy canada brand name plavix online what does zyprexa cost famciclovir tablets side effects finax where to get ordering low dose terramycin benadryl for sale usa terramycin online forum no prescription cheap buy avalide brand name prilosec online rabeprazole domperidone mode of action blopress shortage 2012 celebrex order online voltaren xr dosing drug market order prednisolone safe buy urispas online side effects of fluoxetine 40 mg drug market order depakote cialis mail canada betoptic over counter uk buy bentyl cheap prescription venlor tablets 75mg best generic minocycline sites passion rx buy online buy propecia boots pharmacy buy coumadin for daily use how to take suhagra 100mg buy aldactone online reviews canada buy orlistat without prescription lov cost prednisone flomist nasal drop buy lanoxin 200 online alprazolam no prescription how to get pain meds for kidney stones cephalexin online usa singulair prix en pharmacie en france pharmacy rx 1 reviews is generic synthroid as good as name brand zovirax tab 400 mg how much is casodex tablets pfiser cheap genuine zerit online purchase non drowsy dramamine buy atacand 100mg online clarithromycin buy genuine voveran uk myambutol for men in usa buy avalide cheap irbesartan blood pressure hcg nolvadex and clomid pct safe place order rumalaya buy levaquin bulk provera tablets to stop bleeding sildenafil citrate 100mg pills canada where to buy cheap generic lariam lok adalat cases dramamine chewable reviews metronidazole 200mg dosage buy original viagra online furosemide woldwide shipping
الرئيسية | النادي اللغوي | بحوث نحوية | المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود

صفحة شبكة صوت العربية في فيسبوكtwitterقناة شبكة صوت العربية في يوتيوبشبكة صوت العربية في موقع فليكر

المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود طباعة إرسال إلى صديق
تصنيفات: بحوث نحوية
تقييم المستخدمين: / 54
الكاتب أحمد مجرشي   
الأحد, 10 أبريل 2011 20:07

النشأة :
سيقودنا الحديث عن نشأة هذا المصطلح إلى الحديث عن مناهج النحويين واختلاف آرائهم في الأصول والفروع وهل يرقى هذا الاختلاف لتتميز منه مذاهب ومدارس لها حدود واضحة المعالم أم إن الخلاف يقف عند الفروع لا يتجاوزها فلا يستحق أن يطلع عليها مدرسة أم إنه أقل من ذلك فهو مذهب واحد وطريقة ؟ واحدة تختلف بعض فروعها اختلافا يسيرا داخل نطاق المنهج ولا يخرج عنه .

وقبل التفصيل في هذه المسائل ينبغي أن نعرف إجمالا أن موضوع التقسيم مر بثلاث مراحل هي :

الأولى : تسمية العلماء بأمصارهم وبلدانهم مما يوحي بوجود مذهب خاص بهم أو لا يوحي بذلك .
الثانية : تقسيم مناهجهم وطرقهم وتسميتها بـ " مذهب " وهي مرحلة تالية للمرحلة السابقة .
الثالثة : إطلاق اسم " مدرسة " على المذهب أو على أهل الأمصار وهذه التسمية أطلقت حديثا في الوقت المعاصر.
و بيان ذلك على النحو التالي :

أولا :
"يتضح لنا من عرض مناهج الذين أرخوا للنحو والنحاة من القدماء أنهم اتبعوا في ترتيبهم نسبتهم للبلد الذي ظهروا فيه وتعلموا نحوه ودرسوه أو درّسوه فهم بصريون وكوفيون وأهل بغداد"(1).
"وأول من يلقنا من القدماء محمد بن سلام الجمحي ( 139-231هـ) الذي قال :" وكان لأهل البصرة في العربية قدامة وبالنحو ولغات العرب والغريب عناية "(2).
وترجم لأبي الأسود الدؤلي وعدّه مؤسس علم العربية وليحيى بن يعمر ولعبدالله بن إسحاق الحضرمي ولأبي عمرو بن العلاء وانتهى بالخليل بن أحمد الفراهيدي ولم ينسبهم إلى مدرسة وإنما عدهم من أهل البصرة (3).
وأعقبه أبو محمد عبدالله بن مسلم بن قتيبة الدينوري ( 213 – 276 هـ ) الذي عقد في كتابه "المعارف" بحثا لرواة الشعر وأصحاب الغريب والنحو وترجم بإيجاز لمعظم من اشتهر بهذه العلوم من البصريين والكوفيين ... ويلاحظ في ترجمته لهم أنه لم يذكرهم مقسمين إلى بصريين وكوفيين معتمدا على شهرتهم ولم يسمهم بمذهب أو مدرسة (4).
وجاء بعدهما أبو الطيب عبدالواحد بن علي اللغوي الحلبي ( ت 351هـ ) وألف كتاب "مراتب النحويين" ورتبه حسب الزمن مبتدئا بالبصريين لأن النحو في البصرة كان أقدم نشوءا منه في الكوفة ... وكانت أول إشارة إلى الكوفة عند ترجمته لأبي جعفر الرؤاسي حيث قال : وممن أخذ عن أبي عمرو أبو جعفر الرؤاسي عالم الكوفة (5).
والدليل على أنهم كانوا ينسبون النحاة إلى البلد ويذكرونه في ترجمتهم بحسب البلدان أن أبا الطيب ختم كتابه بعد الانتهاء من ذكر البصريين والكوفيين بقوله :" ولا علم للعرب إلا في هاتين المدينتين "(6).

ثانيا :
كان أبو بكر محمد بن الحسن الزبيدي ( ت 379هـ ) أول من استخدم كلمة " مذهب " عندما ترجم لأصحاب ثعلب فقال عن أبي موسى الحامض : " كان بارعا في اللغة والنحو على مذهب الكوفيين "(7)
"وقال عن ابن كيسان وكان بصريا كوفيا يحفظ القولين ويعرف المذهبين وكان أخذ عن ثعلب والمبرد وكان ميله إلى مذهب البصريين أكثر ... وكان أبو بكر ابن الأنباري شديد التعصب على ابن كيسان والتنقص له وكان يقول : خلط فلم يضبط مذهب الكوفيين ولا مذهب البصريين"(8).

ومن هنا يتضح أن الزبيدي كان أول من قسم النحاة إلى مجموعات بحسب البلدان التي عرفوا بها وكان أول من استخدم عبارات "مذهب الكوفيين" و "مذهب البصريين" و "المذهبين" ويريد بذلك أن النحو متابع
لآراء نحاة الكوفة أو لآراء نحاة البصرة أو لنحاة المدينتين(9).
وجاء بعده ابن النديم· (ت 385 هـ ) واتبع التقسيم نفسه إلا أنه سمى نحاة بغداد " من خلط المذهبين " (10).
وبعدهما جاء أبو البركات الأنباري ( ت 577 هـ ) فقد اتبع في كتابه "نزهة الألباء في طبقات الأدباء" التسلسل الزمني ولم يذكر كلمة مذهب إلى مع البغداديين في الغالب كقوله : " وكان يخلط المذهبين " أو " وكان قيما بمذهب البصريين والكوفيين "(11).

ثالثا :
استحسن الباحثون المحدثون مصطلح "المدرسة" بمعنى المذهب النحوي وقد كانوا في ذلك متأثرين بالغربيين الذين شاع عندهم هذا المصطلح بهذا المفهوم ونجاحه في الدراسات الأدبية فكان عندهم المدرسة الكلاسيكية في الأدب والفن والمدرسة الرومانتيكية والمدرسة الرمزية(12).
وكان من أوائل من استخدم هذا المصطلح "جوتولد فايل" الذي سماهما المدرسة البصرية والمدرسة الكوفية وتبعه في ذلك "بروكلمان" الذي قال : " وقد قسم علماء العربية مذاهب النحو إلى ثلاث مدارس : البصريين والكوفيين ومن مزجوا المذهبين من علماء بغداد "(13).
واستخدم المحدثون الكلمة نفسها ولعل الدكتور مهدي المخزومي أول من تبنى هذه التسمية فسمى أحد كتبه "مدرسة الكوفة ومنهجها في دراسة اللغة والنحو" وألف الدكتور شوقي ضيف كتابا سماه "المدارس النحوية" وألف الدكتور عبدالرحمن السيد كتابا سماه "مدرسة البصرة النحوية (14).

مفهوم المذهب والمدرسة :
1 - مفهوم المذهب النحوي :
المذهب مصطلح فقهي في بداية نشأته فيقال مذهب الإمام الشافعي أو الإمام مالك أو مذهب شيخنا ... وانتقل إلى اللغة حيث أصبح يعبر عن مجموعة مبادئ وآراء متصلة ومنسقة لمفكر ما أو لاتجاه ما .
وفي التعريف النحوي الدقيق هو : طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد تعتنق مذهبا نحويا وتقول برأي نحوي مشترك وتجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع (15).

2 - مفهوم المدرسة النحوية :
بعد الحديث عن تطور مسمى المناهج النحوية وطرق النحويين لعل الوقت قد حان للحديث عن مفهوم المدرسة عند المتأخرين .
فقد عرف المعجم الوسيط مصطلح المدرسة - بهذا المفهوم الجديد - بقوله :" المدرسة جماعة من الفلاسفة والمفكرين أو الباحثين تعتنق مذهبا معينا أو تقول برأي مشترك "(16).
وعند المتأخرين تعريفات كثيرة للمدرسة وكلها تدور حول هذا المعنى وسنستعرض فيما يلي بعضها .
عرف "جوتولد فايل" المدرس بأنها : "الاشتراك في وجهة النظر الذي يؤلف الجبهة العلمية ويربط العلماء بعضهم ببعض على رأي واحد "(17).
والأستاذ على النجدي ناصف يعرف المدرسة بقوله :" المدرسة طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد أو الفن الواحد تجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم العلمية وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع والتفاصيل ".
وعرفها الدكتور أحمد مكي الأنصاري بقوله :" اتجاه له خصائص مميزة ينادي بها فرد أو جماعة من الناس ثم ينادي بها آخرون ".
على حين يعرفها الدكتور مهدي الخزمومي بقوله :" فليست المدرسة إلا أستاذا مؤثرا وتلاميذ متأثرين وقد اجتمعوا على تحقيق غرض موحد نهجوا للوصول إليه منهاجا "(18).
قال ذلك في مدرسة الكوفة عند كلامه على الكسائي إذ قال :" إن الكسائي بمنهاجه وأساليب دراسته مدرسة لها خصائصها ومناهجها فليست المدرسة إلا ..." ثم ساق التعريف .
وقريب من هذا التعريف ما انتهى إليه الدكتور أحمد مختار عمر وهو قوله :" وجود جماعة من النحاة يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج في دراسة النحو ولابد أن يكون هناك الرائد الذي يرسم الخطة ويحدد المنهج والتابعون أو المريدون الذين يعتنقون خطاه ويتبنون منهجه ويعملون على تطويره والدفاع عنه (19).
وقد أخذ محمد حسين آل ياسين في كتاب "الدراسات اللغوية" بتعريف "جوتولد فايل" حيث يقول:" المدرسة في المصطلح العلمي لفظ يطلع على جماعة من الدارسين تشترك في وجهة النظر ويكون لها نهج خاص يؤلف منها جبهة علمية ويربط أفرادها برابط الرأي الموحد "(20).
وقد حاول الدكتور صالح بلعيد الجمع بين التعريفات السابقة فقال إن المدرسة :" كلمة معاصرة تعني الجماعة الذي يشكلون درسا واحدا في بيئة معينة أو بيئات معينة متعددة ويجمعهم نهج واحد أو الاشتراك في وجهة النظر التي تؤلف جبهة علمية واحدة ووجود الجماعة الذي يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج ويكون اتفاقهم على الأصول لا الفروع وعلى رأس المدرسة من يرسم الخطة ويحدد والمنهج وهو الشيخ أو الرئيس والمريدون الذي يعتنقون خطاه ويعملون على تطويرها الدفاع عنه "(21).
ونلاحظ أن هذا إلى التوصيف أقرب منه إلى التعريف حيث جمع ما في التعريفات الأخرى وضمنها هذا التوصيف .
ونخلص مما سبق إلى أن هذه التعريفات تتفق على وجود جماعة من الناس يعتنقون منهجا محددا ذا خصائص ومميزات يؤمنون به ويدافعون عنه وإن لم تجمعهم وحدة جغرافية ولا يشترط الاتفاق على الفروع بل يكفي اتفاقهم على أصول المنهج .
والتعريفات السابقة بهذا المعنى أو قريبة منه جدا ، ولذا نلاحظ أنها بدأت بـ :" جماعة " أو " طائفة " وبدأت أحيانا بـ :" الاشتراك في وجهة نظر " أو " اتجاه له خصائص " وهما – الجماعة والمنهج – الركنان الأساسيان في التعريفات السابقة .
هل توجد مذاهب نحوية أو مدارس نحوية ؟
أولا : المذاهب النحوية
جرى الأقدمون على أن هناك مذهبا في النحو يسمى المذهب البصري ومذهبا آخر في النحو يسمى المذهب الكوفي كما ذكرت بعض مؤلفات الأقدمين أن هناك نحاة مصريين ونحاة أندلسيين (22).

ثانيا : المدارس النحوية
تعددت آراء الباحثين المحدثين في المدارس النحوية بين الإثبات والرفض على ما يأتي :

الرأي الأول :
أنه لا توجد مدارس نحوية إطلاقا وإنما هي تجمعات جغرافية ولا يوجد مدارس نحوية تتميز كل منها بأسلوبها الخاص ومنهاجها الذاتي وتطبق هذه المجموعات أصولا واحدة وإن اختلفت في الفروع وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ سعيد الأفغاني والأستاذ على أبو المكارم (23).

الرأي الثاني :
أنه لا توجد إلا مدرسة نحوية واحدة هي مدرسة البصرة فقط وأنكر هذا الفريق وجود مدرسة الكوفة وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ الدكتور إبراهيم السامرائي وقد سبقه إلى القول بهذا "جوتولد فايل" (24).

الرأي الثالث :
أثبت فريق ثالث من النحويين وجود مدرستين بصرية وكوفية وتردد في القبول بوجود مدرسة بغدادية ويمثل هذا القول الدكتور مهدي المخزومي ، وقد تابعوا في ذلك الزبيدي في طبقاته حيث نظم أفراد المدرسة البغدادية مع رجال المدرسة البصرية والكوفية على حسب اتجاهه وميوله(25).
وما قيل في المدرسة البغدادية ينطبق على بقية المدارس كالأندلسية والمصرية.

الترجيح بين الآراء :
إذا دققنا النظر في الأوصاف التي يطلقها القدماء على الدراسات النحوية غير البصرية والكوفية وجدناها لا تخرج عن وصف هذه الدراسات أو الدارسين لأنهم خلطوا المذهبين أو النحوين أو مزجوا بينهما وهذا يدعونا إلى أنه ليس هناك خلاف بين هذا النحو والنحوين الآخرين خلافا لما نراه من الفروق بين منهجي البصرة والكوفة .
وهذا ينتهي بنا إلى القول بأنه ليس في النحو العربي إلا مدرستان أو مذهبان فقط هما البصرة والكوفة (26).
(1)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي ص / 13 بتصرف .
(2)· نقلته عن : طبقات فحول الشعراء 1 / 12
(3)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 7 بتصرف .
(4)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(5)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(6)· المرجع السابق· ص / 10
(7)· نقلته عنه : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170
(8)· نلقته عن : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170-171
(9)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 11
(10)· المرجع السابق· ص / 11
(11)· المرجع السابق· ص / 12
(12)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(13)· نقلته عن : تاريخ الأدب العربي· 2 / 124 – 125
(14)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 13
(15)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 144
(16)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(17) المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(18)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(19)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(20)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(21)· المرجع السابق· ص / 149 – 150
(22)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 145
(23)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 151 نقله عن طبقات الزبيدي· ص / 213 – 253
(24)· أنظر مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د.عبدالله الخثران والمدارس النحوي د. خديجة الحديثي .
(25)· المرجعان السابقان والمدارس النحوية أسطورة وواقع د. إبراهيم السامرائي ص / 139 – 141
(26)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 16
أحمد بن محمد مجرشي
طالب ماجستير قسم النحو والصرف وفقه اللغة

Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack