is effexor better than cymbalta beconase aq cost without insurance cytotec pct buy how to take colchicine for acute gout rhinocort aqua nasal spray dose lanoxin for sale australia birth control pills cozaar pastillas para tener una ereccion how to get a prescription for propecia buy serophene from india what does cephalexin treat effexor xr missed dose symptoms gasex sold over counter side effects of doxycycline hyclate 100mg cap retino a cream price safe place to buy viagra pharmacy that sells brand cialis levitra australia cost buy generic yasmin finpecia online coupon code can i buy naproxen over the counter uk order aciphex lowest price can you buy kamagra in ireland pharmacy cleocin phone orders citalopram tablets 20mg side effects pharmacy has best price benfotiamine sale calan buy altace online pharmacy omnicef where can i buy it glucophage without content validity missed provera dose sumycin by mail order where do i buy nitrofurantoin order non generic hyzaar walgreens generic claritin astelin discount coupon buy suhagra hong kong can you buy lopressor blood pressure cholesterol dosage prinivil online amantadine generic drug cephalexin non perscription countries buy aciclovir tablets 800mg pharmacy buy prescription drugs online reviews buy abilify 5mg online our canadian cheap dulcolax sale uk lithium 1000ah propranolol prescriptions cheap aricept uk how to spot fake viagra can you buy pharmacy zovirax ointment best online pharmacy generic nolvadex order cod buy endep artane usage de'tourne' xeloda shortage brand cialis costco discount tetracycline azulfidine for dogs side effects best site to buy cymbalta bentyl capsules 10 mg will generic aciphex available pharmacy support services cerritos ca pyridium now co uk how much does cardura cost parlodel tablets uses cost of acivir pills without insurance best place to buy zoloft in australia clomid coupons atacand missed dose mifepristone and prostaglandin buy online diarex medication overnight delivery buy geriforte next day western drug benfotiamine acticin india kytril paypal aristocort woldwide shipping bactroban price philippines buy trandate in uk dutas cost prednisolone 40mg nitrofurantoin medline india cheap indocin mg enzyte reviews forums zyvox iv administration rate buy prazosin in india online abilify by mail aripoprazole canadian isoniazid pill shop discount code original phexin online natural anti-anxiety drugs for dogs order grifulvin v cheap can you buy nootropil half price ponstel accutane 40 mg a day results ventolin 100 mg cipro visa buy rhinocort mexican pharmacies reglan prescription coupon sinequan overseas what are the side effects of lithium withdrawal viagra para mujeres venta order benicar us lincocin con eucalipto dosis zyvox 800 mg atarax online overnight olanzapine sale cephalexin 500 mg canine dose astrazeneca nexium discount card buy genuine minocycline uk para que se usa la crema nizoral can order viagra professional online pyridium 100mg tablets buy painkillers online forum cymbalta and alcohol blackouts metoclopramide prokinetic mechanism of action what does silagra do institute of nuclear medicine and allied sciences (inmas) delhi snafi price in egypt propecia 0.25mg effective glucotrol dosage information canadian superstore online pharmacy reviews viagra buy diclofenac gel 80 mg online order topamax 120 mg low accutane tramadol and alcohol uk where can you buy nizoral como comprar viagra no brasil dramamine tablets cost of hyaluronic acid without insurance acheter une livebox 2 canadian viagra paypal how to use liv 52 can zantac 75 get you high midamor for men in usa buspar discount coupons mircette discount mail order generic zocor buy liv 80 mg online recommended dose of benadryl for infants buying risperdal using paypal cefixime cost without insurance opiniones ivalia dermis order diclofenac pharmacy visa how long does it take for bupropion sr to work trazodone drugs abuse cheap caverta no prescription remeron tablets uk lithium traduzione in italiano resources for acai cheap dutasteride uk where to buy minocycline hydromorphone injection diclofenaco sodico gel embarazo what is midamor tablets buy bentyl in australia hair loss after using accutane oz pills plus viagra tadacip pills sweat which uk site to buy naprosyn geriforte canada overnight delivery tramadol dosage for dogs xanax wiki sk price increase kamagra oral jelly cialis sublingual 5mg tablets is my finpecia fake overseas pharmacy no prescription lopid what does zofran do anxiety medication for dogs over the counter buy alli weight loss uk clinically order vpxl online no presctiption altace online overnight azithromycin 250mg tablets used for buy antabuse online from canada zyrtec medicine while pregnant all types of drugs seroflo barato what is plavix made of can you buy himplasia over the counter in germany mail-order mobic atacand usa get aceon las vegas pastillas alli en mexico side effects of coming off prozac metformin uses medication best place to buy proventil in usa cozaar tablets on line to buy prevacid generic 2013 drugs how to buy hydrocodone online how to get adderall in london confido coupons ortho tri-cyclen online generic pariet where to get venlor generic wikipedia drugs buy ginseng from india what is bactrim ds 800 mg used for buy lithium carbonate capsules los algodones mary;s pharmacy viagra 3days delivery can you get betnovate over the counter phenergan without a prescription elavil amitriptyline medication pamelor generic 2013 drugs dose of bactrim ds for uti zestril with paypal payment best pharmacy to order brand viagra eltroxin no prescription phone in order for deltasone generic motilium india can i order aceon no prescription in the usa to buy actonel in uk do i need a prescription for kamagra gold colored contact lenses no prescription needed cheap genuine maxalt online abilify reviews schizophrenia lansoprazole 30 mg dosage side effects of thalidomide treating myeloma voltaren medicine india where can i buy metformin from pharmacys that carry prednisone without a prescription online imuran purchase where can i buy alligator meat in los angeles viagra cialis cheaper say doctor get prescription viagra buy cialis soft in ireland levaquin for sinus infection trazodone mail order compare prices lukol viagra side effects in women buy imitrex perth australia alli gators florida grill and bar can you order keflex zofran melt cardizem iv bolus dose generic cialis sublingual buy wellbutrin sr paypal accepted buy unisom online pharmacy cost of tofranil amoxicillin nhs side effects discount nizoral of canada lopid 600 prescription tetracycline acne claritin online in us speman for men in usa flagyl side effects in women lozol prescribing information acheter xenical sans ordonnance safe viagra no precription combivent inhaler cost generic name for benzac what types of minocin are there where do i alesse in canada taking viagra drinking alcohol nizoral generic shampoo liv ordering no prescription ortho tri-cyclen perth australia buy pravachol 5 medrol uk brand name buy over the counter yasmin online buy calan 10 light blue oval pill watson 540 one side kosovarja chat western drug toradol topical finasteride cream canada order bupropion atarax no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy can i get advair diskus mail-order terramycin generic actos 30 mg legal buy brand cialis online canada ajanta pharma limited dahej is my zoloft dose too high pharmacy has best price aleve estrace cream reviews order viagra plus online uk generic geriforte syrup in usa use hydrochlorothiazide coupon online where to buy fertomid drugs online buy cheap paroxetine pills accutane cost no insurance micardis tablets on line to buy bactrim forte uses anafranil reviews for depression ephedraxin cost comparison female viagra 10 mg cost minocin canada head office generic uk paypal doxycycline cheap luvox sale uk rid canadian pharmacy emails 25 mg synthroid and weight loss voltaren tablets 75mg cheap accutane 400 mg purchase generic ginseng side effects of lipitor 40 mg fucidin over the counter india can you take coumadin daily diclofenaco pensa 10 mg emulsion cutanea yagara lowest price ralista cheap price directions for taking 100mg viagra how to by zetia online himcocid online bestellen flomax medicine children citalopram 40mg canada avalide online pharmacy uk zyvox pills drugstore dog earthworm medicine online cymbalta aux usa get doxycycline toronto is strattera a class 2 drug buy tofranil in usa buy nolvadex online india can endep 10 mg cause weight gain where can i get rogaine 2 avapro direct pharmacy safe place order olanzapine is generic hyaluronic acid effective finast no prescription compare prices what does diamox do for altitude sickness medrol steroids and alcohol why is there a shortage of ditropan trazodone canada buy norvasc 5 very cheap vantin vytorin drugstore com lasix overnight no rx what is tramadol hydrochloride used for cialis tadalafil 20 mg nedir suhagra refill pack where can i get viagra professional what is zerit costco uk lopressor on line medicine for abortion in first month lamisil pill canadian buy plendil with cheap aleve no prescription levitra pill shortage procardia xl zero order alli diet plan book silver slimming tablets they safe buy lotrisone over counter prescription secure medical online pharmacy lamictal suppliers overseas allegra 180 mg fexofenadine comprar metformin en argentina best resources for aspiring writers nitroglycerin next day shipping how to purchase prednisolone tadalis sx 20 mg rosuvastatin api price voltaren gel dosage information brand viagra offers top 10 online anafranil sites order erexin online no prescription with a visa horse meds online canada how much does lipitor cost at walgreens trazodone pas cher italie wellbutrin prescription only buy generic zovirax ointment where can i get some floxin brand cialis 40 mg pilex spain research grade asacol flomax over the counter equivalent discount code for lexapro fucidin side effects children first medicine online pharmacy store reviews buying serophene in manchester cheap viagra order online top 20 pharmaceutical companies uk deltasone pharmacy online buy aleve visa purinethol generico italiano no prescription fast alli buy real viagra no prescription generic fertomid in usa hyzaar online store wellbutrin medicine side effects rogaine 2 sold over counter most common side effects of paroxetine yasmin dosage instructions cialis prices ireland hoodia sale australia strattera 10 mg cost where can i get rogaine 5 cabergoline pregnancy fda best generic colchicine review what is propranolol used for calcium carbonate canada overnight delivery generic v-gel in usa how long does it take for furosemide to work donde comprar metformina en colombia mircette reviews buy prograf 40 redustat precio mexico cheap blopress 100 mg over the counter estrace common dosage for celexa what is the classification for aricept buy benicar cheap olmesartan emsam medication side effects blopress canada drug store where can i buy terramycin for cats florinef spc floxin dosage forms met rx buy cefadroxil australia price can you split topamax pills cymbalta with no perscription flovent overseas tijuana pharmacy phone number zolpidem tartrate 5mg ambien mail-order seroquel can you buy albendazole online generic pills for advair diskus diclofenac uk buy buy flagyl online overnight prescription solutions login page will zyvox go generic ciprofloxacin side effects joint pain where to benzac bentyl pharmacies 20mg chloramphenicol over counter buy generic advair diskus online with prescription can you buy levitra plus in ireland 20mg 100mg cheapest prinivil tablets uk american gyne-lotrimin cialis south africa online safe cordarone buy levaquin generic canada can you order estrace cheap prescriptions sunglasses online types birth control pills india doxazosin dose titration elocom keno"cs 0 1 boots pharmacy opening hours ireland levitra with out perscription long do take tamoxifen pct buy cheap diflucan online betnovate n cream in pakistan cost of abilify 2mg paxil vs celexa weight gain dosage doxycycline and lyme disease online pharmacy allopurinol canada rx reviews effexor xr discounts geriforte syrup reviews purchase fml forte online bystolic dosage recommended nolvadex australia customs buy aristocort pills over counter acivir pills geriforte for men in usa seroquel overnight shipping cheap prednisone 20 mg finpecia tablets+side effects zetia side effects leg pain buy flomaxtra shatavari medication pravachol 40 mg generic healthy meds viagra blopress lawsuit settlements i pill viagra plus website yagara no prescription compare prices antibiotics without prescriptions usa vasodilan suppositories buy generic viagra 150 mg pills ephedraxin lawsuit settlements where can i buy provera in canada what is pariet medication prograf medicine children use nolvadex coupon online keppra 100 mg yan etkileri purchase liv what is finasteride 5 mg lanoxin uk online buy tetracycline without a subscription consumer reports rx relief card amaryl glimepiride tablets levitra cost canadian what is zyban dosage yasmin birth control online us discount canadian pharmacy toprol xl tretinoin 0,05 medicine online lamisil oral medicine finast delivery nitroglycerin buy usa buy smart drugs online uk clomid ovulation predictor calculators is it safe to buy birth control pills online buy usa diamox overnight can you order biaxin meclizine medicine nitrofurantoin uti pregnancy where cane i buy diflucan online clomid calculator ovulation calendar how to take clomid 50 mg pct wellbutrin and celexa weight loss dramamine 100mg buy no prescription needed kamagra without discount coupons for viagra buy lexapro online pharmacy pharmacy has best price bactroban how much does vermox cost what types of cipro are there canada drugs trimox with prescription ginette-35 pas cher what is the generic for actonel 150 mg cheap glycomet pills buy paxil in india online cleocin gel free shipping frye boots promo code indian pharmacy council registration micronase canadian pharmacy buy cheap cefixime pills cipro looking for what class of drugs is baclofen in how should lamictal be discontinued lotensin with no rx ciprofloxacin side effects tendon minocin billig kaufen benicar side effects anxiety cozaar com dosage tesco pharmacy order diclofenac amy search mp3 cheap alligator hairclips for hair bows generic substitute for valtrex order amaryl lowest price buy vytorin with no rx buy cheap lopid using pay pal generic prednisone for sale on line sinequan spain over counter buy chloromycetin boots triamterene hydrochlorothiazide contraindications avandamet tablets price calcium carbonate non perscription countries warfarin dosing algorithm can you get high off metoclopramide hydrochloride canadian alliance party policies retin-a ge medicine online buy cialis black online tamoxifen cost avapro on line no script lasix australia pharmacy how to get rumalaya forte drug buy cytoxan in ireland viagra sublingual tablets price wellbutrin 100 sr where to buy micronase hcg clomid post cycle therapy buy premarin without prescription us avapro in canada purchase allegra caverta discount what does lithium look like in its pure form levitra side effects blindness evista complaints generic for altace 5mg estrace generic reviews free sample viagra coupon casodex online in usa can you get apcalis sx buy aciphex 15mg online can you buy albendazole trusted is 20 mg citalopram a high dose citalopram hydrobromide tablets 20mg proscar coupons low price retin-a 0,025 uk can you take expired alli pills doxycycline treatment lyme disease dogs generic antivert paypal suppliers of clonidine in us lamisil pills for sale how many acai berry tablets to take aristocort italiano current price cialis serve medicamento sertralina 50mg where to buy protonix online canada viramune xr patient assistance glaxosmithkline ventolin hfa coupons buy alphagan lowest price lincocin spain generic avodart medication american viagra online best place to buy ceftin in uk legal buy antibiotics canada didronel phone orders how to buy cialis online safely low cost does alli work prescription drugs relafen online ordering prescription diflucan online buy effexor xr lowest price best generic diovan sites menosan uk next day delivery doxycycline 100mg low cost overnight calan eurax delivery london cost of alligator tags in texas can you buy dog medicine online how to take promethazine syrup rulid 100 mg roxithromycine what is the generic version of keppra trental medication uses purchase kamagra pills ciplox discounts codes what does atarax feel like side effects buy brand advair diskus visa diclofenac online buy tenormin from toradol medicine side effects buy cheap keftab all types abana pills zantac online order canadian internet policy and public interest clinic where doxycycline order minipress online uk sublingual sale cialis pills tadalafil kamagra pharmacies ipharmacy prevacid prescription strength non prescription duphalac benzac reviews philippines altace pharmacies what is viagra soft tablet what are the side effects of generic zocor buy diarex next day low cost propranolol is glucotrol xl legal in uk online forum overnight serevent cod ventolin user reviews best viagra deals is dipyridamole available over the counter buy paxil with paypal doxycycline hyclate 100mg drug what works better than accutane what is floxin pills used for generic coumadin overnite shipping quiero comprar levitra plus phenergan during labor and delivery effects cialis online without prescription american sarafem omnicef australia seroquel discount card organic pomegranate extract powder zestril 40 mg tablet cost of viagra sublingual without insurance dostinex best online non prescription pharmacy minocin cost in canada elocon dosering where to buy augmentin accutane tablets price flomax and saw palmetto drug interactions cheap bupropion online nolvadex better than clomid cheapest atrovent xerograx pastillas para adelgazar proguanil chloroquine prices discount indocin mexican pharmacy no prescription zovirax biaxin medicine children generic bupropion sr 150 mg cheap birth control online no prescription lincocin online pharmacy uk can i buy a visa gift card online with paypal fast viramune deleviery reducing dosage of prednisone chloroquine without insurance purchase kamagra soft cheap cytotec birth control online us genuine ponstel best price alavert generico italiano acheter revia vivitrol naltrexone atorlip-5 from china buy antibiotics mastercard how long does it take for diovan hct to work aldactone usa sale hair loss after taking accutane dipyridamole mist canada buy mobicosa melbourne amantadine no prescription overnight delivery safe place order furosemide lasix prices cvs what is blopress plus descargar el libro culturismo sin tonterias gratis citalopram pills 20 mg buy parlodel visa nausea from flagyl robaxin with no perscription how to take midamor mg cheap pfizer viagra uk compazine max dose metformin pills not dissolving can i take two 5mg cialis seroflo online in us cheap usa zyprexa online singulair prices at costco lov cost bactroban is micronase a prescription drug order femara uk ordering bactrim cozaar pharmacy coupons what is zocor how to buy strattera in london lotrisone cream 45gm exelon medication canada what types of atorlip-5 are there cheap coreg usa start allopurinol after gout attack viagra generic online canada generic clozaril cost buy acticin cream 30g ceftin mg canada cheapest place to buy zovirax buy alli 80 mg online cleocin phosphate in d5w canada drugs female viagra with prescription buy hyzaar from mexico online can you buy cialis sublingual in ireland online drug shop tadalafil can you take micronase daily el padre chelo viagra boots altace online pharmacy uk albenza package insert brand mirapex buy best place to buy sustiva cost of mirapex what is the dosage for dilantin where to buy antabuse online hyzaar ds vs hyzaar most reliable place to buy norvasc online lotrisone cream directions reglan without online buy tadacip visa order viagra jelly piroxicam capsules tretinoin 0,025 online forum best pct for anavar only cycle abana for men sale in uk bentyl side effects webmd zyvox 1200 mg tablet finax refills periactin without a prescription from uk asacol 400 mg spc cheapest prometrium tablets uk generic from geriforte syrup avinor vigra lufthavn ultra low dose moduretic licensed pharmacy colchicine is there a type of viagra for women paroxetine cr 12.5mg tablet what is the drug accutane for olmesartan side effects alcohol best place buy eulexin pct buy lamisil from canada most reliable place to buy finax online black market viagra uk generic name for noroxin viagra professional pct buy avandamet refills order retin-a ge buy avapro cialis vente libre quebec india levitra super active price can we trust voveran sr online where to buy actos ointment forzest western australia cheap rumalaya pills awp ranbaxy pharmaceuticals doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg order cordarone online in usa best place to buy plavix in india buy accutane patch online fertomid purchase olanzapine online price lexapro where to buy in canada trazodone uk online max viagra pills levlen limited india buy generic plavix online ampicillin shelf life hytrin with american express order artane overnight generic viagra names what is paroxetine what is diclofenaco what is actos 15 mg used for cheapest ginseng tablets uk buy chloromycetin ophthalmic ointment propecia costco canada order non generic cardura is it safe to order remeron order tenormin overnight what is the generic for biaxin voltaren sale buy lipothin without a script can you get addicted to zofran what is the medication apo amitriptyline used for cleocin gel in the uk now minocin without perscription lipitor next day shipping discount code for pilex trazodone desyrel and mirtazapine remeron stopping lasix weight gain buy canada no prescription for prednisone propecia no prescription needed can aldactone cause weight loss colchicine buyers buy regenon amsterdam pharmacy tijuana phone number order prednisolone 5mg dogs generic florinef in usa no prescription proscar sale fexofenadine hydrochloride pregnancy desyrel drug oversea what is saw palmetto in tamil cloridrato sertralina pode ser usado emagrecer hytrin ordering online pharmacy lamictal generic wikipedia drugs best place buy sinemet how much is phexin tablets artane medicine online vantin prix en pharmacie en france drugstore cowboy watch online what is atacand side effects buy acai australia dulcolax dosage rxlist periactin non prescription pills buy wellbutrin usa where to get lozol i pill aceon website sky pharmacy buy albenza online pharmacy albendazole minomycin tablets side effects buy ortho tri cyclen buy bactroban with paypal benicar 40 mg pharmacy mevacor express canada lansoprazole dose range combivent to buy uk buy prevacid mg online for buy rosuvastatin online india discount female cialis viagra capsules price is generic yasmin effective cheap bactroban generic nizagara tablets 100 mg piracetam uk powder sex pills for women how much is medrol dosepak geriforte prices cvs tadacip weekender tablets suhagra direct pharmacy best place buy cleocin gel pct buy alli online from australia decadron results forum india venlor price taxonomies for primate order differing in replacement of tarsiers costco pharmacy online phone will i gain weight on 25mg of seroquel forzest prix en pharmacie en france prazosin shortage where to buy viagra professional ointment wellbutrin canada head office generic abilify 2mg maxalt migraine headaches diabecon prices at costco differin gel long term side effects retin-a ge buy canada can you buy grifulvin v side effects drug actonel purchase buy pariet online no prescription us brand l-tryptophan buy generic motrin for sale on line how to use urispas is generic zantac safe during pregnancy how to import nolvadex norvasc medicine information calan online sales hytrin reviews what is flagyl 400mg for buy generic zithromax cheapest pravachol tablets uk what is lithium ion made of online pharmacy emsam cheapest place buy propecia can you drink alcohol with fexofenadine xeloda patient forum prednisone precio mexico topamax tablets scored allopurinol dosage instructions how to purchase zyloprim maxalt generic cost beat way to order caverta 1 order acticin online pharmacy singulair barato generic viagra brands pharmacy mexico atarax best place buy wellbutrin sr pct cheap cephalexin buy online phenergan generic promethazine cytotec abortion dose cymbalta drug usage flagyl in canada what is caverta drugs angelica and ginseng traditional chinese medicine ordering topamax online prevacid not generic online paxil no prescription the online drugstore haridra cheap generic himcocid betapace next day delivery lisinopril buy online maximum daily dose of ginseng lipitor canada purchase iv augmentin renal dose generic name for reglan cytotec for sale in cebu buy generic avodart with bonus betnovate n steroid cream over counter flomax omnicef dosage rxlist buy colchicine in mexico amitriptyline in the uk zofran usage snovitra super power lawsuit settlements buy cialis for women online tetracycline 40 mg dose fastest kamagra gold uk delivery where to buy flonase generic prescription claravis vs accutane viagra swissmedic glucotrol xl medication online lexapro vs zoloft anxiety nimotop prices at costco medicine ciprofloxacin dexamethasone used metformin hcl oral tablet 500 mg craigslist newcastle indiana cheap capoten india buy femara tablets online sarafem by mail free lantus insulin coupons tulasi telugu movie online youtube buy skelaxin tablets online how long for finasteride to take effect generic premarin 1.25 tenormin from canadian pharmacy buy generic revia online bactroban now buy genuine fluoxetine uk buy aleve hong kong uti treatment antibiotic cipro dosage gout medication allopurinol tretinoin 0,05 pill shortage zyprexa 10mg olanzapine low dose amitriptyline pain blood zoloft 50 mg tablets best place buy rosuvastatin western drug diltiazem buy arjuna generic pamelor usa buy lotensin 10 mg how much does wellbutrin cost at target side effects of pilex ointment identify digoxin pills proscar annual sales adalat 20 mg xl order alli rx where to buy lotensin with visa plavix from mexico acquistare meclizine in italia risperdal online legally can i buy nolvadex over the counter generic uk paypal cialis florida arjuna wellbutrin sr 150mg buy sertraline online order tricor online in usa a safe low-cost and sustainable lithium-ion polymer battery research grade prograf viagra over the counter walgreens pills viagra jet lag golombek no prescription needed accutane pills what drug category is prazosin strattera fast mexico cefixime gonorrhea treatment dosage zithromax limited india online canadian drugs paypal aricept generic release date rumalaya forte tablets on line to buy flonase reviews webmd seroquel online canadian pharmacy no prescription generic cialis shipped from canada where can i buy tetracycline in canada metformin hydrochloride 850 mg cymbalta mg tablet can you order malegra fxt lithium ion battery florida calan now co uk order bystolic cheap list names of birth control pills brands getting cordarone in australia medrol 16 mg italiano yasmin birth control cost canada pamelor limited india discount canadian pharmacy nitroglycerin lamictal bouton visage nolvadex tablets buy uk harga cialis 50 mg levitra vs. viagra effectiveness comprar viagra canada buy voltaren without prescription harga voltaren salep fast flomax deleviery where to buy cheap generic retin-a ge quibron-t side effects uk to buy lincocin oracea doxycycline 40 mg kamagra reviews uk ofloxacin tinidazole side effects worldwide pharmacy benadryl buy over the counter depakote online vendita viagra generico in farmacia levitra super active mail order voveran bonus pills prescription lexapro buy snovitra super power paypal finast tablets on line to buy procardia best price furosemide australia pharmacy billig bactrim online kaufen bristol-myers squibb ireland leopardstown buy accutane online canada (pill box) where can i buy phenergan for kids zolpidem online pharmacy keppra price buy ventolin cheapest zolpidem 10mg tablets buy hytrin tablets online all types nootropil pills can you take pyridium daily orlistat medication side effects buy periactin paypal best site to buy kytril buy cheap tricor online buy generic propranolol online sex pill for men last long sex comprar pilas energizer ultimate lithium evista dosage adults buy pure acai berry uk safe suprax buy safe buy aldactone online clomid cycle after steroids fosamax tablets side effects buy zyprexa no prescription fast delivery buy effexor xr online from usa how to get seroflo drug haldol online bestellen canadian pharmacy online viagra super active biaxin online india periactin online canadian pharmacy + finasteride + "no prescription" how much will lozol cost can you buy zestril over the counter cialis soft over counter ampicillin stock in ethanol what is bactroban ointment for where to buy propecia in canada safely us online pharmacy no prescription tetracycline non prescription gyne-lotrimin pharmacy tetrocycline vs doxycycline order low cost malaria tablets how to use metformin to get pregnant accutane name india online fluoxetine with no prescription celexa mail order india all types serpina pills where to get codeine cough syrup online what is the correct dosage of differin is lozol a sulfa drug where can i buy trimethoprim antibiotic sulfamethoxazole po metoprolol half life what is combivent prescribed for 100 mg alli levaquin dose for uti saw palmetto canada head office erythromycin dosage for ear infection buy premarin in ireland blue pill with watson 503 order strattera from buy generic lamisil tablets online no prescription cheapest cephalexin 1000 doxycycline malaria india nexium wiki buying phenamax in manchester pfizer revatio patient assistance how to take diflucan for candida nature;s science siberian ginseng reviews target com pharmacy list generic drugs can you buy septilin shipping estrace cream price online taking 500 mg metformin twice a day brand levitra delivery is depakote a schedule 2 drug buy starlix hong kong finpecia online pharmacy prednisone 10mg reviews to buy prednisolone drug discount where purchase v-gel estrofem 2mg tablets clomid or femara for infertility get ophthacare las vegas atacand 8mg tablets billig lexapro online kaufen can men take hydroxycut max for women plavix cost comparison generic ajanta pharma kandivali job professional medicines what is carafate suspension for dogs viagra without prescriptions canada is buspar better than paxil mentat ds syrup to buy from europe where do i buy paroxetine primamedics online pharmacy diprosone side effects cream purchase betnovate pills erythromycin stearate tablets 500mg spc overnight online nolvadex without elavil 10mg for headaches buy lexapro tablets online viagra generic 2010 nootropil where can i buy it sustiva sales synthroid medication side effects what is the generic brand for cialis nexium indian pharmacy top 10 online lady era sites compazine now diclofenac medication order viagra soft online in canada cystone maximum dosage buy dilantin mg online for coumadin canada prescription genuine anacin best price prilosec annual sales periactin medication overnight delivery is zantac over the counter medicine ordering himcolin benicar medication manufacturer cialis comprar brasil what otc drugs work like viagra innopran xl brands india zerit sale cheap elimite 100 mg walmart pharmacy drug list 2010 is it safe to buy birth control online buy calan from mexico online cabgolin pill shortage how much benadryl do i give a 100 pound dog cheapest place buy alli pills mail-order trazodone nitroglycerin for sale uk prevacid italiano hebal viagra excel reviews doxycycline monohydrate 100mg for acne cytotec pills dosage online pharmacy no prescription needed bupron sr billig acivir pills online kaufen prescription flagyl online tofranil tablets uk generic pills for trileptal uk drugs law use of misoprostol for pph endep usa how to use injectable lasix voltaren pharmacy gel anafranil tablets us online hydrochlorothiazide canada no prescription aricept price costco ranitidine shopping 77 canada pharmacy phone number how to use mestinon top 10 online albendazole sites generic artane safe liquid crestor review methotrexate dose calculator ectopic flonase shortage 2012 lamisil online pharmacy per pill order there generic hyzaar buy zestoretic for daily use blopress online price buy alphagan inhaler canada mail-order risperdal water pills safe while breastfeeding antabuse and cough medicine doxycycline alcohol interactions buy brand advair diskus from mexico online singulair allergy medicine children buy cozaar mg online buy cardura online no prescription united states imitrex dosing for migraines us online pharmacy no prescription trazodone buy speman hong kong hydrocortisone injection in spine side effects of doxycycline hyclate and alcohol codeine aspirin australia how much does alli cost uk good canadian pharmacy online proscar medication dose tadalista super active review zithromax online australia aceon prix en pharmacie en france nizoral dose cheap himcocid free delivery safe erythromycin buy nexium medication cost noroxin cost comparison treating cancer in dogs with prednisone benefits of aspirin in pregnancy buy adalat online cheap what is singulair 4mg chewable tablets buy elimite 5 acheter pas cher buspar endep shelf life zyvox 600 mg tablets side effects where can i get zebeta kamagra chewable tablets review cardizem in the uk now ordering calander nitrofurantoin 100mg cap alvo buy trental with visa alavert drug schedule azithromycin and alcohol pfizer what is doxycycline used for treatment vibramycin buy converse shoes online australia fucidin side effects skin cialis 40 mg reviews cialis tadalafil 20 mg bula indian generics online kytril daily cialis reviews pakistan pharmacy online how to order eldepryl online buy nolvadex usa desyrel prescription only discount adalat torsemide medicine online pfizer pharmaceuticals address what does cytotec pill look like marksman stats hellgate london desyrel tablets from buy best place buy speman pct para que se usa terramycin buy fluoxetine without a subscription upper back pain relief medicine where elavil viagra jelly drugs aciphex fedex delivery rx order erection packs 2 buy viagra levothroid generic drug allegra over the counter generic acheter du baclofene en belgique best place to buy wellbutrin sr how to by prilosec online can i buy fluconazole online luvox uk buy side effects of tricor tablets decadron dose im my evecare coupons canadian meds sarasota nolvadex uses medication buy advair diskus lowest price cozaar losartan blood pressure where to get fluoxetine buy brahmi tablets cheap tretinoin 0,05 uk exelon for sale australia withdrawal from strattera protonix over counter uk leadmedic online pharmacy prednisone 5mg dose pack cystone order online buy generic minocycline online no prescription buy tamoxifen online no prescription uk desyrel 100 mj yan etkileri nolvadex 10 mg cost vermox plus bebidas alcoholicas what is the difference between wellbutrin sr vs. xl purchase american ginseng root how much is a prescription of singulair buy citalopram in uk without prescription nitroglycerin comprar clonidine no prrescription renagel generic name dipyridamole 75 mg tablet aciclovir buy uk florida actos augmentin 1 gm singulair asthma medication steroid pharmacy support specialist salary promethazine hcl 25mg side effects cam you buy coreg canadian finpecia buy australia can you get styplon pariet tablets 10mg ordering voltaren gel lipitor without prescription will generic avalide available where can i buy live chickens in los angeles arimidex buy dipyridamole without a prescription from canadian pharmacy my alli weight loss coupon where to claritin order trial erection packs 1 online no presctiption cheap glucophage sr what is the generic for flomax ordering rx from canada online motilium with no prescription online rogaine 2 india can you die from drinking on antibiotics terramycin mexico differin 0.3 discount pharmacy that sells arimidex unique hoodia slimming pills cordarone dose de charge acfa xenical prix discount what is effexor xr pills used for generic prograf us maximum lasix dose per day cheapest place to buy paroxetine low price phenamax uk orlistat side effects forum clozaril uk sale what is beconase aq pills used for cozaar in the uk now yasmin mogahed new zealand ciproxin 250 dose yasmin ed tablets side effects propecia discount indian generics online voltaren ugg boots online shop promo code pharmacy technician online schools cost hydrochlorothiazide online in usa allegra usa cvs prices finasteride tablets online shop accutane reviews and dosage zentel apteka canadian pharmacy relafen buy reglan capsules unisom pill shortage dutas next day delivery how to get a prescription for birth control pills online american kamagra oral jelly prevacid pills online in the australia order lamisil canada ginseng medicine lipitor generico italiano compare prices prandin periactin from florinef pharmacy prices list order suprax on line canada abilify generic alternative buy sildenafil citrate paypal tadalofil online uk cheap zentel worm medicine commercial speman billig kaufen generic celebrex no prescription what is didronel used for lipothin for sale online canadian pharmacy accutane buy isotretinoin us online pharmacy no prescription lasix where can i buy amaryllis tofranil 40 mg pharmacy common side effects of tofranil mirtazapine withdrawal insomnia co diovan novartis tofranil effective dose doxazosin pills sweat benadryl 100 mg to sleep cytotec medicines side effects clomid women feldene buy on line plavix in the uk now will keflex interfere with birth control pills glycomet best price donde comprar diltiazem buy tamoxifen online usa lipitor from drugs atorvastatin calcium buy viagra over counter tesco generic paxil online pharmacy tamoxifen by mail where to purchase oxytrol van you buy diflucan over the counter in in cheap phenamax no prescription what does cialis pills look like donde comprar viagra sin receta sevilla buy ampicillin uk save overnight acheter pas cher rumalaya forte what is amoxil for lantus insulin no prescription what is the generic form of digoxin there generic clozaril where to buy tamoxifen ointment rhinocort generic 2013 drugs tamoxifen pill canadian mexico abana prescription after sex pill cvs where to buy cheap generic valtrex ordering inderal buy suhagra astrailia como comprar viagra generico en espan~a cipla ltd virgonagar bangalore buy actos 40 discount valtrex online where can i purchase voveran buy brand viagra online mexico no prescription artane cheap uk adavan drug non perscription can bystolic pills be cut in half nolvadex 20 mg dosage donde puedo comprar protonix methotrexate alcohol units rumalaya forte mail order india order nexium on line uk side effects of diflucan excel herbal viagra uk buying floxin in manchester pantoprazole sodium sesquihydrate usp monograph donde comprar xenical argentina paxil 20 mg high buy avapro mg viagra professional usa cvs prices online pharmacy directory is lipitor generic in 2011 didronel online pharmacy uk mentax legal us ordering aygestin buy astelin overseas wellbutrin generic best price baclofen cheap depakote 250mg buy antibiotics online from india pharmacy buy pletal with visa recommend the use of generics viagra drugs mens sex pills uk purchase dipyridamole on line in canada free or low cost zenegra cozaar 10 mg elavil dose for insomnia zyprexa canada price discount citalopram otc detrol online order cheap omnicef usa propranolol for migraines in children cheap glasses without prescriptions unisom in italia avodart drug in mexico pharmacy prope latin definition what is the difference between zanaflex capsules and tablets i pill avapro website mobic prices diflucan online store eulexin 50mg tablets cheapest actonel in the uk online avodart purchase what doses does micardis come in nizagara without script buy acticin cream viagraa helposti sinequan max dose cheap generic clonidine minocin from usa diflucan fluconazole alcohol tac dung cua thuoc ciprobay 500 germany drugstore roxithromycin rxlist seroquel xr product monograph canada long term effects of ibuprofen overdose dramamine brand order cheap diet pills that work fast uk buspar doctors online can you get high off seroquel 300 what are the side effects of provera tablets cheap allinclusive holidays for the future comprar norvasc en argentina is pyridium available over the counter can you get levitra plus over the counter praziquantel tablets for humans postgraduate pharmacy courses in ireland to buy amitriptyline there generic aciphex available anastrozole 1 mg for men trimox online price feldene on line for sale no script mail order xeloda what is premarin cream used for yaz vs yasmin weight gain seroquel reviews finpecia medicine online can i get nolvadex from my doctor how to order viagra in india is it illegal to buy antibiotics from mexico get cymbalta cheaper xenical diet pill buy lov cost brand levitra suppliers of orlistat non generic brand cialis confessions of a viagra salesman acquistare tetracycline in italia lipitor tablets cholesterol best viagra site on internet seroflo refill pack which works better viagra or cialis or levitra viagra sample online bactrim ds australia purchase medrol lowest price overseas pharmacy no prescription forzest cefadroxil over counter over the counter avalide mg hydrochlorothiazide baclofen manufacturer usa plavix from canada pharmacy get nizoral tablets online uroxatral for sale buy nitrofurantoin inhaler canada over the counter roxithromycin generic ponstel switzerland online drugs prednisone lisinopril 100mg tablet how to use nolvadex for gyno lamictal antitrust lawsuit to buy proventil buy flovent perth australia lisinopril generic or brand buy pariet online overnight delivery how to use floxin ear drops ophthacare perth australia prandin tablets on line to buy side effects of mevacor comprar diflucan original how much is topamax without insurance at walmart cheap genuine lipitor online generic propecia india safe
الرئيسية | النادي اللغوي | بحوث نحوية | المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود

صفحة شبكة صوت العربية في فيسبوكtwitterقناة شبكة صوت العربية في يوتيوبشبكة صوت العربية في موقع فليكر

المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود طباعة إرسال إلى صديق
تصنيفات: بحوث نحوية
تقييم المستخدمين: / 54
الكاتب أحمد مجرشي   
الأحد, 10 أبريل 2011 20:07

النشأة :
سيقودنا الحديث عن نشأة هذا المصطلح إلى الحديث عن مناهج النحويين واختلاف آرائهم في الأصول والفروع وهل يرقى هذا الاختلاف لتتميز منه مذاهب ومدارس لها حدود واضحة المعالم أم إن الخلاف يقف عند الفروع لا يتجاوزها فلا يستحق أن يطلع عليها مدرسة أم إنه أقل من ذلك فهو مذهب واحد وطريقة ؟ واحدة تختلف بعض فروعها اختلافا يسيرا داخل نطاق المنهج ولا يخرج عنه .

وقبل التفصيل في هذه المسائل ينبغي أن نعرف إجمالا أن موضوع التقسيم مر بثلاث مراحل هي :

الأولى : تسمية العلماء بأمصارهم وبلدانهم مما يوحي بوجود مذهب خاص بهم أو لا يوحي بذلك .
الثانية : تقسيم مناهجهم وطرقهم وتسميتها بـ " مذهب " وهي مرحلة تالية للمرحلة السابقة .
الثالثة : إطلاق اسم " مدرسة " على المذهب أو على أهل الأمصار وهذه التسمية أطلقت حديثا في الوقت المعاصر.
و بيان ذلك على النحو التالي :

أولا :
"يتضح لنا من عرض مناهج الذين أرخوا للنحو والنحاة من القدماء أنهم اتبعوا في ترتيبهم نسبتهم للبلد الذي ظهروا فيه وتعلموا نحوه ودرسوه أو درّسوه فهم بصريون وكوفيون وأهل بغداد"(1).
"وأول من يلقنا من القدماء محمد بن سلام الجمحي ( 139-231هـ) الذي قال :" وكان لأهل البصرة في العربية قدامة وبالنحو ولغات العرب والغريب عناية "(2).
وترجم لأبي الأسود الدؤلي وعدّه مؤسس علم العربية وليحيى بن يعمر ولعبدالله بن إسحاق الحضرمي ولأبي عمرو بن العلاء وانتهى بالخليل بن أحمد الفراهيدي ولم ينسبهم إلى مدرسة وإنما عدهم من أهل البصرة (3).
وأعقبه أبو محمد عبدالله بن مسلم بن قتيبة الدينوري ( 213 – 276 هـ ) الذي عقد في كتابه "المعارف" بحثا لرواة الشعر وأصحاب الغريب والنحو وترجم بإيجاز لمعظم من اشتهر بهذه العلوم من البصريين والكوفيين ... ويلاحظ في ترجمته لهم أنه لم يذكرهم مقسمين إلى بصريين وكوفيين معتمدا على شهرتهم ولم يسمهم بمذهب أو مدرسة (4).
وجاء بعدهما أبو الطيب عبدالواحد بن علي اللغوي الحلبي ( ت 351هـ ) وألف كتاب "مراتب النحويين" ورتبه حسب الزمن مبتدئا بالبصريين لأن النحو في البصرة كان أقدم نشوءا منه في الكوفة ... وكانت أول إشارة إلى الكوفة عند ترجمته لأبي جعفر الرؤاسي حيث قال : وممن أخذ عن أبي عمرو أبو جعفر الرؤاسي عالم الكوفة (5).
والدليل على أنهم كانوا ينسبون النحاة إلى البلد ويذكرونه في ترجمتهم بحسب البلدان أن أبا الطيب ختم كتابه بعد الانتهاء من ذكر البصريين والكوفيين بقوله :" ولا علم للعرب إلا في هاتين المدينتين "(6).

ثانيا :
كان أبو بكر محمد بن الحسن الزبيدي ( ت 379هـ ) أول من استخدم كلمة " مذهب " عندما ترجم لأصحاب ثعلب فقال عن أبي موسى الحامض : " كان بارعا في اللغة والنحو على مذهب الكوفيين "(7)
"وقال عن ابن كيسان وكان بصريا كوفيا يحفظ القولين ويعرف المذهبين وكان أخذ عن ثعلب والمبرد وكان ميله إلى مذهب البصريين أكثر ... وكان أبو بكر ابن الأنباري شديد التعصب على ابن كيسان والتنقص له وكان يقول : خلط فلم يضبط مذهب الكوفيين ولا مذهب البصريين"(8).

ومن هنا يتضح أن الزبيدي كان أول من قسم النحاة إلى مجموعات بحسب البلدان التي عرفوا بها وكان أول من استخدم عبارات "مذهب الكوفيين" و "مذهب البصريين" و "المذهبين" ويريد بذلك أن النحو متابع
لآراء نحاة الكوفة أو لآراء نحاة البصرة أو لنحاة المدينتين(9).
وجاء بعده ابن النديم· (ت 385 هـ ) واتبع التقسيم نفسه إلا أنه سمى نحاة بغداد " من خلط المذهبين " (10).
وبعدهما جاء أبو البركات الأنباري ( ت 577 هـ ) فقد اتبع في كتابه "نزهة الألباء في طبقات الأدباء" التسلسل الزمني ولم يذكر كلمة مذهب إلى مع البغداديين في الغالب كقوله : " وكان يخلط المذهبين " أو " وكان قيما بمذهب البصريين والكوفيين "(11).

ثالثا :
استحسن الباحثون المحدثون مصطلح "المدرسة" بمعنى المذهب النحوي وقد كانوا في ذلك متأثرين بالغربيين الذين شاع عندهم هذا المصطلح بهذا المفهوم ونجاحه في الدراسات الأدبية فكان عندهم المدرسة الكلاسيكية في الأدب والفن والمدرسة الرومانتيكية والمدرسة الرمزية(12).
وكان من أوائل من استخدم هذا المصطلح "جوتولد فايل" الذي سماهما المدرسة البصرية والمدرسة الكوفية وتبعه في ذلك "بروكلمان" الذي قال : " وقد قسم علماء العربية مذاهب النحو إلى ثلاث مدارس : البصريين والكوفيين ومن مزجوا المذهبين من علماء بغداد "(13).
واستخدم المحدثون الكلمة نفسها ولعل الدكتور مهدي المخزومي أول من تبنى هذه التسمية فسمى أحد كتبه "مدرسة الكوفة ومنهجها في دراسة اللغة والنحو" وألف الدكتور شوقي ضيف كتابا سماه "المدارس النحوية" وألف الدكتور عبدالرحمن السيد كتابا سماه "مدرسة البصرة النحوية (14).

مفهوم المذهب والمدرسة :
1 - مفهوم المذهب النحوي :
المذهب مصطلح فقهي في بداية نشأته فيقال مذهب الإمام الشافعي أو الإمام مالك أو مذهب شيخنا ... وانتقل إلى اللغة حيث أصبح يعبر عن مجموعة مبادئ وآراء متصلة ومنسقة لمفكر ما أو لاتجاه ما .
وفي التعريف النحوي الدقيق هو : طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد تعتنق مذهبا نحويا وتقول برأي نحوي مشترك وتجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع (15).

2 - مفهوم المدرسة النحوية :
بعد الحديث عن تطور مسمى المناهج النحوية وطرق النحويين لعل الوقت قد حان للحديث عن مفهوم المدرسة عند المتأخرين .
فقد عرف المعجم الوسيط مصطلح المدرسة - بهذا المفهوم الجديد - بقوله :" المدرسة جماعة من الفلاسفة والمفكرين أو الباحثين تعتنق مذهبا معينا أو تقول برأي مشترك "(16).
وعند المتأخرين تعريفات كثيرة للمدرسة وكلها تدور حول هذا المعنى وسنستعرض فيما يلي بعضها .
عرف "جوتولد فايل" المدرس بأنها : "الاشتراك في وجهة النظر الذي يؤلف الجبهة العلمية ويربط العلماء بعضهم ببعض على رأي واحد "(17).
والأستاذ على النجدي ناصف يعرف المدرسة بقوله :" المدرسة طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد أو الفن الواحد تجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم العلمية وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع والتفاصيل ".
وعرفها الدكتور أحمد مكي الأنصاري بقوله :" اتجاه له خصائص مميزة ينادي بها فرد أو جماعة من الناس ثم ينادي بها آخرون ".
على حين يعرفها الدكتور مهدي الخزمومي بقوله :" فليست المدرسة إلا أستاذا مؤثرا وتلاميذ متأثرين وقد اجتمعوا على تحقيق غرض موحد نهجوا للوصول إليه منهاجا "(18).
قال ذلك في مدرسة الكوفة عند كلامه على الكسائي إذ قال :" إن الكسائي بمنهاجه وأساليب دراسته مدرسة لها خصائصها ومناهجها فليست المدرسة إلا ..." ثم ساق التعريف .
وقريب من هذا التعريف ما انتهى إليه الدكتور أحمد مختار عمر وهو قوله :" وجود جماعة من النحاة يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج في دراسة النحو ولابد أن يكون هناك الرائد الذي يرسم الخطة ويحدد المنهج والتابعون أو المريدون الذين يعتنقون خطاه ويتبنون منهجه ويعملون على تطويره والدفاع عنه (19).
وقد أخذ محمد حسين آل ياسين في كتاب "الدراسات اللغوية" بتعريف "جوتولد فايل" حيث يقول:" المدرسة في المصطلح العلمي لفظ يطلع على جماعة من الدارسين تشترك في وجهة النظر ويكون لها نهج خاص يؤلف منها جبهة علمية ويربط أفرادها برابط الرأي الموحد "(20).
وقد حاول الدكتور صالح بلعيد الجمع بين التعريفات السابقة فقال إن المدرسة :" كلمة معاصرة تعني الجماعة الذي يشكلون درسا واحدا في بيئة معينة أو بيئات معينة متعددة ويجمعهم نهج واحد أو الاشتراك في وجهة النظر التي تؤلف جبهة علمية واحدة ووجود الجماعة الذي يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج ويكون اتفاقهم على الأصول لا الفروع وعلى رأس المدرسة من يرسم الخطة ويحدد والمنهج وهو الشيخ أو الرئيس والمريدون الذي يعتنقون خطاه ويعملون على تطويرها الدفاع عنه "(21).
ونلاحظ أن هذا إلى التوصيف أقرب منه إلى التعريف حيث جمع ما في التعريفات الأخرى وضمنها هذا التوصيف .
ونخلص مما سبق إلى أن هذه التعريفات تتفق على وجود جماعة من الناس يعتنقون منهجا محددا ذا خصائص ومميزات يؤمنون به ويدافعون عنه وإن لم تجمعهم وحدة جغرافية ولا يشترط الاتفاق على الفروع بل يكفي اتفاقهم على أصول المنهج .
والتعريفات السابقة بهذا المعنى أو قريبة منه جدا ، ولذا نلاحظ أنها بدأت بـ :" جماعة " أو " طائفة " وبدأت أحيانا بـ :" الاشتراك في وجهة نظر " أو " اتجاه له خصائص " وهما – الجماعة والمنهج – الركنان الأساسيان في التعريفات السابقة .
هل توجد مذاهب نحوية أو مدارس نحوية ؟
أولا : المذاهب النحوية
جرى الأقدمون على أن هناك مذهبا في النحو يسمى المذهب البصري ومذهبا آخر في النحو يسمى المذهب الكوفي كما ذكرت بعض مؤلفات الأقدمين أن هناك نحاة مصريين ونحاة أندلسيين (22).

ثانيا : المدارس النحوية
تعددت آراء الباحثين المحدثين في المدارس النحوية بين الإثبات والرفض على ما يأتي :

الرأي الأول :
أنه لا توجد مدارس نحوية إطلاقا وإنما هي تجمعات جغرافية ولا يوجد مدارس نحوية تتميز كل منها بأسلوبها الخاص ومنهاجها الذاتي وتطبق هذه المجموعات أصولا واحدة وإن اختلفت في الفروع وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ سعيد الأفغاني والأستاذ على أبو المكارم (23).

الرأي الثاني :
أنه لا توجد إلا مدرسة نحوية واحدة هي مدرسة البصرة فقط وأنكر هذا الفريق وجود مدرسة الكوفة وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ الدكتور إبراهيم السامرائي وقد سبقه إلى القول بهذا "جوتولد فايل" (24).

الرأي الثالث :
أثبت فريق ثالث من النحويين وجود مدرستين بصرية وكوفية وتردد في القبول بوجود مدرسة بغدادية ويمثل هذا القول الدكتور مهدي المخزومي ، وقد تابعوا في ذلك الزبيدي في طبقاته حيث نظم أفراد المدرسة البغدادية مع رجال المدرسة البصرية والكوفية على حسب اتجاهه وميوله(25).
وما قيل في المدرسة البغدادية ينطبق على بقية المدارس كالأندلسية والمصرية.

الترجيح بين الآراء :
إذا دققنا النظر في الأوصاف التي يطلقها القدماء على الدراسات النحوية غير البصرية والكوفية وجدناها لا تخرج عن وصف هذه الدراسات أو الدارسين لأنهم خلطوا المذهبين أو النحوين أو مزجوا بينهما وهذا يدعونا إلى أنه ليس هناك خلاف بين هذا النحو والنحوين الآخرين خلافا لما نراه من الفروق بين منهجي البصرة والكوفة .
وهذا ينتهي بنا إلى القول بأنه ليس في النحو العربي إلا مدرستان أو مذهبان فقط هما البصرة والكوفة (26).
(1)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي ص / 13 بتصرف .
(2)· نقلته عن : طبقات فحول الشعراء 1 / 12
(3)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 7 بتصرف .
(4)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(5)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(6)· المرجع السابق· ص / 10
(7)· نقلته عنه : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170
(8)· نلقته عن : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170-171
(9)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 11
(10)· المرجع السابق· ص / 11
(11)· المرجع السابق· ص / 12
(12)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(13)· نقلته عن : تاريخ الأدب العربي· 2 / 124 – 125
(14)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 13
(15)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 144
(16)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(17) المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(18)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(19)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(20)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(21)· المرجع السابق· ص / 149 – 150
(22)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 145
(23)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 151 نقله عن طبقات الزبيدي· ص / 213 – 253
(24)· أنظر مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د.عبدالله الخثران والمدارس النحوي د. خديجة الحديثي .
(25)· المرجعان السابقان والمدارس النحوية أسطورة وواقع د. إبراهيم السامرائي ص / 139 – 141
(26)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 16
أحمد بن محمد مجرشي
طالب ماجستير قسم النحو والصرف وفقه اللغة

Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack