haridra order where can i buy metformin tablets i want to pay some cardura where to get disulfiramum pct generic trial erection packs 1 for sale on line generic for aricept venlor discount erection packs 2 low cost free or low cost famvir purchase lipothin mg duprost mg mexico bupropion cost canada generic keflex for sale on line is there a generic version of prometrium what bacteria does zyvox cover purchase lansoprazol on line in usa glucovance supplier in uk how to buy phenamax in london procardia fast mexico ajanta pharma kamagra price usa buy nolvadex without prescription generic flagyl er us buy generic endep online with prescription amlodipine besylate 5mg price comparison how long does depakote stay in your system after you stop taking it trimox drug in mexico pharmacy can i get lortrisone cream without a prescription canadian pharmacy bystolic floxin for sale philippines purinethol tablets online side effects of taking benadryl long term ampicillin drug facts beat way to order cleocin long time side effects emsam side effects of erythromycin antibiotics trial erection packs 3 generic 2013 drugs celapram no prescription overnight delivery carafate canadian pharmacy ventolin without prescription canada topamax tablets non persciption mestinon amitriptyline dosage dose tadalafila cialis oder mg tablets of cialis sublingual buy citalopram in canada online pharmacy cialis zetia cheap finasteride 1mg tablets india lioresal reviews for men cheap dostinex pills generic from kamagra purchase amlodipinbesilat online no prescription anafranil delivery london best place to order aricept in us medazole mg no prescription how to get eldepryl drug can you buy dutasterid over the counter in germany capoten to buy in the uk without a prescription accutane generico italiano what is the generic name for effexor xr is metronidazole over the counter cialis professional online pharmacy buy novo digoxin online no prescription canada etodolac for purchase without a prescription can we trust tadapox online where to buy cheap generic fluconazol zyban no prescription needed order eurax online no prescription with a amex how to buy actoplus zithromax z pak for sale 150 mg viagra for sale purchasing cabaser online zitromax supplier in uk trazodone price india duphalac online pay paypal acnetane to buy in england mircette perth australia duphalac pharmacy non prescription methotrexate pharmacy hoodia fast usa side effects of dulcolax suppository best place to buy citalopram toenail fungus medicine lamisil clomid from china order flonase pill what is micardis side effects mometasona cheapest rate flovent spain post cycle therapy tadalis sx can order aciclovir online depression and anxiety medication symptoms how to buy altace in canada clonidine annual sales of approximately ordering fucidin canada flovent coupon discount how long to use lotrisone evista buy online india best price for real erythromycin allopurinol rash pictures terramycin mg mexico mentat from mexico best way get high off pain pills brand cialis purchase zitromax to buy lady era in the uk brahmi generic cheap costs order buy doxazosin online where can i buy furosemide mg colospa drugstore com pricing uk pharmacies online that sell orlistato micardis mg india where to buy cheap generic myambutol american pamelor how much is azurette tablets how often to take aleve cold and sinus oder mg tablets of accuran ordering florinef on line malegra dxt online canadian buy risperdal online no prescription usa cotrim kaufen ohne rezept viagra super active plus online oristal pills online in the mexico can you get high off hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg buy viagra pfizer online no prescription kamagra soft reviews purchase grifulvin v in us propecia side effects liver enzymes cytotec costo df costco pharmacy microzide price lopressor birth control online india rx europe drug pharmacy levaquin 500 mg tabletas para sirve best flunil prices levoxyl usa tetracycline phone orders walgreens discount drugs program beat way to order cialis jelly canada nexium tablets online can you get high off paroxetine 20mg rogain buy bentyl mexican pharmacies where to buy amitriptyline online canada western drug precose generic uk paypal orlistar order cleocin gel on line usa online prescriptions australia how long does strattera 40 mg last most trusted online pharmacies usa levothroid daily use reviews dostinex on line no script zaditor with american express thyrohormone fast india crushing carafate tablets prezzo cialis in farmacia italiana ordering claritin d disulphiram for sale buy robaxin tablets mexico canadian online pharmacy cipa celexa mg tablet nizoral cream storage buy generic c ratioph online no prescription buy albenza online ireland vpxl lawsuit settlements lamictal 50mg tablet order orlistar from usa without prescription levitra super active buy online ireland eldepryl without a prescription from mexico buy carbozyne uk para que se usa doxycycline hyclate hydrochlorothiazide api manufacturers in india desyrel 3days delivery maxalt canada companies only generic wellbutrin best price for cialis 5 mg online vpxl drug in canada pharmacy safe norvasc no precription female viagra to buy in the uk without a prescription buy robaxin no prescription fast delivery generic for lasix vpxl cost in canada unprescribed clomid pregnant canadian pharmacy evecare natural fertility drugs for men free or low cost paxil metformin glucophage contraindications purchase ginseng lowest price buy phexin overseas viagra on sale uk nitrofurantoin birth control online us anafranil to buy in england buy emoquette greece online amoxicilina india canadian stat holidays family day fosamax class action lawsuit 2010 viagra plus prescriptions trial erection packs 2 online with out prescription colchicine women buy bisoprololi fumaras order in the us prevacid rx dosage overnight pharmacy alli discount best site to buy liposafe bactrim ds for cystic acne trileptal over the counter australia abana generic wikipedia drugs cipro prescription coupon canadian online pharmacy that accepts american express gift card betnovate on line in the uk retino a cream 0,025 not generic rythmol sr order tadalafil cipla recipe for liquid viagra drink buy cialis professional no prescription fast delivery best prices prescriptions canada buy eldepryl 50 where to buy tadacip online mexico buy haldol discount buspar for anxiety dosage phd in pharmacy practice in canada norvasc high blood pressure medicine buy viagra gold online order antivert medication by mail where can i purchase doxycycline yasmin mg mexico predalone usa sale can i buy cilest in canada viagra soft cheap us pharmacy aloprim pharmacy order alli availability issues cheap doxazosin mg cheap amoxil pills what does seroquel do to your brain buy zenegra 100 how to take disulphiram mg genuine styplon best price z pack 5 day dose pack dosage costco pharmacy haldol price buy priligy online is it safe to order levlen purinethol over counter purchase rosuvastatin on line in uk when is crestor going generic in canada viagra online same day delivery rosuvastatin pharmacy cymbalta overnight delivery paroxetine seroxat side effects purchase tindamax on line in uk radio 1 dance anthems augmentin drug in germany pharmacy buy elimite uk where can i buy actoplus online without a prescription nitroglycerin dosage angina define percocet cost of clomid uk aleve us companies only why has metocarbamol been discontinued maxalt online from india nimotop prescriptions online levaquin india how to buy cilais safe to buy generic serophene from canada long term side effects of colchicina buy meclizine pills in the australia cardura dosage too high generic eldepryl canada buy acyclovir cream boots mexico pharmacy buy metoclopramide reglan online doxycycline overnight delivery best tretinoin 0 05 prices lincocin how to buy purchase albuterol online no prescription aspirin online sales purchase salbumol in mexico buy celexa online from india cytotec refills tizanidinum drug in germany pharmacy can we trust seroflo online what is pfizer vgr 100 why has tegretol been discontinued generic plavix canadian pharmacy xenical reviews meal shoppers drug mart canada post holiday hours zedd canada overnight delivery what does augmentin 875 cure buy sildenafil citrate india is epivir hbv available over the counter betnovate ointment to buy to buy leukeran in uk how to buy drugs online from canada caverta mg buy seroquel online pharmacy canada no prescription orlistar buy online ireland buy generic fertomid with bonus nexium refills v gel without subscription prevacid 40 mg side effects bactrim for purchase cialis on line buy oxytrol shop net aygestin online usa no prescription how to buy toradol safe to buy generic lotrel from usa doxycycline 10 mg eutirox 75 dimagrire costco pharmacy sepibest price pak online newspapers over the counter blog buy allopurinol buy generic azithromycin online genuine prednisolone 100mg where to purchase l tryptophan does alli work buy online weight loss pills dosage for premarin cream fertomid generic reviews cialis online meds riperdal prescription only prometrium for dogs buy triamterenum drug in uk pharmacy can u buy viagra in uk rythmol sr australia companies only arimidex maximum dosage caprysin usa no prescription augmentin 625 duo india how to buy betnovate online can you only get rogaine 5 on prescription lexapro with no rx licensed pharmacy levitra plus where do they sale viagra how to buy protonix in canada frumil discount code no prescription minipress sale when to start clomid steroids how to import zenegra is tinidazole over the counter no prescription diclofenac cephalexin to buy in england cheap canadian stromectol no prescription western drug seasonique acquisto dutas sicuro online florida carbozyne accutane pharmaceutical company tetracycline 500mg buy klipal codeine buy online ireland zenegra side effects uk doksazosin lek online no prescription abilify bonus pills como comprar elimite fast diarex delivery order trandate on line canada bentyl online australia viagra soft canada all orders online buy online zovirax generic order synthroid canada online pharmacy bupropion xl snovitra super power over counter online duetact with no prescription celebrex dosage instructions order rumalaya gel overnight olanzapine usan aripiprazola prix en pharmacie en france premarin 1.25 mg tablet effexor xr maximum daily dose florida lotrel compazine noprescrition needed uk online pharmacy where to buy thyrohormone online without rx accutane purchase buy allegra without a script where can i get blopress pills safe to buy generic cialis from canada name brand mirapex online cymbalta legal us cheap keppra 40 mg cipla tadacip review precipitated calcium carbonate price india comprar flagyl er portugal buy prograf 10 liposafe no prescription canada the online drugstore eldepryl ordering female cialis canada para que se usa el paroxetine the chepest valaciclovir best drugstore mascara of 2012 mex select viagra products diabetes and viagra what works brand levitra spain online pharmacy uk mycelex g what is atorlip 10 used for mobic meloxicam ingredients glucotrol with no subscription brand name meclizine online non prescription seasonique can you order claritin drugs relief valtrex cost walgreens cheap retin a gel 0 1 delivered overnight generic lopid no prescription didronel sublingual dosage what are the side effects of celebrex 200 mg avapro 150 mg tablet digoxin on line in the mexico prometrium 200 mg. discount grifulvin v cost canadian albenza india sale buy generic florinef online no prescription generic levitra uk accutane uk lawsuits viagra effects on women buy amaryl tablets india endep uk companies only cipro cost canadian benzac uses medication tizanidinum buy online canada the evolution of a viagra salesman wiki janumet pricing what is the drug paxil used to treat pills for erectile dysfunction over the counter where can i buy alli in canada generic leukeran where can i buy liposafe zestoretic on line in the mexico i pill rosuvastatin website crestor discount diovan from canada can order extendaquin canada purchase pulmicort lowest price generic drug for procardia xl american accuran buy finax in australia alesse refill pack oder mg tablets of viagra sublingual half price levitra canada pharmacy store online lantus solostar needles patient assistance to buy aceon in uk best place to buy zydis exelon from australia zenegra dosage too high prinivil mg uk levitra super active pct buy detrol mg buy cheapest ponstel tablets uk buy celebrex pills in the uk where can i purchase caverta amantadine dosage children health canada levothroid hydrocortisone cream side effects in men where to get doxycycline grifulvin v from europe metrogel birth control online us zestoretic 40 mg dose ordering pletal indian generic buy medrol buy ginseng patch buy brand mestinon where can i buy pletal in uk what are trental tablets for buy sildenafila online amazon generic retino a cream in usa buy prevacid online canada no prescription zertalin over counter uk cipro dose for uti minipress now co uk trental without subscription buy voveran sr with paypal buy over the counter amlodipinbesilat online delta cortef mg canada can you buy l tryptophan over the counter in germany order buy cheap chloromycetin being content in a relationship order cabgolin without prescription how to get clomid in the uk ventolin for men in usa doxycycline reviews for acne is arjuna legal in uk nootropil buy online india non narcotic pain meds buy cardizem pills online female pink viagra in india plavix drug in fr pharmacy allegra 180 mg twice daily cardizem cheap uk pharmacy order uk alli weight loss capsules buying retin a gel 0,1 ondansetron dose iv esomeprazole dosage and administration propranolol pills buy online drugs from canada illegal zentel tablets usage where to buy depakine chrono online uk raciper online usa generic pills for fluss 40 furosemide use in horses azithromycin and alcohol consumption order alli canada lowest dipyridamole bonus pills tadalis for sale australia actos daily use reviews cataflam united states acivir pills without prescription over the counter medicine flunil kytril 1 mg 10 tablet methocarbamol dosage for opiate withdrawal levitra 20 mg. tabletas where to buy female viagra mg can bactrim ds cause weight gain cytoxan tablet sale wigraine without prescription order tetracycline from australia without prescription buy colospa online with mastercard what are the side effects of coming off seroquel promethazine 12.5 tablets what is it for purchase ponstel on line in australia buy ditropan quick pharmacies amaryl prescription discount buy over the counter coumadin online is prilosec available on line in canada lipitor discount pfizer order viagra plus lowest price alli slimming tablets celebrex recall celebrex medication can you buy viagra over the counter in england prescription ovral l uses medication low cost overnight naprosyn what is the price of levaquin 500 mg buy sertraline uk cheap tamoxifen buy online discount clomid from canada vytorin mg tablet prednisone 20mg uses buy cialis 50 uk buy thyrox without prescription safe metoclopramide no precription dostinex price in pakistan buy online cordarone generic buy erection packs 2 online safely pyridium no rx can i get reglan over the counter tetracycline buy canada erection packs 1 refills buy glucophage tablets us amaryl pill shop discount code safety fluconazole pregnancy what does seroquel 25 mg do to you zovirax ointment for sale aygestin coupons viagra in pakistan stores buy accutane western drug confido tofranil phone orders stieva a pills online in the mexico where to buy retino a cream 0,025 ointment rosuvastatin discount very cheap riperdal floxin mg canadian rx order non generic robaxin xenical pharmacy order buy medrol online from mexico buy voltaren gel usa where can i get floxin from antivert buy online canada zyvox from mexico best price for real bactroban gabapentin withdrawal syndrome isoniazid without a prescription from india purchase coreg lowest price lasilix for dogs buy proventil brands india buy clomid in spain toprol xl in usa dipyridamole india no prescription how much does elocon cost how long is cialis shelf life buyers of haldol canada lov cost cialis super active buy female viagra online from uk canada buy glucophage too much synthroid medication symptoms lasix medication classification where to buy imitrex without a prescription trial erection packs 1 canada head office villas for sale calan porter unisom over counter uk mentax without rx generic strattera overnite shipping oratane pct buy is wellbutrin xl generic mestinon daily use reviews generic feldene in usa canada buy yasmin without prescription indian generics online stediril buying sustiva in manchester buy diflucan online cheap buy mirapex online cheap lozol tablets uk gowrie discount pharmacy contact cheap pills echeck generic gasex entocort 3mg tablets dramamine shortage roxithromycin for purchase cheap valtrex online canada order lipitor no prescription needed where to buy albenda without a prescription accutane acne treatment reviews buy moduretic discount no prescription cialis mastercard buy nexium pills in the uk arimidex online price cheap viagra jelly licensed online secure tabs coupon code buy norvasc 10 best online pharmacy generic ranitidine buy furosemide online canada order kemadrin online with visa purchase fluoxetine on line in mexico buy kamagra oral jelly pills in the mexico medicine coumadin and alcohol brand levitra online from india order sildenafil citrate without prescription geriforte online pay paypal orlistat 120 mg in stock letrozole cost walmart is generic demadex available in usa low price flucazole uk where do i tricor in uk amaryl order fluconazole thrush boots tulasi generico italiano procardia 10 mg where do i suhagra in australia furosemide for sale philippines fake vgr 100 pravachol medicine children all types blopress pills retino a cream 0,05 buy online canada aspirin spot treatment overnight cheap oxybutyninum no prescription donde puedo comprar viagra chile fake cialis from india does over the counter testosterone cream work zyprexa medication cost where to buy disulfiram online best price raloxifeno what drug category is zenegra disulphiram online cheapest combivent in the uk retino a cream 0,025 online from canada cardura doxazosin tablets carafate for men sale in uk naprosyn from india buy acai next day flomax online legally zloft candian pharmacy no script disulphiram shelf life buy bactroban pills in the australia exelon without prescriptions where to buy alavert online without rx minocin fda approved to buy without prescription buy zyloprim 15mg online can you get accutane nhs generic albuterol in usa cymbalta online canadian ivenox canadian online where can i get viagra for free noroxin online overnight seroquel drugs for sale buy nymphomax online no prescription us viagra 100mg no prescription buy viagra online thru paypals erexin v generic 2013 drugs cardizem without rx tadapox birth control online canada emsam buy mexico brand name tretinoin online clomid for sale australia overnight pharmacy cheap alli cheap actos discount purchase duetact in usa sale renagel safe revia no prescription buy toprol xl uk best price emsam zyloprim sublingual dosage cheap wisconsin ginseng safe viagra jelly no prescription propranolol medicine side effects where can i buy ortho tri cyclen online cialis soft drug in mexico pharmacy buy eli lilly brand cialis sildenafil citrate oral jelly india wigraine order online no prescription eltroxin over the counter canada esperal order in the us how to get glyset in australia medicine ampicillin tr cialis online.ca buy cheap levaquin no prescription pill rx health order effexor xr products vytorin brand positioning viagra jelly from uk price buy ampicillin 250mg imitrex over counter buy triamcinolone acetonide cream .1 cialis black cialis soft drug store online buy allopurinol boots metocarbamol side effects long term use how long does it take to get used to norvasc alavert without a prescription from australia generic ophthacare usa pharmacy aceon where can i buy how to buy cheap abilify online order beta val online no prescription with a mastercard buy sinequan for daily use how to take requip for rls zentel for sale australia how much will eurax cost best non prescription medicine for migraines where to clomid lipitor tablets us online inderal use in pregnancy generic protonix uk paypal buy zestril online with no prescription elocon 5mg tablets confido mexico companies only buying ivenox from canada no prescription motilium cheap uk pharmacy buying toprol xl using paypal orlistat mg price omnicef weight dosing rxlist buspar reviews patients do you need rx cleocin como comprar trimox billig neurontin online kaufen zyvox 300 mg pill proventil noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy why has betoptic been discontinued where do i lantus in uk ou acheter des livres sterling pas cher wellbutrin spain mircette next day shipping buy abilify no prescription medication quiero comprar sumycin non prescription drugs abuse glucofage online canadian naproxen 250mg tablet ivermectin for horses injection femcare reviews for men suhagra supplier in uk triamterenum usa pharmacy order hytrin 2mg where to buy brand amoxil online uk ordering lipitor here in canada raloxifeno online in canada safe to buy generic tenormin from usa purchase beta val on line in canada where to buy viagra sublingual with echeck order generic artane order amlodipin no rx canadian pharmacy non prescription birth control sponge med cab cipralex what is glycomet 500 sr american mentat ds syrup where to purchase crestor pfizer viagra side effects buying remeron baridium over the counter india bupron sr pas cher ajanta pharma new delhi tretinoin 0 05 order on web comprar clavamox original en madrid buy cialis professional online overnight cholestoplex generic release date cheapest place to buy trial erection packs 1 flagyl er looking for cheap oxytrol 40 mg clomid best online non prescription pharmacy buy artane online australia no prescription drugs similar to stieva a no script baridium mg generic benicar hct 40 12.5 mg benemid coupon code where to find zithromax order generic avandamet wellbutrin price carafate tablets side effects resources for silagra buy kamagra gold without rx purchase salbutamol mg trimox without a prescription from australia atacand 16 mg tabletten nebenwirkungen zaditor tablets from buy is there a generic brand for seroquel oristal lowest price where can i get some tetracycline uroxatral next day doksazosin lek without subscription vpxl no prescription purchase zertalin in usa flagyl 250 mg for dogs.side effects cat costa o cutie de dostinex generic maxalt paypal alli availability update canadian health card requirements cialis preisvergleich generika buy aviane 28 mexican pharmacies order flovent online no prescription with a echeck dangers of mixing viagra and cialis how to buy glucotrol xl online buying furosemide uk levitra comprar what is norvasc medication glimepiride dose maximum ditropan pills trandate brand pills for sale order dramamine no rx canadian pharmacy generic uk paypal proventil best viagra professional prices generic 100mg buy moduretic online safely where can i order caverta i pill isotretin website benefits of testosterone cream for men ciprofloxacin eye drops order diprosone online no presctiption estrofem pharmacy prices list lexapro generic release purchasing sinemet online uk esperal dosage instructions can you buy antibiotics in spain over the counter is there a generic for premarin cream mail order skelaxin albenza to buy in the uk without a prescription proventil dosage nebulizer ordering remeron kamagra now co uk kamagraoraljelly how to use kamagra soft brand viagra pills sweat cheap tamoxifen no prescription maxaman best online non prescription pharmacy noroxin buy online canada can you buy l tryptophan online actonel for men sale in uk american pharmacy online similar accutane medications order roxithromycin without rx buy plendil quick buy estradiol valerate online from uk purchase acnetane on line in the uk keftab spain farmacia web pharmacy rx opinioni speman online canadian buy periactin tablets india onde comprar metformina buspar canada online no prescription anteovin cheap mexico pharmacy can i buy arjuna in canada minocin pas cher italie can you buy levitra over the counter purchase lansoprazol on line in mexico ordering cymbalta india acheter acivir pills pas cher brand cialis prescription coupon lithium canadian online how to take aspirin without hurting stomach raloxifeno usa no prescription quetiapinum prescription coupon buy generic luvox online order generic roxithromycin tetracycline medication for fish order cheap valtrex glucofage generic mexico isotretinoin tablets side effects buy lopid online uk no prescription generic substitute for diovan risperdal medication information twic cardlongs drugs weekly advertisement cheapest nordette tablets uk buy fasigyne mg purchase sildenafil citrate on line in india is there a generic form of atacand diprosone australia price buy vermox with mebendazole 100mg paediatric actonel tablets side effects order cafergot on line canada best price for real kamagra soft cipro online in canada fluoxetine from uk betoptic online ordering cialis professional ordering online pharmacy buy eltroxin online from india buy mircette singapore buy biaxin xl online floxin fast uk can you buy viagra plus in ireland order nizagara no rx canadian pharmacy priligy side effects long term use where viagra soft keflex without script buy generic medrol dosepak online order metronizadole online asthma medication copd advair diskus allegra printing show low az order mobic from canada without prescription buy glucophage mg online for cost of yasminelle flagyl er online forum ponstel medication overnight delivery exelon without subscription online pharmacy uk levothroid bentyl women buy tadapox generic release date indocin medication for arthritis generic albenza no prescription canada buy permethrinum without prescription levaquin sales how long does orlistat take to work buy brand riomont elocon ointment mometasone furoate used for online pharmacy uk zertalin buy aripiprazola tablets how long to take doxycycline for malaria prophylaxis homeopathic medicine like viagra best place to buy brafix pastillas para ereccion what is xanax in uk purchasing zenegra online uk pharm online norx how to buy zyprexa online clavamox to buy in the uk without a prescription cafergot without prescrip 100mg minocycline acne list of tesco stores selling diarex pyridium without subscription online endep india buy penicillin for people buy mobic online at canada pharmacy quickest lotrisone zovirax 400 mg tabletten buy propecia 10 prevacid usa sale buy aloprim online from india canada pharmacies online that sell roaccutane what is coreg 6.25 mg used for cheap zithromax 500mg buy sarafem online india no prescription zovirax tablets to buy sale zertalin cheap viagra uk no prescription best place to buy caffeine ergotamine in canada cheap pulmicort no prescription arava israel bike ride low cost overnight clozaril cafergot canadian source ciplox from usa pharmacy cheap genuine paxil online side effects of flagyl for dogs buy tramadol online with mastercard glucotrol buy usa order premarin discount levitra professional no script accuran for purchase without a prescription best place to buy procardia in australia how to take noroxin mg use levitra super active coupon online frumil shop net pharmacies buy atarax online salbutamol dose buy avapro from mexico online long term side effects of benadryl use drinking alcohol while zithromax flovent where to get best place buy zestril pct what is the generic version of viagra over counter tinidazole buy rumalaya with no rx murders in indianapolis indiana what is paroxetine medication ranitidine from china how to use proventil hfa over the counter levothyroid buy silagra online india no prescription acai fast canada avalide medication cost high blood generic chloromycetin safe buy atorlip 5 in india online leukeran medication side effects clomid 100mg with metformin pill rx health ortho cyclen products relafen pills buy minocin coupons generic plavix for sale on line yasmin direct pharmacy how to buy deltasone minocycline medicinenet etodolac online forum purchase viagra online cheap purchase chloromycetin on line in australia order isoptin without prescription where can i buy rogaine 2 online without a prescription no prescription levoxyl vermox without prescription calan buy india viagra over the counter walgreens pills buying proscar online best place to buy l thyroxine in uk frumil price india safe warafin no prescription cheap cystone no prescription crestor cost 5mg indian pharmacy finasteride buy disulfiramo without a subscription order raciper without rx alesse birth control buy cheap purchase lamisilate pills anastrozolo online ordering is levothroid available over the counter levothyroxin costco zovirax 800 mg price india permethrinum india sildenafil viagra cleocin gel refill pack best site for voveran sr cost of haldol without insurance is it legal to order generic drugs from india serophene order online no prescription zyprexa weight gain nolvadex canada companies only gasex sale buy online alesse generic amitriptyline 10mg weight gain what is diltiazem hydrochloride where bentyl malegra fxt max dose nymphomax without script can flovent diskus cause weight gain protonix iv push dose carafate suppositories buy no script cipro mg andy shaw canadian healthcare technology promethazine pills 25 mg high order unisom lowest price where to buy acai berry fruit in malaysia buy cheap brahmi using pay pal augmentin tablets online trileptal no prescription needed buy orlistato online from australia buy zestoretic with visa misoprost order online etodolac canada online no prescription beconase aq online in uk what is viagra used for treatment how to use lasix pre contest diovan 80mg tablets ar r liquid cialis dosage order remeron online canada ortho cyclen tablets side effects is ordering viagra online safe canadian where to buy hoodia diet pills hoodia priceline cymbalta over the counter drug can we trust retin a gel 0,1 online cheap acivir pills free delivery buy levothroid online without a prescription lamisil over the counter usa what types of pariet are there un rey en la habana online tadalis sx cheap australia pharmacy bactroban birth control online mexico tetracycline dosage for gonorrhea tindamax online no prescription lisinopril 20mg online pharmacy best site get erection packs 2 pariet cheap us pharmacy canine doxycycline dosage lowest price dramamine aricept 40 mg pharmacy starlix no prescription compare prices allopurinol without prescriptions over the counter alternative to cymbalta antara fast india online zetia overnight delivery donde puedo comprar trental mentax next day shipping buy zyrtec online thru paypals over the counter fucidin luvox coupon code acivir pills doctors online paxil reviews for ocd imdur where to purchase buy colchicina inhaler canada what is the difference between biaxin and biaxin xl betnovate betamethasone low cost tinidazolum overnight pharmacy kelnor canada pharmacy where do amaryllis originate from order cholestoplex us pharmacy canada how to get lasix on line probalan online no prescription buy acyclovir medication online from usa where to buy viagra super active with echeck alliant mexico city viagra online purchase reviews prescription mobic meloxicam effects where can i buy torsemide mg can you get female viagra over the counter key pred prix en pharmacie en france buy cardura xl doxazosin cleocin gel costco etabus no prescription overnight delivery mirtazapine sleep architecture ciprofloxacino cinfa alcohol retino a cream shelf life cheap medrol dosepak sale uk where do i nolvadex in canada clomid for men success stories digoxin overseas percocet mg uk allegra cost india best place to buy zovirax in usa prilosec online in uk yaz canada tadapox paypal order digoxin on line canada how long does it take for strattera to work in adults effexor xr india no prescription med cab innopran xl leukeran drug canadian pharmacy retino a cream 0 05 canada prescription buy fasigyne online amazon gabapentine dosage too high safe place order ayurslim no prescription serevent sale what does allopurinol inhibit albuterol delivered to your home buy zyprexa zydis online estrace pills online in the canada aprovel generic uk kamagra tablet sale where to buy tetracycline for fish discount pharmacy retino a cream 0,05 buy canada over the counter medicine that acts as aldactone cephalexin fast usa long time side effects key pred lansoprazol online india generic v gel india acivir pills pill shop discount code voltaren gel shelf life curacne pricing buy alfa flucon online order prescription meds from mexico metronidazole alcohol in food buy famvir in uk cheap doxazosin usa quickest benicar mg prescription do you need rx obelit canadian pharmacy crestor para que se usa el trental ranitidine birth control online india buy luvox tablets us order buy prescription eurax buy viagra over the counter london customer satisfaction walmart prescriptions by mail order ordering lasix usa canada pharmacies online that sell dyazide how long does noroxin take to work where to buy bupropion in canada safely bentyl 20 mg oral tablets order fluoxetina overnight buy generic maxaman online with prescription best site to buy ponstel keftab on line no script medicines to avoid when taking coumadin generic propecia vs propecia is viagra over the counter in australia how to get periactin on line flovent shopping order klipal codeine online without rx purchase lotensin in usa can you buy viagra over the counter in the uk into buy zithromax online australia no prescription cost of bupropion hcl canada safe viagra online non generic risperdal generic depo provera shot robaxin 750 prices buy nizagara canada suppliers of eltroxin in us protonix prescription price what is medrol steroid pack arava on line where to buy stieva a with visa cefadroxil dose duration ciplox online india cialis order online generic buy cialis online canadian pharmacy safe online pharmacy uk ordering flucazole india buy cialis professional mexican pharmacies where do i glucofage in canada online levoxyl overnight delivery zyrtec class action lawsuit triamcinolone acetonide cream usp .1 uses amoxil capsules 250mg dosage children code red pill 7 seconds diarex canada us pharmacy online tadapox dostinex online uk menosan mail order over the counter medicine furosemide i need viagra cause youre too ugly to turn me on lyrics canadian pharmacy seroflo purchase speman on line in australia buy orlistat online from uk comprar wellbutrin sr original en madrid differin pills drugstore buy meclizine online no prescription us amoxicillin buy uk no prescription thyrox no prescription compare prices toprol delivery uk ortho cyclen generic brand long term side effects of korean ginseng zyrtec buy usa cabaser on line no script buy beta val boots pharmacy cabaser mexico pharmacy safe trial erection packs 1 no precription retino a cream phone orders shuddha guggulu with paypal payment side effects of co diovan tablets order pyridium online without rx use lamictal coupon online safe to buy generic betnovate from uk can you buy abana over the counter in germany vermox without a prescription aristocort over counter viagra and nitrates treatment can i get wellbutrin in australia elimite drug oversea gabapentine on line in the canada works best viagra levitra cialis fluoxetina tablets price azithromycin 250 mg treatment order zentel online canada accutane drugs recall where can i buy cabaser mg buy trandate pills in the uk purchase hydrochlorothiazide 50mg gabapentine on line in the india finpecia 1mg review crestor recommended dosage online delta cortef with no prescription how to take finasteride safely ivenox pills sweat prescription drug brand advair diskus safe to buy generic acivir pills from canada fastest lamisilate uk delivery doxycycline tablets purchase on line buy metformin hcl 500mg trial erection packs 3 uk online aspirin protect 100 u trudnoci femara twins ovral l without a prescription fucidin cream price where can i buy elimite cream where can i purchase cyklokapron buy arjuna pills in the us buy amoxil online canada no prescription generic amaryl in usa capoten pills research grade celadrin order amaryl from australia without prescription vpxl on line in the mexico best place to buy vasotec in india billig micardis online kaufen buy avalide tablets australia get seroflo toronto alli orlistat onde comprar no brasil danazol drug classification where could i buy adalat without prescription generic tadalafil canada buy eurax online no prescription us liquid levothroid review clonidine without cialis jelly buy canada buy antabuse online uk no prescription van you buy diflucan over the counter in canada buy malarone tablets tesco buy cheap adalat cozaar mail order india discount floxin mg aripiprazola prescription only aurochem cialis reviews purchase stromectol in india cheap cardura uk best place to buy premarin in canada order valtrex lowest price beconase aq next day delivery buy yoga dvd online australia augmentin pharmacy online buy nexium for daily use lasix overnight fedex purchase estrace on line in australia order danazol without rx buy zedd xr without prescription kelnor online from uk offshore pharmacy no prescription canadian female viagra glucotrol xl max dose can you buy raciper over the counter zoloft from pfizer inhouse pharmacy uk reviews hytrin drug in canada pharmacy how to buy nitroglycerin in london fluoxetine no prescription buy isotretin pills in the india benicar hct 20mg 12.5mg use of ondansetron in pregnancy novo digoxin with paypal payment delivery alphagan cod cash tinidazole online usa no prescription cheap alternative to zyprexa beat way to order depakote how long is the shelf life of augmentin purchase zedd on line in india nexium manufacturers in india medicine allied courses india azitromicina generic usa where to buy cheap generic v gel where to get oestrogel pct pharmacy buy alli overnight delivery post cycle therapy silagra alli available in stores buy minocycline online amazon ciprofloxacin eye drops children inderal uk sale lanoxin online shipping order effexor xr online can i get kamagra gold abilify uk boots snorting gabapentin capsules clomifene next day order baridium on line uk i pill betnovate website purchase mirapex on line in canada genuine terramycin 100mg flovent 100 mcg betnovate pregnancy keppra prices cvs canada pharmacies online that sell mometasona sarafem online overnight shipping is ophthacare available over the counter tizanidina with no rx bupron sr canada overnight delivery cialis soft suppositories buy buy robaxin dogs buy prednisolona online canada no prescription cheap clopidogrelum sale uk can you buy cyklokapron over the counter in germany buy decadron online thru paypals acai berry precio mexico ordering lithium arzomicin drugstore.com vasotec lawsuit settlements buy viagra super active from canada actoplus pharmacy mail order how to get cialis jelly on line cordarone oral dose cialis kopen zonder voorschrift is meclizine available on line in canada what is max dose of levitra cuanto cuestan las pastillas cytotec en peru order ortho tri cyclen uk pharmacy buy cabana generic suppliers of viagra super active in us viagra cipla bactroban nasal medication where can you buy nexium buy cheap propecia online buy avalide online overnight delivery best canadian no prescription pharmacy buy tadalis sx from mexico online himalaya ayurslim tablets review lanoxin pediatric dose acheter viagra cialis et levitra is zyrtec better than singulair buy generic danazol online no prescription dramamine generic name apcalis sx prescriptions cleocin usa sale tesco chesterfield pharmacy opening hours cleocin gel for sale tamsulozin coupon code remeron 30 mg tablets atorlip 10 prescription only lipitor in canada prices amaryl online bestellen canada order trandate where to buy parlodel drugs online paroxetine indian brands voltaren retard uk generic depo medrol can you order seroflo canadian buy tulasi plant in melbourne buy salbumol bulk seroquel price per pill half inderal capsules buying strattera online no prescription order furosemide online no prescription with a echeck fluoxetine 20 mg for menopause safe hyzaar no prescription discount zertalin mg buy speman online no prescription cialis super active best online non prescription pharmacy is dramamine sold over the counter drug market order trental oral acyclovir over the counter zyloprim delivery eurax cost per month keppra prices by plavix from canada kamagra oral jelly generic uk buy trental no prescription fast delivery carbozyne sale vpxl canada prescription safe to buy generic nexium from uk health canada micardis is generic wellbutrin available in usa purchase rogaine 5 in mexico purchase acai max purchase tadalis sx on line in uk valtrex 1000 mg 21 tablets canada pharmacies without a script purchase keflex in us eltroxin cheap mexico pharmacy discount bactrim from usa viagra sales online celebrex india pharmacy buy bupron sr usa minocin order by phone best generic ditropan sites tinidazolum generic australia canada and cardizem levitra super active overnight pharmacy etodolac no prescription oder mg tablets of retin buy altace from canada buy allopurinol online overnight delivery what does promethazine make u feel like buy retin a tablets mexico get cialis online prescription super v8 viagra cheap luvox usa walgreens claritin sale side effects of differin 0.1 gel side effects of coumadin warfarin movalis online without rx proscar shortage how to buy ciprofloxacina in london how much will nitrofurantoin cost metoclopramide over the counter uk viagra sublingual pills online in the india cost of micardis 80 mg prednisolona fast usa genuine doxi 1 best price buy nizagara online canada no prescription forzest ranbaxy phone in order for augmentin zyrtec over the counter price mail order cleocin online vytorin dosage forms tadalis sx cheap uk blue sky pharmacy reviews fluoxetina online order can i crush keppra tablets is isoniazid available on line in canada where to buy plendil online canada discount hytrin from usa post accutane treatment scarring buy tamoxifen online uk pharmacy lotrisone without a prescription from us alphagan pas cher order indocin on line uk tinidazole pfizer costo del viagra in slovenia finasteride online no prescription online prednisone order legal buy sepibest online canada what does risperdal do for children is cipro better than bactrim fosamax prescription coupon avapro to buy in australia can you buy cialis jelly over the counter in germany arjuna yoga aspen reviews plavix cost generic carvedilolo from mexico prilosec in the uk now levothroid no prescription compare prices allopurinol india companies only cheap generic requip advair discus without a perscription generic naprosyn tablets cost of norvasc micardis plus uk requip side effects uk buy cabaser without prescription best site to buy depakote diovan generic usa ortho cyclen no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy cymbalta sales 2011 order zovirax online no prescription with a visa order ortho tri cyclen from canada without prescription use ciplox coupon online emsam discounts promethazine otc medication buy cipro without online pharmacy tulasi buy ciprofloxacina in india online purchase benicar no prescription retin a next day thyroxin buy online australia suppliers of lynoral in us seroquel high erowid buy ciplox australia what does cephalexin tablets look like tramadol high side effects can you order fluoxetina buy viagra professional without rx half price speman buy elimite online no prescription us movalis online pharmacy shipped to canada price increase maxalt hoodia online canadian pulmicort respules discounts fluoxetine canada price synthroid medication order ordering disulphiram india best pet medication online effexor xr tablets side effects side effects of synthroid withdrawal buying cleocin fastest altace uk delivery buy zebeta with a mastercard buy retin a 0,05 pills in the australia asthma guidelines 2012 uk testosterone therapy dosage buying brand cialis ordering erythromycin india metformin hcl 500 mg tablet zyd drugs similar to retino a cream 0,025 buy orlistat mexican pharmacies shelf life of ampicillin plates trazodone tablets 40mg stromectol to buy from europe protonix online pharmacies fluss 40 no rx triamterenum india no prescription why not allopurinol in acute gout zoloft and pregnancy category femara to buy in australia where to purchase pamelor lasuna brand positioning prednisolone 5mg buy online where to get differin pct atorlip 20 buy without donde comprar medicamento florinef chloromycetin pharmacy purchase albenda on line in canada can you buy lasilix online vente de periactin au quebec celadrin mg buy generic erexin v mometasona purchase cheap doxycycline hyclate 100mg tablets where can i get paxil azitromicina phone orders buy albenza tablets uk buy alli 100mg online buy rumalaya liniment online pharmacy lasix usage zyvox in usa trade generic name nitroglycerin advair diskus canadian medications without prescription zyban online cheap does viagra work the first time men pastillas abortivas cytotec precio order benicar pill doxycycline mono 75 mg tablet salvent pills buy stromectol pills online in the australia what is sominex for tulasi theater online booking us pharmacies online that sell sildenafil citrate high dose prednisone side effects in dogs buy stieva a pills in the india get avodart prescription online buy terramycin using paypal cialis professional tadalafil femara over the counter australia online generic xeloda valaciclovir us companies only order ampicilina from canada without prescription cost of plavix actonel without insurance reviews on ceftin buy cheap xenical online healthnet prescriptions by mail nitrofurantoin from australia what is acticin serophene uk brand name where to buy erythromycin eye ointment pediatric pulmicort dose canadian pharmacy online colchicina list of tesco stores selling levitra plus viagra jelly online from usa canada buy brand amoxil without prescription purchase unique hoodia canadian pharmacy lexapro price what is the best prescription medicine for migraines imitrex from canada without rx canadian prescription free cialis paroxetine overnight line view topic where to buy propranolol with visa zebeta generic name best place to buy kamagra in australia duetact manufacturer cost of cialis per pill walmart cystone pills sweat zoloft cheap australia pharmacy extra strong herbal viagra elocon canadian medications without prescription can you only get erection packs 2 on prescription all types cephalexin pills over the counter drugs similar to zestril phexin cheap purchase voveran sr in us buy aceon pills in the australia buy altace greece januvia 100 mg tablets can order deltasone online can you buy viagra over the counter in hong kong all types l tryptophan pills taking clomid after birth control pills erexin v india companies only buy lasix without a prescription fluconazol refills mail order ditropan online discount lasix otc vpxl fast canada buy percocet no prescription lamisil no prescription compare prices generic paroxetine side effects is viagra made in india safe northstar rx fluoxetine diclofenac canadian online fluconazol pharmacy mail order discount singulair of canada buy medrol dosepak perth australia dipyridamole next day shipping order zocor from mexico without prescription cost of lipitor generics baby zyrtec reviews lantus insulin no prescription buy generic accutane 10mg seth roberts
الرئيسية | النادي اللغوي | بحوث نحوية | المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود
 

صفحة شبكة صوت العربية في فيسبوكtwitterقناة شبكة صوت العربية في يوتيوبشبكة صوت العربية في موقع فليكر

المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود طباعة إرسال إلى صديق
تصنيفات: بحوث نحوية
تقييم المستخدمين: / 54
سيئجيد 
الكاتب أحمد مجرشي   
الأحد, 10 أبريل 2011 20:07

النشأة :
سيقودنا الحديث عن نشأة هذا المصطلح إلى الحديث عن مناهج النحويين واختلاف آرائهم في الأصول والفروع وهل يرقى هذا الاختلاف لتتميز منه مذاهب ومدارس لها حدود واضحة المعالم أم إن الخلاف يقف عند الفروع لا يتجاوزها فلا يستحق أن يطلع عليها مدرسة أم إنه أقل من ذلك فهو مذهب واحد وطريقة ؟ واحدة تختلف بعض فروعها اختلافا يسيرا داخل نطاق المنهج ولا يخرج عنه .

وقبل التفصيل في هذه المسائل ينبغي أن نعرف إجمالا أن موضوع التقسيم مر بثلاث مراحل هي :

الأولى : تسمية العلماء بأمصارهم وبلدانهم مما يوحي بوجود مذهب خاص بهم أو لا يوحي بذلك .
الثانية : تقسيم مناهجهم وطرقهم وتسميتها بـ " مذهب " وهي مرحلة تالية للمرحلة السابقة .
الثالثة : إطلاق اسم " مدرسة " على المذهب أو على أهل الأمصار وهذه التسمية أطلقت حديثا في الوقت المعاصر.
و بيان ذلك على النحو التالي :

أولا :
"يتضح لنا من عرض مناهج الذين أرخوا للنحو والنحاة من القدماء أنهم اتبعوا في ترتيبهم نسبتهم للبلد الذي ظهروا فيه وتعلموا نحوه ودرسوه أو درّسوه فهم بصريون وكوفيون وأهل بغداد"(1).
"وأول من يلقنا من القدماء محمد بن سلام الجمحي ( 139-231هـ) الذي قال :" وكان لأهل البصرة في العربية قدامة وبالنحو ولغات العرب والغريب عناية "(2).
وترجم لأبي الأسود الدؤلي وعدّه مؤسس علم العربية وليحيى بن يعمر ولعبدالله بن إسحاق الحضرمي ولأبي عمرو بن العلاء وانتهى بالخليل بن أحمد الفراهيدي ولم ينسبهم إلى مدرسة وإنما عدهم من أهل البصرة (3).
وأعقبه أبو محمد عبدالله بن مسلم بن قتيبة الدينوري ( 213 – 276 هـ ) الذي عقد في كتابه "المعارف" بحثا لرواة الشعر وأصحاب الغريب والنحو وترجم بإيجاز لمعظم من اشتهر بهذه العلوم من البصريين والكوفيين ... ويلاحظ في ترجمته لهم أنه لم يذكرهم مقسمين إلى بصريين وكوفيين معتمدا على شهرتهم ولم يسمهم بمذهب أو مدرسة (4).
وجاء بعدهما أبو الطيب عبدالواحد بن علي اللغوي الحلبي ( ت 351هـ ) وألف كتاب "مراتب النحويين" ورتبه حسب الزمن مبتدئا بالبصريين لأن النحو في البصرة كان أقدم نشوءا منه في الكوفة ... وكانت أول إشارة إلى الكوفة عند ترجمته لأبي جعفر الرؤاسي حيث قال : وممن أخذ عن أبي عمرو أبو جعفر الرؤاسي عالم الكوفة (5).
والدليل على أنهم كانوا ينسبون النحاة إلى البلد ويذكرونه في ترجمتهم بحسب البلدان أن أبا الطيب ختم كتابه بعد الانتهاء من ذكر البصريين والكوفيين بقوله :" ولا علم للعرب إلا في هاتين المدينتين "(6).

ثانيا :
كان أبو بكر محمد بن الحسن الزبيدي ( ت 379هـ ) أول من استخدم كلمة " مذهب " عندما ترجم لأصحاب ثعلب فقال عن أبي موسى الحامض : " كان بارعا في اللغة والنحو على مذهب الكوفيين "(7)
"وقال عن ابن كيسان وكان بصريا كوفيا يحفظ القولين ويعرف المذهبين وكان أخذ عن ثعلب والمبرد وكان ميله إلى مذهب البصريين أكثر ... وكان أبو بكر ابن الأنباري شديد التعصب على ابن كيسان والتنقص له وكان يقول : خلط فلم يضبط مذهب الكوفيين ولا مذهب البصريين"(8).

ومن هنا يتضح أن الزبيدي كان أول من قسم النحاة إلى مجموعات بحسب البلدان التي عرفوا بها وكان أول من استخدم عبارات "مذهب الكوفيين" و "مذهب البصريين" و "المذهبين" ويريد بذلك أن النحو متابع
لآراء نحاة الكوفة أو لآراء نحاة البصرة أو لنحاة المدينتين(9).
وجاء بعده ابن النديم· (ت 385 هـ ) واتبع التقسيم نفسه إلا أنه سمى نحاة بغداد " من خلط المذهبين " (10).
وبعدهما جاء أبو البركات الأنباري ( ت 577 هـ ) فقد اتبع في كتابه "نزهة الألباء في طبقات الأدباء" التسلسل الزمني ولم يذكر كلمة مذهب إلى مع البغداديين في الغالب كقوله : " وكان يخلط المذهبين " أو " وكان قيما بمذهب البصريين والكوفيين "(11).

ثالثا :
استحسن الباحثون المحدثون مصطلح "المدرسة" بمعنى المذهب النحوي وقد كانوا في ذلك متأثرين بالغربيين الذين شاع عندهم هذا المصطلح بهذا المفهوم ونجاحه في الدراسات الأدبية فكان عندهم المدرسة الكلاسيكية في الأدب والفن والمدرسة الرومانتيكية والمدرسة الرمزية(12).
وكان من أوائل من استخدم هذا المصطلح "جوتولد فايل" الذي سماهما المدرسة البصرية والمدرسة الكوفية وتبعه في ذلك "بروكلمان" الذي قال : " وقد قسم علماء العربية مذاهب النحو إلى ثلاث مدارس : البصريين والكوفيين ومن مزجوا المذهبين من علماء بغداد "(13).
واستخدم المحدثون الكلمة نفسها ولعل الدكتور مهدي المخزومي أول من تبنى هذه التسمية فسمى أحد كتبه "مدرسة الكوفة ومنهجها في دراسة اللغة والنحو" وألف الدكتور شوقي ضيف كتابا سماه "المدارس النحوية" وألف الدكتور عبدالرحمن السيد كتابا سماه "مدرسة البصرة النحوية (14).

مفهوم المذهب والمدرسة :
1 - مفهوم المذهب النحوي :
المذهب مصطلح فقهي في بداية نشأته فيقال مذهب الإمام الشافعي أو الإمام مالك أو مذهب شيخنا ... وانتقل إلى اللغة حيث أصبح يعبر عن مجموعة مبادئ وآراء متصلة ومنسقة لمفكر ما أو لاتجاه ما .
وفي التعريف النحوي الدقيق هو : طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد تعتنق مذهبا نحويا وتقول برأي نحوي مشترك وتجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع (15).

2 - مفهوم المدرسة النحوية :
بعد الحديث عن تطور مسمى المناهج النحوية وطرق النحويين لعل الوقت قد حان للحديث عن مفهوم المدرسة عند المتأخرين .
فقد عرف المعجم الوسيط مصطلح المدرسة - بهذا المفهوم الجديد - بقوله :" المدرسة جماعة من الفلاسفة والمفكرين أو الباحثين تعتنق مذهبا معينا أو تقول برأي مشترك "(16).
وعند المتأخرين تعريفات كثيرة للمدرسة وكلها تدور حول هذا المعنى وسنستعرض فيما يلي بعضها .
عرف "جوتولد فايل" المدرس بأنها : "الاشتراك في وجهة النظر الذي يؤلف الجبهة العلمية ويربط العلماء بعضهم ببعض على رأي واحد "(17).
والأستاذ على النجدي ناصف يعرف المدرسة بقوله :" المدرسة طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد أو الفن الواحد تجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم العلمية وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع والتفاصيل ".
وعرفها الدكتور أحمد مكي الأنصاري بقوله :" اتجاه له خصائص مميزة ينادي بها فرد أو جماعة من الناس ثم ينادي بها آخرون ".
على حين يعرفها الدكتور مهدي الخزمومي بقوله :" فليست المدرسة إلا أستاذا مؤثرا وتلاميذ متأثرين وقد اجتمعوا على تحقيق غرض موحد نهجوا للوصول إليه منهاجا "(18).
قال ذلك في مدرسة الكوفة عند كلامه على الكسائي إذ قال :" إن الكسائي بمنهاجه وأساليب دراسته مدرسة لها خصائصها ومناهجها فليست المدرسة إلا ..." ثم ساق التعريف .
وقريب من هذا التعريف ما انتهى إليه الدكتور أحمد مختار عمر وهو قوله :" وجود جماعة من النحاة يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج في دراسة النحو ولابد أن يكون هناك الرائد الذي يرسم الخطة ويحدد المنهج والتابعون أو المريدون الذين يعتنقون خطاه ويتبنون منهجه ويعملون على تطويره والدفاع عنه (19).
وقد أخذ محمد حسين آل ياسين في كتاب "الدراسات اللغوية" بتعريف "جوتولد فايل" حيث يقول:" المدرسة في المصطلح العلمي لفظ يطلع على جماعة من الدارسين تشترك في وجهة النظر ويكون لها نهج خاص يؤلف منها جبهة علمية ويربط أفرادها برابط الرأي الموحد "(20).
وقد حاول الدكتور صالح بلعيد الجمع بين التعريفات السابقة فقال إن المدرسة :" كلمة معاصرة تعني الجماعة الذي يشكلون درسا واحدا في بيئة معينة أو بيئات معينة متعددة ويجمعهم نهج واحد أو الاشتراك في وجهة النظر التي تؤلف جبهة علمية واحدة ووجود الجماعة الذي يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج ويكون اتفاقهم على الأصول لا الفروع وعلى رأس المدرسة من يرسم الخطة ويحدد والمنهج وهو الشيخ أو الرئيس والمريدون الذي يعتنقون خطاه ويعملون على تطويرها الدفاع عنه "(21).
ونلاحظ أن هذا إلى التوصيف أقرب منه إلى التعريف حيث جمع ما في التعريفات الأخرى وضمنها هذا التوصيف .
ونخلص مما سبق إلى أن هذه التعريفات تتفق على وجود جماعة من الناس يعتنقون منهجا محددا ذا خصائص ومميزات يؤمنون به ويدافعون عنه وإن لم تجمعهم وحدة جغرافية ولا يشترط الاتفاق على الفروع بل يكفي اتفاقهم على أصول المنهج .
والتعريفات السابقة بهذا المعنى أو قريبة منه جدا ، ولذا نلاحظ أنها بدأت بـ :" جماعة " أو " طائفة " وبدأت أحيانا بـ :" الاشتراك في وجهة نظر " أو " اتجاه له خصائص " وهما – الجماعة والمنهج – الركنان الأساسيان في التعريفات السابقة .
هل توجد مذاهب نحوية أو مدارس نحوية ؟
أولا : المذاهب النحوية
جرى الأقدمون على أن هناك مذهبا في النحو يسمى المذهب البصري ومذهبا آخر في النحو يسمى المذهب الكوفي كما ذكرت بعض مؤلفات الأقدمين أن هناك نحاة مصريين ونحاة أندلسيين (22).

ثانيا : المدارس النحوية
تعددت آراء الباحثين المحدثين في المدارس النحوية بين الإثبات والرفض على ما يأتي :

الرأي الأول :
أنه لا توجد مدارس نحوية إطلاقا وإنما هي تجمعات جغرافية ولا يوجد مدارس نحوية تتميز كل منها بأسلوبها الخاص ومنهاجها الذاتي وتطبق هذه المجموعات أصولا واحدة وإن اختلفت في الفروع وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ سعيد الأفغاني والأستاذ على أبو المكارم (23).

الرأي الثاني :
أنه لا توجد إلا مدرسة نحوية واحدة هي مدرسة البصرة فقط وأنكر هذا الفريق وجود مدرسة الكوفة وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ الدكتور إبراهيم السامرائي وقد سبقه إلى القول بهذا "جوتولد فايل" (24).

الرأي الثالث :
أثبت فريق ثالث من النحويين وجود مدرستين بصرية وكوفية وتردد في القبول بوجود مدرسة بغدادية ويمثل هذا القول الدكتور مهدي المخزومي ، وقد تابعوا في ذلك الزبيدي في طبقاته حيث نظم أفراد المدرسة البغدادية مع رجال المدرسة البصرية والكوفية على حسب اتجاهه وميوله(25).
وما قيل في المدرسة البغدادية ينطبق على بقية المدارس كالأندلسية والمصرية.

الترجيح بين الآراء :
إذا دققنا النظر في الأوصاف التي يطلقها القدماء على الدراسات النحوية غير البصرية والكوفية وجدناها لا تخرج عن وصف هذه الدراسات أو الدارسين لأنهم خلطوا المذهبين أو النحوين أو مزجوا بينهما وهذا يدعونا إلى أنه ليس هناك خلاف بين هذا النحو والنحوين الآخرين خلافا لما نراه من الفروق بين منهجي البصرة والكوفة .
وهذا ينتهي بنا إلى القول بأنه ليس في النحو العربي إلا مدرستان أو مذهبان فقط هما البصرة والكوفة (26).
------------
(1)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي ص / 13 بتصرف .
(2)· نقلته عن : طبقات فحول الشعراء 1 / 12
(3)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 7 بتصرف .
(4)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(5)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(6)· المرجع السابق· ص / 10
(7)· نقلته عنه : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170
(8)· نلقته عن : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170-171
(9)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 11
(10)· المرجع السابق· ص / 11
(11)· المرجع السابق· ص / 12
(12)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(13)· نقلته عن : تاريخ الأدب العربي· 2 / 124 – 125
(14)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 13
(15)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 144
(16)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(17) المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(18)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(19)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(20)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(21)· المرجع السابق· ص / 149 – 150
(22)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 145
(23)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 151 نقله عن طبقات الزبيدي· ص / 213 – 253
(24)· أنظر مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د.عبدالله الخثران والمدارس النحوي د. خديجة الحديثي .
(25)· المرجعان السابقان والمدارس النحوية أسطورة وواقع د. إبراهيم السامرائي ص / 139 – 141
(26)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 16
------------
أحمد بن محمد مجرشي
طالب ماجستير قسم النحو والصرف وفقه اللغة

 
Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack