florida lisinopril avalide uk sale best generic kamagra chewable review what are the 3 main types of drugs can you only get brand cialis on prescription where to buy estrace with amex cout cialis quebec percocet uk purchase robaxin online no prescription order tadapox on line usa safe to buy generic lasix from usa alli weight loss coupons printable kamagra oral jelly over the counter canada buy cheap clomid us discount zedd drug in usa pharmacy listaflex carisoprodol prinivil cheap price order levitra no prescription per pill buy elavil 200 lexapro normale dosering over the counter medicine that acts as fluticanose can youtube buy levitra super active in ireland online coversyl side effects weight gain chloroquine and proguanil goa amantadine us companies only buy tamoxifen for daily use order toprol xl pills chloroquine lawsuit canada plendil more drug side effects afina med cabinets cheap rx meds online kikisu male enhancement albenza sold over counter generic lopid usa pharmacy order tricor online no prescription with a mastercard finpecia with paypal payment over the counter lamisil at eltroxin tablets side effects brand name riperdal online betnovate without insurance generic glucofage uk paypal buy beconase aq low cheap price price increase nexium how long does flonase last how to buy differin in london canadian pharmacy wellbutrin jennifer t alli love bites reading order erexin v pills online in the canada triamterene without insurance doryx dr cheap genuine amoxicilina online content analysis of newspapers metformin 500 mg price philippines what is metoclopramide tablets valtrex without a prescription from uk otomax shelf life best site to buy bentyl where to buy tricor online uk yasmin canada drug store buy tamoxifen online at canada pharmacy buy levothroid online mexico no prescription what is the cost of voltaren gel buy grifulvin v online without prescription arzomicin buy no prescription ginseng suppliers overseas generic zithromax uk paypal india zanaflex price generic viagra soft online non prescription prednisone emsam uk next day delivery beconase aq discount no prescription where to buy prometrium with visa pharmacy buy drugs colospa pariet over the counter australia alcohol and azithromycin antibiotics get hard pills bactrim ds dose for dogs bactroban canada sale bupron sr no rx maxalt us companies only viagra jelly for sale australia altace canada companies only lisinopril without a prescription from india what is synthroid medication for ginseng en mexico confido buy online us zanaflex cheap india pharmacy glucotrol drug in fr pharmacy suprax generic release date over the counter drugs similar to raciper where to buy meclizine with echeck where can i buy doksazosin lek tablets ciprofloxacin eye drops during pregnancy best foundation for women over 50 with dry skin lipitor recall november 2012 buy albuterol online no prescription us estrace medication dosage order voltaren in erexin v for men in usa atarax generic mexico premarin online pay paypal aristocort drug canadian pharmacy prilosec canadian medications without prescription is thyrox available over the counter maxalt online store generic from xeloda swift current online where can i get hydrochlorothiazide order buspar cabaser delivery london best place to buy ranitidine in australia tinidazole drugs developing bacteria precio arava 10 mg buying orlistato buy tretinoin 0,025 online no prescription preorder alli drugstore flagyl medication pregnancy side effects of proscar for hair loss diakof daily use reviews buy deltasone 100mg online prandin birth control online us bactrim for sale usa indinavir prices usa purchase probalan in us how to by zyban online why is there a shortage of astelin celexa and low energy cheap cafergot buy online femara in canada can you buy cialis jelly in ireland tadalafil cipla how to use penegra 50 mg buy valaciclovir tablets india best kamagra oral jelly prices ophthacare uses medication buy thyrox online usa indinavir cheap uk pilex where can i buy it hong kong viagra cramping after ovulation while on clomid overnight pharmacy singulair prescription what does it mean if cialis doesnt work celebrex canadian source best place to buy flunil in uk priligy purchase zoloft forums side effects shingles acyclovir treatment dose buy levitra plus 10 coumadin without a prescription from mexico clomid lawsuit settlement how to use clomid to get pregnant how to get off seroquel xr sinemet online coupon code nexium lawsuit 2012 himalaya serpina tablets best place to buy proscar in uk reviews on benzaclin ponstel online pharmacy shipped to canada viagra suppliers canada order innopran xl online no presctiption buy viagra online us pharmacy generic wellbutrin sr side effects purchase clozaril online discount code for ashwagandha doxazosin 2mg tablets side effects furosemide combination product overnight delivery buy floxin drug orlistat express canada buy generic benadryl with bonus generic name for flagyl er ordering phenergan here in canada withdrawal from paroxetine cipro otic price actonel tablets price clomid calculator due date zithromax medication online amlodipin maximum dosage is generic estrofem effective cost of mail propecia buy detrol online from canada pyridium side effects common alternatives doxycycline chlamydia no prescription needed pharmacy reviews nombre generico de lamisil buy glucotrol xl mg online dilantin 100mg capsule januvia 50 mg online no rx order wellbutrin online no prescription mirapex prices cvs cheap beta val buy provera in singapore safe buy bisoprololi fumaras online zetia sold over counter amoxiline online coupon code what is fucidin drugs ditropan cheap us pharmacy aristocort usa diclofenac gel buy on line where to buy sildenafil citrate with amex keftab best online non prescription pharmacy proscar 5mg tab sumycin australia pharmacy thyroxine online pharmacies with out prescription diamox delivered to your home purchase xbox live membership online revia buy online canada plavix dose in acs purchase coumadin in india uk version of phenergan glycomet on line no script what do bupropion pills look like generic from cialis can i get allegra how to by remeron online tizanidina buy mexico cheap brand levitra buy online colchicine buy uk albendazole over the counter uk low price serophene buy amantadine online reviews vytorin india companies only side effects of enalapril quiero comprar triamterene prometrium tablets uk slimex spain over counter ordering viagra online from india average cost of trazodone emsam pas cher italie roxithromycin drug in usa pharmacy yasmin india pharmacy singulair tablets side effects in children get zanaflex toronto purchase diprolene on line in india baclofen to buy buy effexor xr boots acticin online genuine acticin uk pharmacies online that sell dramamine chlamydia symptoms men timeline pills buy cheap allopurinol overnight generic mirapex overnite shipping resources for neurontin mevacor canada pharmacy albuterol pills online in the canada where to buy betapace ointment buy rocaltrol in uk ciproxin 500 mg dosage minocycline birth control online uk buy erexin without a subscription generic serophene canada compare prices xalatan buy no prescription bentyl online side effects of advair diskus 500 50 elavil amitriptyline medication to buy fluconazol in uk what does a zofran tablet look like canadian pharmacy zestoretic cheap reglan uk zyvox without used drug diabecon weight gain allegra costa cruise canadian cialis jelly hormone medicine premarin buy malegra fxt quick bactroban dosage nasal topamax uk sale xenical alli orlistat mexico pharmacies online that sell carvedilolo generic roxithromycin us retin a gel 0 1 wholesale canadian medication identification accutane second time success bentyl mg price order elavil can order reminyl canada finpecia usa sale actoplus cheap canada pharmacy glucovance uk sale discount sildenafila mg order inderal without prescription florida lasilix where can i buy lady era in canada buy lipitor overseas online no prescription uk for oristal online pharmacy uk clomifene lloyds pharmacy allergy reliever user manual dr oz and lipothin renagel online no prescription vasodilan discount medications amitriptyline online cheap inderal brands india is zocor better than lipitor actonel with paypal payment mobic meloxicam 7.5mg buy toradol online from uk buy avodart without a script where can i buy accutane tablets buy wigraine online from india accutane fda approved to buy without prescription buy salvent tablets india buyalli order pills alli weight loss valtrex pills pregnancy what is brand levitra for depakote over the counter natural medicine for low back pain how soon can i get pregnant after cytotec how to buy benicar in canada express scripts prior authorization form humira over counter januvia order keppra from mexico without prescription mail order generic olistat buy zetia 100mg online elavil prescription coupon how much does zofran cost at cvs cardura wikipedia how to use viagra sublingual buy zofran greece can you get furosemide over the counter levothroid usa cvs prices bupropion cheapest rate vente de albenza au quebec buy ivenox tablets india ciprofloxacina online legally where can i buy xenical online without a prescription metoclopramide india buy retin a gel how to take flomax mg online amlodipinbesilat purchase where can i buy periactin online without a prescription medication from mexico augmentin buy kamagra 200 triderm crema 30g aricept birth control online us doxazosin cost aldactone birth control online canada cialis super active drug in mexico pharmacy apcalis sx uses medication nexium overnight pharmacy order generic plavix canada how to buy amlodipin viagra jelly online usa no prescription coversyl plus hd prednisolone refills best price for real estrofem clomid canada where to buy diflucan in canada safely metformin pills in poop buy generic cardizem online with prescription where to buy synthroid online usa ciprofloxacina infeccion urinaria posologia comprar bystolic en argentina generic lotrisone no prescription canadian minipress buy desyrel online safely healthy meals for a working man lisinopril overdose death common side effects of provera trandate buy online ireland rizact drugs for sale comprar zitromax en argentina buy provera 50 keppra price us bing search by image acyclovir dose in renal failure amaryl over the counter india order allopurinol 100mg best place to buy danazol without a prescription amitriptyline low blood sugar buy coumadin mexican pharmacies botanical gel slimming tablets reviews buy toradol boots buy actos online canada no prescription urispas no prescription needed order amoxycillin uk pharmacy arzomicin pct buy super dmz rx buy buy amoxiline with paypal acheter periactine sur internet motilium australia price atarax mg mexico purchase ginseng in usa is it safe to order nymphomax cabgolin for men sale in uk cabgolin suppositories buy best site get tretinoin 0,025 safe place order rythmol sr raciper fast canada viagra sublingual birth control online canada mirapex from canada januvia generic equivalent purchase trental 100mg what are the storage requirements for nitroglycerin sl tablets order prednisolone online without rx pfizer canada viagra purchase levitra professional on line in mexico buy levitra online 24 hours indian decadron vente de artane au quebec canada motilium tablets online zebeta bisoprolol acivir pills online order purchase cabgolin in india cheapest online pharmacy in canada buy amaryl online mexico no prescription where can i get finax crestor statin buy kamagra quick delivery motrin buy australia yasmin not generic snovitra super power uk buy no prescription unisom how long viagra last gabapentin capsules dosage snl flomax commercial different type of cialis where to buy olanzapine with mastercard what does bactrim antibiotic treat sominex shopping where to buy over the counter viagra where can i buy kamagra in london sildenafil arimidex generic release date cheap canadian lopid no prescription discount code for female viagra legal psychedelic drugs for sale comprar isotretin portugal fluoxetine 20 mg oral cap generic actos when over the counter antibiotics for ear infection buy benicar in canada liquid paxil review where to buy nootropil with visa prinivil tablets price como comprar live no xbox alli without a prescription from us clavamox dose olistat pills buy online azulfidine tablets online lukol mg buy buying female viagra uk maxalt online forum orlistat shortage june endep 10 overdose purinethol online forum colchicine drug canadian pharmacy what does prometrium treat what does starlix look like erection packs 1 online purchase mexitil pharmacy yagara online usa order accuran on line mexico cheap seroflo uk viagra pills drugstore rosuvastatin 20 mg tabletta buy amitriptyline 100mg adalat retard 20 pendant la grossesse skelaxin online forum pariet drug in mexico pharmacy how to buy trial erection packs 2 in canada hydrochlorothiazide indications what does fucidin cream cure disulphiram prices usa donde comprar metformina mexico what is actos 15 mg used for isoniazid online canada what does lasix do to potassium yasmin taj times of india buy cabgolin with combivent in the uk cafergot to purchase without a prescription comprar cialis generico no brasil what is fucidin cream 15g used for buy alesse 27 generic name colospa rosuvastatin tablets 40 mg cheap medrol dosepak no prescription what is isoptin mg used to treat mail order otomax online glucotrol drugstore com pricing where to buy nootropil drugs online buy diarex online with out prescription buy hydrochlorothiazide with visa buy coversyl capsules azax 500 uses free coupon for ranitidine actonel 150 mg tablet where to buy remeron online usa pulmicort order online no prescription purchase prednisone on line in australia where to buy alavert drugs online antabuse dosage instructions aciphex for sale australia where can i get some nitroglycerin what is the normal dosage for abilify nombres de pastillas para prolongar la ereccion purchase atorlip 10 on line in usa zestoretic lawsuit canada glucotrol to buy in the uk without a prescription pill rx health thyroxin products what doses does celebrex come in dyazide mexico pharmacy acyclovir 800 mg side effects buy zithromax bulk nitroglycerin tablets max dose cialis 5mg online apotheke femara pills buy online bactrim buy online canada buy clopidogrelum cheap what is sildenafila mg used to treat where to buy cheap generic midamor generisk cialis danmark is generic female viagra available in usa altace indian pharmacy 10mg glucophage dose for pcos can you get high on lexapro 10mg buy venlafaxina in singapore buying erexor in manchester remeron to buy in england which uk site to buy terramycin legal buy betapace online canada where can i get caverta pills can order dutasterid canada buy rogaine 5 online without a prescription buy beta val have no prescription buy brand brand cialis buy skelaxin online overnight delivery apcalis sx discounts codes endep in singapore medrol generic uk buy carbozyne pills online what does arava allopurinol direct pharmacy where do i mobic in india flovent side effects uk order altace online with mastercard ordering nizoral best place to buy sepibest online lesofat price in the philippines benadryl pills for hives nice donepezil galantamine rivastigmine methotrexate where can i buy how to take erythromycin 250mg bupron pharmacy mail order erexor over counter uk synthroid online in usa to buy calcium carbonate in uk ephedraxin buy online canada how to take glucophage mg silver slimming tablets day night review is cipro generic warafin from uk where to buy capoten online india flomax weight gain order kamagra oral jelly online no prescription with a echeck compare prices prometrium erythromycin topical for sale nitrofurantoin india pharmacy buy tretinoin 0,025 pills online ordering cleocin gel canada where to dulcolax best price for real omnicef levlen phone orders buy brand indocin top 10 online ponstel sites accuran buy online australia colospa tablets india can you take aprovel daily costco uk reading where can i buy claritin online where to buy bupropion online canada albuterol price india low cost viagra super active fluoxetine hcl discount sildenafil citrate without a script purchasing brand amoxil online uk endep next day diovan weight gain side effects order zithromax from usa without prescription zovirax fast uk actoplus discount no prescription albenza buy usa nitroglycerin mexico generic clavamox buy canada zofran usa pharmacy best place to buy estradiol valerate ordering tizanidinum usa uk buy erection packs 1 without prescription venta de cytotec costa rica prednisone 10 mg tablet picture prevacid solutabs cheap discount code for diclofenac buy cialis montreal hydrochlorothiazide pills online in the usa hyzaar over the counter australia curacne birth control online india order caffeine ergotamine online canada cost of lexapro at walmart is rabeprazole available otc where could i buy mexitil without prescription antabuse mg canada periactin drug oversea generic pills for levlen zovirax buy online canada lipitor generic canada pharmacy hcg diet escrow pharmacy buying chloroquine for dogs lisinopril 20 mg cheap micardis no prescription buy cefixime usa buy amoxiline online amazon cheap menosan pills buy venlafaxina tablets usa safe to buy generic micronase from usa stromectol pills online in the usa cheap allopurinol mg benicar patient reviews viagra for sale in arizona buy diovan online thyroxine cheap uk buy serevent no prescription fast delivery doxycycline 100mg dosage for chest infection topamax without a prescription from uk diovan hct side effects weight gain minipress to buy in australia my diabecon coupons revia capsules purchase phenamax on line in australia buy lipothin in uk levaquin tablets for sale percocet side effects constipation best place to buy triamterenum in usa metformin without insulin resistance cefixime tablets during pregnancy buy albuterol low cheap price buy isoptin xr without prescription can order citalopram online purchase speman in mexico snovitra super power drug oversea duloxetine indian generics online maxaman generic orlistar safe lipitor generic online allopurinol in croatia salbutamol price india purchase pulmicort on line in mexico non prescription exelon lozol mg order where to purchase v gel proscar from usa pharmacy fastest biaxin uk delivery what is sildenafil citrate powder cabgolin pas cher paroxetine manufacturers in india how to get antabuse out of system cholestoplex pills sweat billig vardenafilum online kaufen buy aldactone no prescription three clomid generic price sominex no prescription needed where to buy cytotec ointment propecia 1 or 5 ortho tri cyclen lo generic name 2011 ranitidine maximum dosage for babies is depo provera available in india generic zofran buy canada levitra professional buy mexico buy suhagra toradol 10 mg medication generic aciphex us generic ibuprofen same motrin what is the success rate of pregnancy with clomid buspar tablets stieva a shopping cheap kamagra oral jelly no prescription fastest erection packs 1 uk delivery zyloprim prices at costco order relafen from canada without prescription where can i buy viagra plus mg where can i buy amoxil buying artane in manchester safe place buy accutane online i pill retino a cream 0,05 website elocom order canada tretinoin 0 05 online order what does zestril treat viagra sale online australia where to buy penegra in india 1mg finasteride can clomid cause late ovulation where can i buy seroquel how much does viagra cost in thailand what is c ratioph mg used to treat where do i serpina in uk celadrin pills buy buying valaciclovir from canada no prescription is predalone available on line in canada safe place order renagel ordering clozaril mexico what is naprosyn 500 used for side effects of alphagan p 0.15 tizanidina on line no script erythromycin estolate 500mg dosage what is sarafem pills used for zofran prescription assistance program purchase amitriptyline 75mg online fastest permethrinum uk delivery where can i buy accuran top 10 canadian online pharmacy buyers of tofranil canada what does benicar lozol for men sale in uk side effects of norvasc 5mg viagra soft fda approved to buy without prescription there generic drug cozaar cheap heartworm medicine for dogs no prescription canada oxybutyninum tablets online topamax mist canada sertraline reviews order vistaril rx where do i cardura in uk ordering atarax india purchase lipothin on line in canada buy discount adalat xl generic lipitor ranbaxy artane shopping centre shops western drug haridra hytrin fda approved to buy without prescription danazol buy without online forum prescription order periactin aciphex how to buy best place to buy tamsulozin online buy cleocin gel 50 prescription erythromycin european journal of hospital pharmacy science and practice cialis soft cost canadian advair mexico pharmacy permethrinum pills online in the canada viagra pills ebay tofranil in italia canada mometasona tablets online what is the brand name for diltiazem bupron sr mg no prescription comprar dramamine original amitriptyline shopping buy serpina tablets online clincin tablets uses india kamagra price over the counter medicine levothyroxin renagel tablets uses buy carvedilolo online uk no prescription where to buy alfa flucon online usa buy cialis sublingual astrailia aciclovir noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy buy diprolene online canada no prescription zoloft online bestellen buy venlor pills viagra medicine children cheapest flonase in the uk hoodia gordonii reviews side effects purchase janumet in usa advair diskus delivery london legal buy tegretol online canada how to order unisom side effects of colchicine tablets dostinex delivery london toprol xl lawsuit canada beconase long term use side effects buy cardura tablets us orphan drugs specialty pharmacy what types of thyroxine are there xenical diet medication elocom shopping cozaar prix en pharmacie en france buy pulmicort online reviews genuine cefixime best price where do i trental in mexico raciper discount cheap canadian pariet no prescription is generic amantadine available in usa buying online pharmacy safe phenergan over counter uk safe to buy generic requip from usa india pharmacies online that sell simvastatina uroxatral generic acai generico italiano purchase tenormin cheap non generic floxin amoxycillin pricing tadapox sale drugs cialis lisinopril canada pharmacy free or low cost anacin estrace usa cvs prices diamox to buy cialis on the internet zitromax from usa tretinoin 0 05 max dose tadacip canada sale boots terramycin london pharmacy valacyclovir 500 mg prices pletal medication dosage apo clopidogrel drugstore.com can you buy fasigyne flagyl online mexico does fosamax cause weight gain evista buy online mexico leukeran uk online non prescription prednisolona pharmacy buy zyrtec online from australia red ginseng new zealand order amantadine online no presctiption sangria pomegranate juice recipe walgreens pharmacy river and la canada buy novo digoxin in singapore nitroglycerin online without prescription trileptal without a script what is the generic version of plavix fucidin 100mg cheap mail order generic levaquin what types of frusemide are there costco nexium price compare prices cabgolin pyridium for uti pain improvement clomid price in mercury drug where can i buy lamictal in canada what is klipal codeine used for clonidine in canada for what is medrol medication used orlistar prix en pharmacie en france is generic trandate available in usa revia sale cardizem where to buy in canada order flonase nasal spray shuddha guggulu generico italiano best trimix computers do walk in clinics prescribe viagra anteovin where can i buy azulfidine 500 mg dosis buy aloprim online us no prescription cialis tablets 10mg predalone from china buy zedd in ireland nymphomax avec paypal requip india suppliers buy ciproxin apo clopidogrel prices safe buy cozaar online is viagra over the counter in canada generic citalopram switzerland cialis online cheap canada cymbalta sales rep female estrogen pills for men order medrol dosepak from usa without prescription how to use ivenox ayurslim with no rx erection packs 2 online without prescription aripiprazola women buy canadianpharmacystore aciclovir complete acticin weight gain rhinocort discounts codes online pharmacy uk ethionamide shoppers drug mart canada day hours toronto where is nizoral shampoo maxalt mlt rxlist betapace medicine children diakof supplier in uk augmentin 875 generic name cozaar usa janumet no prescription needed tesco swindon pharmacy opening times ordering ampicillin usa atrovent with american express buy viagra for men uk no prescription uroxatral depakote online mexico is allegra available in generic form generic trandate buy american ginseng plants is there a drug comparative to seroquel arjuna online cheap diovan hct generic availability actos reviews side effects extendaquin to buy trial erection packs 2 canadian online overnight pharmacy metformin xr rxlist common examples of anti anxiety drugs retail pharmacy assistant salary in canada warafin fast mexico is it illegal to order generic minomycin vente de levitra au quebec erection packs 2 limited india purchase dipyridamole on line in australia buy betnovate have no prescription grifulvin v mg canada zestril canada head office where to purchase fasigyn fluoxetina india companies only caffeine ergotamine no prescription needed where do i diclofenac gel in usa curacne pas cher online sale of predisone where can you buy alli pills sepibest over the counter india my baby is super active in the womb viagara by mail 24 hours capoten online no prescription discount exelon from canada is it illegal to buy viagra in uk purchase brafix in us female cialis pills buy online buy zertalin boots pharmacy indian generics online ortho cyclen vasotec for sale philippines avodart uk brand name salbutamol prescription coupon what happened to pharmacy escrow what is ginseng pills good for how to import kamagra cialis customer service phone number lisinopril canada where can i buy orlistar carvedilolo mg uk zocor generic canada best place to buy flexisyn order cialas zurich aloprim perth australia avodart 10 mg speman for sale purchase dostinex can you buy styplon over the counter top 10 online lotrisone sites celadrin without insurance flonase reviews for men propecia pills for sale canada and roxithromycin lipothin cheapest rate risk ordering viagra online pill what is the drug prevacid used for order raloxifeno online no prescription with a visa ordering valaciclovir usa fluconazol buy online india stieva a online canada baclofen withdrawal symptoms comprehensive view cheap zyrtec no prescription online pharmacy nymphomax arzomicin buy mexico is it legal to take viagra to thailand ondansetron dose buy valtrex online australia no prescription can you buy toprol xl canadian pharmacy where to buy aloprim online without rx buy flunil tablets mexico order differin from uk without prescription is levitra a prescription drug purchase duprost in australia toprol drugstore.com where can i get some viagra plus craigslist new york manhattan furniture buy calan low cheap price buy clincin pills in the uk clozaril cheap price predalone buy canada where to get glucophage pct mail order generic albenda best pills get you high ampicillin ceftriaxone combination rumalaya online overnight trihexyphenidyl recreational dosage 1 800 numbers for viagra can you get caprysin compare prices lamisil once where to get clomid privately buy ortho cyclen online with no prescription mirapex drug schedule pharmacy2u paroxetine ordering zantac on line buying actos canada asacol hd india discount seroflo stieva a canada head office where can i buy rimonabant tablets online pharmacy triamterene no prescription rabeprazole domperidone wiki viagra professional max dose valaciclovir pharmacy order inderal weight gain depression where to purchase hoodia pill rx health erection packs 1 products what is the side effect of norvasc 10 mg forum ou acheter du cialis sur internet cheap canadian toprol xl no prescription rythmol sr without script purchase roaccutan on line in uk medication without prescriptions overnight canada pharmacy review meclizine and compazine rosuvastatin fast usa ordering zyprexa without prescription journal of the history of medicine and allied sciences protonix online india buspar to buy from europe compazine with prescription not taking thyroid medication side effects ventolin canada no prescription order dipyridamole from india without prescription silagra over counter uk how to take viagra soft mg augmentin to buy in the canada without a prescription what is the inflammation of the visceral and parietal pleura buying rosuvastatin online legal atomoxetin limited india yasmin birth control india aygestin drugstore com pricing desyrel prescribing information pdf glucotrol xl to buy in england buy indocin drug prevacid online canada usa buy permethrinum without prescription where can i get viagra jelly pills mentat ds syrup pharmacy coupons evecare 10 mg shallaki generic usa buy lopressor online no prescription usa buy bystolic fast shipping feldene spain over counter maxaman no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy novo digoxin order online no prescription how to take cephalexin 500mg little bluepill is it safe to order eurax what is keflex used for in humans order generic skelaxin prednisolone prescription coupon buy finax next day bupron sr online order cialis 20 mg 2 tablet lotensin from usa pharmacy trileptal mg canadian rx order aloprim on line mexico nexium fast uk liv 52 shoppers drug mart lariam online forum online prinivil overnight delivery overnight aciphex online cod what class of drugs is benicar where to buy erectile dysfunction pills generic astelin cost lamisil to buy in australia ayurslim online australia paxil lawsuits in canada cleocin gel in the uk mail order retin a 0,025 online cheapest zebeta to buy stromectol buy india can you buy viagra over the counter usa online pharmacy where can i order adalat how to order keftab online lopressor sublingual dosage combivent for sale can order retin a 0 05 online comprar levitra professional en argentina what is losartan generic for cheap apcalis sx india buy mobicarte in us buy periactin canada azulfidine drug classification aloprim online from india crestor canadian product monograph buy thyrox pills in the uk prednisone pills identification brand viagra online pharmacy what is zyrtec for children for bupron on line in the uk zanaflex now co uk cleocin gel prescription coupon prograf delivery london menosan no prescription reviews uk pharmacies online that sell tegretol 24h pharmacy southampton bactrim use in early pregnancy allegra kurer engaged antabuse buy usa wellbutrin online overnight where can i get synthroid from brand arjuna buy buy glucotrol xl generic calan for men in usa lasix side effects on kidneys how long does it take for procardia xl to work zoloft ordering no prescription order bisoprololi fumaras from mexico without prescription low price decadron uk zyrtec generic uk styplon no prescription phone in order for bupron zyvox coupon codes sale best online canadian pharmacy no prescription reviews viagra buy combivent bulk zestoretic lawsuit evista dose lamisil online from india indian strattera astelin uses medication fluconazol from usa pharmacy where can i buy singulair mg ordering periactin india i pill prograf website cheapest place to buy doksazosin lek generic requip imitrex migraine medicine oder mg tablets of diflucan can you buy isoniazid allegra over the counter 1996 compare prices clopidogrelum discount cefixime from canada ordering lasix online fluoxetine prescription drug free coupon for luvox cilest india pharmacy buy valtrex 100 fluticanose women buy pariet tablets for reflux where to buy tretinoin online discount erythromycin from canada voveran sr reviews clearblue easy fertility monitor clomid order diarex without prescription very cheap danazol triamterenum birth control online india can i buy misoprostol over the counter voltaren generic price diltiazem for men sale in uk where to get demadex pct prandin over the couter comprar eldepryl portugal promethazine cheap india pharmacy why has vasodilan been discontinued proscar canadian online over counter viagra equivalent diabecon without script lanoxin women buy tretinoin 0 05 uk brand name tylenol motrin dose chart i pill ethionamide website printable alli coupon 2011 disulfiramo over the counter cipro in india xeloda medication where to buy mail order pulmicort online viagra with dapoxetine overnight para que es la clorfenamina compuesta ky6 what are the side effects of flagyl in dogs fosamax sales 2010 cefixime generic cost generic for cozaar 100mg zoplicone to buy on line inderal fast mexico hydrochlorothiazide capsules mexico pharmacies online that sell terramycin methotrexate sodium drug classification maxalt mlt medicine medrol dosepak mg no prescription addicted to pain pills while pregnant rosuvastatin pills buy organic pharmacy rose balm acheter periactine en ligne seroquel overseas zyrtec generic canada acheter seroflo best place to buy femara in canada buy amaryl no prescription fast delivery buy tadalis sx boots pharmacy side effects of aricept tablets why is there a tetracycline shortage zetia generic wikipedia drugs how to get cialis on line evista generic substitute selegiline shortage anxiety medication for dogs thunderstorms genuine viagra plus 100mg elocon buy without reviews on protonix sildenafil citrate dapoxetine 100mg 60mg stieva a weight gain minocycline pigmentation gums can i order levritra off the internet cheap synthroid purchase sildenafila in mexico canadian medrol tablet is it safe to drink alcohol while taking accutane pyridium cheap mexico pharmacy what does generic metformin look like took accutane but acne came back orlistar fast mexico is it safe to order citalopram sinequan tablets for purchase generic pills for elocon can you buy chloramphenicol online cialis kopen toprol online coupon code pharmacy has best price aspirin order cialis no prescription online buy lamisilate hong kong can you buy fml forte methotrexate shortage cause purchase medazole in uk buy duprost online with out prescription what is feldene drugs flagyl forte 500mg obat apa serpina supplier in uk valtrex valacyclovir pregnancy best price for zanaflex effexor venlafaxine hydrochloride kamagra oral jelly online from usa moduretic uk sale sale probalan mg lexapro brand positioning lamictal and alcohol bipo ciprofloxacina 500 para que sirve cvs mail order prescriptions viagra soft no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy order lady era online no prescription with a amex amantadine buy canada anastrozolo sublingual dosage purchasing tricor online uk buy aciphex 200 mg what is zaditor used for tadalafila medicamento canadian dutasterid atarax without prescriptions feldene tablets 150 mg fast haldol deleviery rumalaya gel uk next day delivery online sominex purchase antivert australia maxalt mlt 10 mg no prescription low dose wellbutrin for weight loss wellbutrin xl name brand vs generic flagyl er online with out prescription 80 mg accutane results indian pharmacy ampicilina brand elocon for sale indian pharmacy pravachol ordering midamor india online diamox india uk buy tinidazolum without prescription diflucan uk buy kroger pharmacy lexington ky hours buy tegretol pills in the canada side effects of claritin 24 hour serophene vs clomid como comprar viramune como comprar cefadroxil cialis under tongue generic mexican order propranolol salvent buy usa diarex cheap canada pharmacy plendil cost comparison 5mg pharmacy detrol without insurance bupron sr side effects uk cyklokapron in costa rica cytoxan 100 mg over counter silagra tadalafil generic cialis review mexican pharmacy no prescription stediril ordering reglan mexico purchase abana 3 pharmacy zentel a tabletki antykoncepcyjne buy viagra soft tablets usa rosuvastatin for purchase without a prescription what does purim mean in hebrew buy pletal online no prescription united states order flomax online no prescription with a amex sale erection packs 2 ordering ivenox india robaxin prices buy imuran with paypal propecia tablets online pharmacy wellbutrin drug oversea no prescription kamagra oral jelly sale herbal viagra suppliers uk online pharmacy atorlip 20 voveran sr prices cvs bentyl lowest price online ordering canadian actoplus met online prevacid or prilosec or nexium buy tamoxifen citrate uk drugs valtrex discount coupons how to order zithromax trental next day levothroid without subscription is atacand available over the counter take cialis without ed celebrex 100mg cap tadalafil us maxifort tomato rootstock prometrium tablets us online flagyl antibiotics terramycin india no prescription best generic drugs manufacturers prilosec medication overnight delivery mevacor on line no script clozaril drug in fr pharmacy india viagra sublingual price proscar in croatia what is dulcolax made of compare viagra online prices remeron groggy next day paxil legal us mometasona to buy from europe gonorrhea treatment rocephin injection promethazine on line in the mexico buying diflucan online prednisona for men sale in uk minipress medication where to buy best online pharmacy generic abilify c ratioph with no perscription getting lady era in australia generic for betapace how to use cytotec orally for abortion lexapro 10 mg side effects bentyl ships from india clonidine dose for opioid withdrawal order erection packs 11 online without breaking lipitor pills stopped synthroid symptoms order viagra professional online no prescription with a mastercard where can i buy lamisil tablets wellbutrin sr with paypal payment how to get lotrisone on line where to buy cabaser online uk buy zestril online no prescription us valaciclovir prices at costco medicine comparable to aciphex where to buy sarafem without a prescription can your buy cialis soft in ireland pill shop buy pilex online with no prescription i pill coversyl website wellbutrin xl 150 mg tablet ler a bula do remedio sertralina buying atrovent using paypal can we trust celebrex online chem research nolvadex robaxin roche precio argentina zyvox pas cher overseas pharmacy no prescription cozaar discount digoxin healthy mango drink nitroglycerin pills side effects buy artane online ireland serophene spain where can i get some coversyl nexium 20 mg buy online fast cystone deleviery prometrium canada no prescription minipress generic wikipedia drugs best place buy atrovent drugstore publicis best drugstore face powder 2012 best place to buy lantus online cheapest price on allegra d buy zebeta boots pharmacy disulfiramum without subscription generic lansoprazol india cheapest brand levitra tablets uk oestrogel australia companies only ordering seroquel online order celebrex online no prescription with a mastercard buy citalopram new zealand online trandate how to buy buy prednisona online no prescription canada diprosone order online no prescription buy canada no prescription for penegra can you buy cozaar canadian pharmacy drugs my urispas coupons buy nitroglycerin tablets usa cheap living room ideas overseas pharmacy no prescription zocor diamox tablets from buy toradol on line purchase amantadine parkinsons mechanism cytotec uk companies only buy cheap zyban online tadapox pills drugstore dutas over the counter usa switching from ambien to trazodone treatment flagyl er pill canadian overnight pharmacy buy zyprexa online does viagra work yahoo generic get protonix legal clomifene without a prescription from india online sale of vpxl ordering prevacid usa buy depakote tablets usa ordering noroxin brand noroxin for sale billig retino a cream 0,025 online kaufen unisom online legally where to buy ciplox in canada safely buy tetracycline no prescription prices hytrin over the counter australia what does sumycin do order thyrox tablets canada buy avodart without prescription online pharmacies european isoniazid canadian medications without prescription where to buy avapro drugs online celexa wanted online review best place to buy voltaren in australia order etabus no rx canadian pharmacy cheap 10mg buy generic accutane order micronase online no prescription with a echeck buy furosemide 15mg online buy anteovin tablets us aricept pills online in the canada coversyl with no perscription to buy aviane 28 lotrel uk next day delivery erection packs 3 canada companies only cheapest pletal generic name for emsam lipitor weight gain cialis sales uk prescription ventolin tablets purchase on line buy viagra in vancouver how long does bactrim take to work for mrsa cheap accutane no prescription isotretinoin can you only get levaquin on prescription buy cheap oxytrol using pay pal colchicina shoppers drug mart cialis super active buy online us coversyl limited india non prescription plendil pharmacy can you take haridra daily clozaril discontinued erythromycin phone orders low price aceon uk oristal uk companies only cialis professional wikipedia where to buy accutane review online without premarin online legally buy lotensin with paypal female cialis order online cheap pills buy acticin legal buy rosuvastatin online canada pharmacy mexico zoloft nitrofurantoin alcohol interactions how much does tetracycline cost generic wellbutrin weight gain mexico pharmacies online that sell propecia feiertage bayer 2013 generic lopressor switzerland buyers of zentel canada buy alfa flucon tablets uk emoquette mg uk non persciption zyprexa furosemide alternative medicine why has glucotrol xl been discontinued can you buy levlen over the counter augmentin 500 mg tabletas best site for riperdal cheap albenza sale uk can you use fucidin cream for thrush orlistar cheap canada pharmacy cholestoplex pharmacy mail order geriforte without a prescription from canada fasigyn cost in canada 100mg clomid chance of twins show low az pet allies inc purchase lansoprazol on line in the uk what is the generic name for cialis generic trental for sale on line canadian aceon ponstel over the counter drugs buy motrin perth australia comprar bystolic original where do i buy betapace indocin dosage too high phrmacia mx.com amoxil dose for strep throat in children carbozyne mg order where to buy atarax in canada safely xenical prescriptions online buy blopress from mexico online buy erexin v online from uk slimming tablets that actually work pharmacy buy drugs acnetane plavix 75 mg daily when will seroquel go generic in us advair diskus over the counter prescription quetiapinum side effects long term use effexor xr generic equivalent where can i get some confido phenergan suppository safe during pregnancy fastest lotrel uk delivery do you need rx medrol cheap trimox price of generic zofran zofran zydis lingual where to get ginseng seeds dramamine online ordering canada amiodipine propecia acquisto coreg maximum daily dosage side effects of prednisone 5mg legal buy menosan online canada how long does it take for 5mg of lexapro to leave your system alli diet medication prescription fedex overnight free buy aceon online university pharmacy programs canada pharmacy technician online programs in mississippi order lamisil on line canada sildenafil citrate powder price order trazodone no rx canadian pharmacy purchase cheap generic allegra liponexol canadian pharmacy order ortho tri cyclen birth control is ashwagandha a prescription drug original motrin online wellbutrin 40 mg ordering lisinopril india isoniazid shipping overseas where to get norvasc pct mail order generic zyban buy glucophage lowest price maximum benadryl dose for children toprol xl delivery uk feldene for purchase without a prescription safe to buy generic accutane from usa what is asacol hd dr zestoretic tablets for sale canada and avodart mobic drugs arthritis caffeine ergotamine buy online uk very cheap prometrium disulphiram buy australia cost of levitra professional online motilium with no prescription what is cialis used for women phenergan maximum daily dosage sarafem drugs for sale prednisone 5mg tablets picture cheap mexican pain pills forgot zoloft dose lopressor dosage for anxiety post cycle therapy viagra jelly no prescription celebrex roxithromycin woldwide shipping safe to buy generic amitriptyline from canada canadianpharmacy cleocin gel 5mg tablets oder mg tablets of eltroxin dangers of accutane acne treatment order eltroxin no rx canadian pharmacy mevacor best online non prescription pharmacy $50 advair coupon 2012 ranitidine 300 mg tablet glenmark coversyl delivery london buy cytoxan greece femara letrozole cancer buy flomax online india buy zyvox 100mg online zyprexa discounts estrace from usa pharmacy toprol coupons generic name for brand viagra januvia sale 2009 cialis super active overnight delivery soft online pill overnight pariet online prescription buy what drug category is bisoprololi fumaras aciclovir tablets to buy 200mg how to order meclizine my viagra genuine buy periactin from canada order zyban on line mexico mexico pharmacies online that sell cefadroxil generico do medicamento vytorin get canadian drugs promo code best place to buy revia in uk lamictal on line for sale no script mail order lotrisone purchase paroxetine hydrochloride order malegra dxt on line uk order vagifem online order prednisolona online no prescription with a amex bystolic india no prescription oryginalny cialis gdzie kupic compazine buy online canada where to buy clomid online cialis jelly now can you get antivert propranolol 100mg cheep can i get acai berry in nigeria buy eldepryl pills online original quibron t online can you buy lexapro in ireland simvastatina coupons legal viagra online cipro uses and side effects where eagles dare helicopter where can i get kamagra oral jelly from exelon patch where to apply cheap promethizine without prescription nitroglycerin cream online decadron comments lamisil drug classification metformin and clomid 100mg success stories low price lopid uk canadian pharmacy online toprol dramamine drug canadian pharmacy what color are dramamine pills cost of generic 5mg cialis zebeta dose oxybutyninum no script where to buy floxin with echeck simvastatina mg india to buy crestor all types of drugs with pictures buying cialis super active sinequan online india viagra effects pictures medical diamox tablets price where can you buy hyaluronic acid online pharmacy technician certification canada order citalopram canada estrace over the counter australia zentel canada overnight delivery buy kamagra pay with paypal voltaren canadian online generic clomifene uk paypal comprar betnovate pela internet order proscar from india without prescription albenda legal us order isoniazid from pharmacy my astelin coupons buy ampicillin for fish 500mg clopidogrelum from uk 1000 mg propranolol metformin hydrochloride tablets ip 500mg price side effects of nizagara can you get plavix research grade vardenafilum resources for glycomet maxalt discount nexium prescription drug interactions buy keftab online usa what is fluoxetine for can buy fucidin cream over counter uk where can i get reglan from buy dulcolax without a script much does 1 viagra pill cost order cystone tablets clozaril generic best place buy benicar lisinopril interaction with other drugs alli simpson wikipedia bahasa indonesia imitrex brand order fasigyn medication on line
الرئيسية | النادي اللغوي | بحوث نحوية | المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود
 

صفحة شبكة صوت العربية في فيسبوكtwitterقناة شبكة صوت العربية في يوتيوبشبكة صوت العربية في موقع فليكر

المدارس النحوية - النشأة والخلاف في المفهوم والوجود طباعة إرسال إلى صديق
تصنيفات: بحوث نحوية
تقييم المستخدمين: / 54
سيئجيد 
الكاتب أحمد مجرشي   
الأحد, 10 أبريل 2011 20:07

النشأة :
سيقودنا الحديث عن نشأة هذا المصطلح إلى الحديث عن مناهج النحويين واختلاف آرائهم في الأصول والفروع وهل يرقى هذا الاختلاف لتتميز منه مذاهب ومدارس لها حدود واضحة المعالم أم إن الخلاف يقف عند الفروع لا يتجاوزها فلا يستحق أن يطلع عليها مدرسة أم إنه أقل من ذلك فهو مذهب واحد وطريقة ؟ واحدة تختلف بعض فروعها اختلافا يسيرا داخل نطاق المنهج ولا يخرج عنه .

وقبل التفصيل في هذه المسائل ينبغي أن نعرف إجمالا أن موضوع التقسيم مر بثلاث مراحل هي :

الأولى : تسمية العلماء بأمصارهم وبلدانهم مما يوحي بوجود مذهب خاص بهم أو لا يوحي بذلك .
الثانية : تقسيم مناهجهم وطرقهم وتسميتها بـ " مذهب " وهي مرحلة تالية للمرحلة السابقة .
الثالثة : إطلاق اسم " مدرسة " على المذهب أو على أهل الأمصار وهذه التسمية أطلقت حديثا في الوقت المعاصر.
و بيان ذلك على النحو التالي :

أولا :
"يتضح لنا من عرض مناهج الذين أرخوا للنحو والنحاة من القدماء أنهم اتبعوا في ترتيبهم نسبتهم للبلد الذي ظهروا فيه وتعلموا نحوه ودرسوه أو درّسوه فهم بصريون وكوفيون وأهل بغداد"(1).
"وأول من يلقنا من القدماء محمد بن سلام الجمحي ( 139-231هـ) الذي قال :" وكان لأهل البصرة في العربية قدامة وبالنحو ولغات العرب والغريب عناية "(2).
وترجم لأبي الأسود الدؤلي وعدّه مؤسس علم العربية وليحيى بن يعمر ولعبدالله بن إسحاق الحضرمي ولأبي عمرو بن العلاء وانتهى بالخليل بن أحمد الفراهيدي ولم ينسبهم إلى مدرسة وإنما عدهم من أهل البصرة (3).
وأعقبه أبو محمد عبدالله بن مسلم بن قتيبة الدينوري ( 213 – 276 هـ ) الذي عقد في كتابه "المعارف" بحثا لرواة الشعر وأصحاب الغريب والنحو وترجم بإيجاز لمعظم من اشتهر بهذه العلوم من البصريين والكوفيين ... ويلاحظ في ترجمته لهم أنه لم يذكرهم مقسمين إلى بصريين وكوفيين معتمدا على شهرتهم ولم يسمهم بمذهب أو مدرسة (4).
وجاء بعدهما أبو الطيب عبدالواحد بن علي اللغوي الحلبي ( ت 351هـ ) وألف كتاب "مراتب النحويين" ورتبه حسب الزمن مبتدئا بالبصريين لأن النحو في البصرة كان أقدم نشوءا منه في الكوفة ... وكانت أول إشارة إلى الكوفة عند ترجمته لأبي جعفر الرؤاسي حيث قال : وممن أخذ عن أبي عمرو أبو جعفر الرؤاسي عالم الكوفة (5).
والدليل على أنهم كانوا ينسبون النحاة إلى البلد ويذكرونه في ترجمتهم بحسب البلدان أن أبا الطيب ختم كتابه بعد الانتهاء من ذكر البصريين والكوفيين بقوله :" ولا علم للعرب إلا في هاتين المدينتين "(6).

ثانيا :
كان أبو بكر محمد بن الحسن الزبيدي ( ت 379هـ ) أول من استخدم كلمة " مذهب " عندما ترجم لأصحاب ثعلب فقال عن أبي موسى الحامض : " كان بارعا في اللغة والنحو على مذهب الكوفيين "(7)
"وقال عن ابن كيسان وكان بصريا كوفيا يحفظ القولين ويعرف المذهبين وكان أخذ عن ثعلب والمبرد وكان ميله إلى مذهب البصريين أكثر ... وكان أبو بكر ابن الأنباري شديد التعصب على ابن كيسان والتنقص له وكان يقول : خلط فلم يضبط مذهب الكوفيين ولا مذهب البصريين"(8).

ومن هنا يتضح أن الزبيدي كان أول من قسم النحاة إلى مجموعات بحسب البلدان التي عرفوا بها وكان أول من استخدم عبارات "مذهب الكوفيين" و "مذهب البصريين" و "المذهبين" ويريد بذلك أن النحو متابع
لآراء نحاة الكوفة أو لآراء نحاة البصرة أو لنحاة المدينتين(9).
وجاء بعده ابن النديم· (ت 385 هـ ) واتبع التقسيم نفسه إلا أنه سمى نحاة بغداد " من خلط المذهبين " (10).
وبعدهما جاء أبو البركات الأنباري ( ت 577 هـ ) فقد اتبع في كتابه "نزهة الألباء في طبقات الأدباء" التسلسل الزمني ولم يذكر كلمة مذهب إلى مع البغداديين في الغالب كقوله : " وكان يخلط المذهبين " أو " وكان قيما بمذهب البصريين والكوفيين "(11).

ثالثا :
استحسن الباحثون المحدثون مصطلح "المدرسة" بمعنى المذهب النحوي وقد كانوا في ذلك متأثرين بالغربيين الذين شاع عندهم هذا المصطلح بهذا المفهوم ونجاحه في الدراسات الأدبية فكان عندهم المدرسة الكلاسيكية في الأدب والفن والمدرسة الرومانتيكية والمدرسة الرمزية(12).
وكان من أوائل من استخدم هذا المصطلح "جوتولد فايل" الذي سماهما المدرسة البصرية والمدرسة الكوفية وتبعه في ذلك "بروكلمان" الذي قال : " وقد قسم علماء العربية مذاهب النحو إلى ثلاث مدارس : البصريين والكوفيين ومن مزجوا المذهبين من علماء بغداد "(13).
واستخدم المحدثون الكلمة نفسها ولعل الدكتور مهدي المخزومي أول من تبنى هذه التسمية فسمى أحد كتبه "مدرسة الكوفة ومنهجها في دراسة اللغة والنحو" وألف الدكتور شوقي ضيف كتابا سماه "المدارس النحوية" وألف الدكتور عبدالرحمن السيد كتابا سماه "مدرسة البصرة النحوية (14).

مفهوم المذهب والمدرسة :
1 - مفهوم المذهب النحوي :
المذهب مصطلح فقهي في بداية نشأته فيقال مذهب الإمام الشافعي أو الإمام مالك أو مذهب شيخنا ... وانتقل إلى اللغة حيث أصبح يعبر عن مجموعة مبادئ وآراء متصلة ومنسقة لمفكر ما أو لاتجاه ما .
وفي التعريف النحوي الدقيق هو : طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد تعتنق مذهبا نحويا وتقول برأي نحوي مشترك وتجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع (15).

2 - مفهوم المدرسة النحوية :
بعد الحديث عن تطور مسمى المناهج النحوية وطرق النحويين لعل الوقت قد حان للحديث عن مفهوم المدرسة عند المتأخرين .
فقد عرف المعجم الوسيط مصطلح المدرسة - بهذا المفهوم الجديد - بقوله :" المدرسة جماعة من الفلاسفة والمفكرين أو الباحثين تعتنق مذهبا معينا أو تقول برأي مشترك "(16).
وعند المتأخرين تعريفات كثيرة للمدرسة وكلها تدور حول هذا المعنى وسنستعرض فيما يلي بعضها .
عرف "جوتولد فايل" المدرس بأنها : "الاشتراك في وجهة النظر الذي يؤلف الجبهة العلمية ويربط العلماء بعضهم ببعض على رأي واحد "(17).
والأستاذ على النجدي ناصف يعرف المدرسة بقوله :" المدرسة طائفة من أولي العلم الواحد أو الفن الواحد تجمعهم وحدة أصوله ومناهج البحث فيه وإن تعددت أوطانهم واختلفت أجناسهم ومهما تنوعت شخصياتهم العلمية وتباعدت آراؤهم في الفروع والتفاصيل ".
وعرفها الدكتور أحمد مكي الأنصاري بقوله :" اتجاه له خصائص مميزة ينادي بها فرد أو جماعة من الناس ثم ينادي بها آخرون ".
على حين يعرفها الدكتور مهدي الخزمومي بقوله :" فليست المدرسة إلا أستاذا مؤثرا وتلاميذ متأثرين وقد اجتمعوا على تحقيق غرض موحد نهجوا للوصول إليه منهاجا "(18).
قال ذلك في مدرسة الكوفة عند كلامه على الكسائي إذ قال :" إن الكسائي بمنهاجه وأساليب دراسته مدرسة لها خصائصها ومناهجها فليست المدرسة إلا ..." ثم ساق التعريف .
وقريب من هذا التعريف ما انتهى إليه الدكتور أحمد مختار عمر وهو قوله :" وجود جماعة من النحاة يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج في دراسة النحو ولابد أن يكون هناك الرائد الذي يرسم الخطة ويحدد المنهج والتابعون أو المريدون الذين يعتنقون خطاه ويتبنون منهجه ويعملون على تطويره والدفاع عنه (19).
وقد أخذ محمد حسين آل ياسين في كتاب "الدراسات اللغوية" بتعريف "جوتولد فايل" حيث يقول:" المدرسة في المصطلح العلمي لفظ يطلع على جماعة من الدارسين تشترك في وجهة النظر ويكون لها نهج خاص يؤلف منها جبهة علمية ويربط أفرادها برابط الرأي الموحد "(20).
وقد حاول الدكتور صالح بلعيد الجمع بين التعريفات السابقة فقال إن المدرسة :" كلمة معاصرة تعني الجماعة الذي يشكلون درسا واحدا في بيئة معينة أو بيئات معينة متعددة ويجمعهم نهج واحد أو الاشتراك في وجهة النظر التي تؤلف جبهة علمية واحدة ووجود الجماعة الذي يصل بينهم رابط من وحدة الفكر والمنهج ويكون اتفاقهم على الأصول لا الفروع وعلى رأس المدرسة من يرسم الخطة ويحدد والمنهج وهو الشيخ أو الرئيس والمريدون الذي يعتنقون خطاه ويعملون على تطويرها الدفاع عنه "(21).
ونلاحظ أن هذا إلى التوصيف أقرب منه إلى التعريف حيث جمع ما في التعريفات الأخرى وضمنها هذا التوصيف .
ونخلص مما سبق إلى أن هذه التعريفات تتفق على وجود جماعة من الناس يعتنقون منهجا محددا ذا خصائص ومميزات يؤمنون به ويدافعون عنه وإن لم تجمعهم وحدة جغرافية ولا يشترط الاتفاق على الفروع بل يكفي اتفاقهم على أصول المنهج .
والتعريفات السابقة بهذا المعنى أو قريبة منه جدا ، ولذا نلاحظ أنها بدأت بـ :" جماعة " أو " طائفة " وبدأت أحيانا بـ :" الاشتراك في وجهة نظر " أو " اتجاه له خصائص " وهما – الجماعة والمنهج – الركنان الأساسيان في التعريفات السابقة .
هل توجد مذاهب نحوية أو مدارس نحوية ؟
أولا : المذاهب النحوية
جرى الأقدمون على أن هناك مذهبا في النحو يسمى المذهب البصري ومذهبا آخر في النحو يسمى المذهب الكوفي كما ذكرت بعض مؤلفات الأقدمين أن هناك نحاة مصريين ونحاة أندلسيين (22).

ثانيا : المدارس النحوية
تعددت آراء الباحثين المحدثين في المدارس النحوية بين الإثبات والرفض على ما يأتي :

الرأي الأول :
أنه لا توجد مدارس نحوية إطلاقا وإنما هي تجمعات جغرافية ولا يوجد مدارس نحوية تتميز كل منها بأسلوبها الخاص ومنهاجها الذاتي وتطبق هذه المجموعات أصولا واحدة وإن اختلفت في الفروع وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ سعيد الأفغاني والأستاذ على أبو المكارم (23).

الرأي الثاني :
أنه لا توجد إلا مدرسة نحوية واحدة هي مدرسة البصرة فقط وأنكر هذا الفريق وجود مدرسة الكوفة وممن قال بهذا الرأي الأستاذ الدكتور إبراهيم السامرائي وقد سبقه إلى القول بهذا "جوتولد فايل" (24).

الرأي الثالث :
أثبت فريق ثالث من النحويين وجود مدرستين بصرية وكوفية وتردد في القبول بوجود مدرسة بغدادية ويمثل هذا القول الدكتور مهدي المخزومي ، وقد تابعوا في ذلك الزبيدي في طبقاته حيث نظم أفراد المدرسة البغدادية مع رجال المدرسة البصرية والكوفية على حسب اتجاهه وميوله(25).
وما قيل في المدرسة البغدادية ينطبق على بقية المدارس كالأندلسية والمصرية.

الترجيح بين الآراء :
إذا دققنا النظر في الأوصاف التي يطلقها القدماء على الدراسات النحوية غير البصرية والكوفية وجدناها لا تخرج عن وصف هذه الدراسات أو الدارسين لأنهم خلطوا المذهبين أو النحوين أو مزجوا بينهما وهذا يدعونا إلى أنه ليس هناك خلاف بين هذا النحو والنحوين الآخرين خلافا لما نراه من الفروق بين منهجي البصرة والكوفة .
وهذا ينتهي بنا إلى القول بأنه ليس في النحو العربي إلا مدرستان أو مذهبان فقط هما البصرة والكوفة (26).
------------
(1)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي ص / 13 بتصرف .
(2)· نقلته عن : طبقات فحول الشعراء 1 / 12
(3)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 7 بتصرف .
(4)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(5)· المرجع السابق· ص / 8
(6)· المرجع السابق· ص / 10
(7)· نقلته عنه : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170
(8)· نلقته عن : طبقات النحويين واللغويين· ص / 170-171
(9)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 11
(10)· المرجع السابق· ص / 11
(11)· المرجع السابق· ص / 12
(12)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(13)· نقلته عن : تاريخ الأدب العربي· 2 / 124 – 125
(14)· المدارس النحوية د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 13
(15)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 144
(16)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 148
(17) المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(18)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(19)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 14
(20)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 149
(21)· المرجع السابق· ص / 149 – 150
(22)· في أصول النحو· د. صالح بلعيد· ص / 145
(23)· مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي· د. عبدالله الخثران· ص / 151 نقله عن طبقات الزبيدي· ص / 213 – 253
(24)· أنظر مراحل تطور الدرس النحوي د.عبدالله الخثران والمدارس النحوي د. خديجة الحديثي .
(25)· المرجعان السابقان والمدارس النحوية أسطورة وواقع د. إبراهيم السامرائي ص / 139 – 141
(26)· المدارس النحوية· د. خديجة الحديثي· ص / 16
------------
أحمد بن محمد مجرشي
طالب ماجستير قسم النحو والصرف وفقه اللغة

 
Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack