buy ciprofloksacin mg online buy advair diskus in singapore for sale colchicine is generic fasigyne available in usa valtrex mg india alli usa no prescription cialis jelly over the counter drugs metformin pharmacy information ditropan to buy in the canada without a prescription india kytril price donde puedo comprar viagra generico atorvastatin tablets spc wellbutrin sr 100mg bupron sr generic australia voltaren 50 mg filmtabletten novartis order motrin 120 mg yasmin tablets 150 mg buy ginseng root plant betapace brand order descargar dvd culturismo sin tonterias gratis viagra plus over the counter canada confido buy online uk a good web page to buy priligy with no script toppik side effects propecia safe to buy generic zocor from uk cheapest femara tablets uk sale accutane doxycycline uses uti mail order generic oestrogel costco pharmacy triamterene price luvox without a prescription from mexico buy accutane online canada isotretinoin what symptoms does metformin treat positive paxil reviews how to import midamor the chepest dutasterid nifedipine pregnancy risks german remedies ltd website diflucan 150 mg prospect is isoptin legal in uk can i order periactin no prescription in the usa cheap cafergot online celebrex 100 dosage astelin pharmacy coupons neurontin weight gain loss insurance coverage for viagra beloc zok analogai atrovent 10 mg cost can order hydrodiuril online safe to buy generic quibron t from usa cheap brahmi uk clindamycin lotion uses how to get buspar drug cleocin gel uk pharmacy zovirax to buy in the canada without a prescription plendil bonus pills most common side effects of hydrea chloroquine shopping aleve sale caverta without prescription miami awccanadianpharmacy review mirapex online legally what is the antidote for digoxin toxicity what are the side effects of fluoxetine hcl side effects of metronidazol can you order fluconazol can i buy advair in canada maxalt mlt discontinued pletal 100 mg uses which uk site to buy lotrisone healthyman ciprofloksacin australia companies only lasix no prescription north american express list of weakest to strongest acids online abilify with no prescription cheap tadapox 100 mg citalopram to buy in the uk without a prescription united airlines customer support phone number elimite delivery london silenafil citrate how long to take carafate buy feldene 10 shuddha guggulu canada overnight delivery safe place order sinequan donde puedo comprar kamagra gold can i make floxin pain meds for kidney stones during pregnancy ciprofloksacin not generic can we trust procardia online tofranil 10 mg children no signs of ovulation on clomid zoloft 10mg side effects ciprofloxacina women buy canadian pharmacy for antibiotics without prescription pil viagra tricor from canada with no prescription buy risperdal tablets mexico canadian pharmacy lamisil granules buy permethrinum pills online safe to buy generic tricor from uk ordering viagra super active 100mg sildenafil prazosin side effects uk order generic capoten where to buy metformin online abortion pill online pharmacy uk comprar revia online do people abuse zanaflex zyban to purchase without a prescription illegal prescription drug sales hydrocodonefrom candacheap donde puedo comprar acai berry thin what does tegretol do to you bisoprololi fumaras on line in the canada vipps purchase venlafaxina mg how to purchase adalat carafate now co uk terramycin from canadian pharmacy free or low cost glycomet levaquin refill pack misoprost online mexico buy ivenox online in the united states without a prescription the chepest flunil acivir pills without a prescription from canada antara to buy order neurontin from india without prescription trial erection packs 1 canada drugs celexa medicine online buy amlodipinbesilat online from uk canadian aciphex drug can order blopress online trimox spain buy himcolin pills in the mexico what is doxycycline monohydrate 100 mg singulair buy online ireland mail order generic diarex buy online flunil generic grifulvin v not generic abilify 5 mg canada canadian drug company procardia cefixime pills online in the australia periactin tablets for cats best place to buy wellbutrin in india generic beta val usa pharmacy cytotec 100 mcg side effects rosuvastatin api price sominex paypal mentat cheap canada pharmacy avapro online from india phenamax generic uk ethionamide online in us roaccutan legal us decadron tablets online viagra shoppers drug mart price generic snovitra super power for sale on line allopurinol cheap india pharmacy order oestrogel on line uk canada pharmacies online that sell kamagra buy shallaki online overnight reversing side effects of propecia can you order quetiapinum trental lawsuit settlements para comprar viagra se necesita receta us no prescription pharmacies deltasone generic reviews diarex from canada buy indocin online from uk antara lowest price online oder mg tablets of seroquel what is aceon mg used to treat how to buy zyloprim in london fast leukeran deleviery is it illegal to order generic toradol buy nitrofurantoin 100mg online buy moduretic in india online where to buy zestoretic with amex how to buy synthroid without a prescription how to take prednisone 50 mg robaxin drug oversea what does cephalexin pills look like best prescription pill to get high buy rocaltrol with paypal buy ophthacare inhaler canada long time side effects floxin retin a 0,05 mg uk micardis mail order india online pharmacy uk erection packs 2 discount tizanidinum otc birth control pills combivent discount albuterol from canada canada pharmacies online that sell rosuvastatin buy cialis in malaysia floxin without a script ashwagandha prices at costco pharmacy buy drugs motrin purchase zoloft in canada taking more than 100mg of viagra what is bupropion hcl generic for best place to buy synthroid is there a shortage of nizoral buy lipitor online with mastercard where can you get lamisil confido perth australia generic metrogel no prescription prinivil for dogs buy advair diskus dose risperdal tablets 2 mg indian generics online acai trial erection packs 1 canada overnight delivery order eulexin medication by mail withdrawal from paxil effects buy baridium online from canada toradol dose pediatrica iai arava 101 viagra se puede tomar keftab medication overnight delivery asacol online australia nymphomax pharmacy why are canadian prescription drugs so cheap buspar with no perscription metronidazole india macrobid mexico clonidine australia best site get otomax selegiline hydrochloride uses flovent online pharmacy uk buy trileptal online from mexico real viagra online with prescription no prescription curacne sale minocin pharmacy order cheap medrol boots bupron sr london pharmacy vardenafilum order by phone order diflucan over the counter pill generic citalopram us where to buy viagra in kuala lumpur purchase baclofen 10 mg aceon for sale usa cheap fursomide generic cardura paypal celexa mexico no prescription nexium canada cost us pharmacies online that sell bactrim luvox pills online in the mexico buy benemid boots side effects of pain pills addiction furosemide medicinenet com meclizine without prescription medication order orlistatum online no presctiption bupropion depression dosage where do i vagifem in australia american calan northwood what is alesse 28 order weight gain ponstel acnetane birth control online australia levitra uk supplier buy letrozole cheap australia c ratioph pills online in the canada buying colchicina in manchester ovral l canadian online overnight pharmacy how to buy norvasc generic combivent canada buy premarin 15mg online seroflo online forum comprar adoair where to buy acticin online mexico pharm support group propecia detrol india kamagra oral jelly generic4all buying drugs canada no prescription kelnor fast mexico purchase caprysin on line in canada where to buy betnovate with echeck where can i get maxalt pills imitrex 100mg dosage best site for augmentin cialis sales 2013 how to take motilium m venlafaxina online usa no prescription flexeril cyclobenzaprine uk microzide pharmacy order sertralina with no subscription albenza over the counter uk buspar wanted online review lipitor usa generic beconase aq brand order how to order orlistat bupron birth control online uk india cytoxan price order zedd rx buy eldepryl inhaler canada safe to buy generic ciprofloksacin from uk can you buy oxytrol is it safe to order zestril buy zentel pills in the mexico buy serophene boots pharmacy can i order prograf no prescription in the usa cheap cialis online india proventil perth australia how to by metformin online remedio singulair mais barato viagra 10 mg fiyat buy prinivil cheapest lisinopril is generic pletal effective amaryl low dose birth control cheap bystolic 10mg ligament of marshall coumadin ridge levothroid online pay paypal buy viagra over counter germany non prescription detrol pharmacy requip no prescription needed canadian online pharmacy quibron t tablets price topamax shortage optimmune 2mg benemid italiano how long is the shelf life of viagra without cheapest online alphagan midamor brands india med cab voveran sr amaryllis order online mexico pharmacies online that sell orlistatum what types of serevent are there confido online ordering buy mirapex online without a prescription generic brand of prilosec purchase rogaine 5 in australia buy fluoxetine astrailia westhroid patient reviews is there a generic skelaxin bactrim not generic how much nolvadex for gyno can you order pulmicort budesonide can you buy endep in ireland myambutol express canada cytotec medication side effects generic zetia drug what doses does crestor come in where to buy vardenafilum online india proventil online canadian flagyl from canada what is prednisone 20mg medication trial erection packs 2 without subscription order prednisolone on line uk cytotec with american express want buy abortion pills online zoloft weight loss dosage how much is zyban tablets lantus supplier in uk capoten tablets online fast ceftin deleviery metformin 850 mg tablets picture safe isoniazid no prescription buy januvia uk how to order dapoxetine online buy aviane 28 low cheap price buy lipitor without prescription revia tablets online buy robaxin online rocaltrol 0.25 mg generic lamisilate switzerland effexor weight gain medical questions reviews on torsemide can we trust estrofem online warafin for purchase without a prescription effexor xr from canada without rx zyloprim to buy in england order brand advair diskus 120 mg ranitidine trusted online drug stores in canada haldol on line in the india i pill paxil website order vermox uk pharmacy vermox uk companies only clomid venta on line buy erexin low cheap price over the counter skelaxin doxycycline dosage for acne rosacea januvia online usa over counter furosemide oder mg tablets of sepibest what is anacin pills used for top three pharmaceutical wholesalers distributors claritin lowest price order weight gain duphalac liv 52 weight gain buy cheap medrol color accutane pills where purchase speman olanzapine by mail brafix no rx lansoprazol pill shortage purchase levothyroid in usa order triamterenum online uk estrace medication online mircette online in us amitriptyline without prescription cost of vermox without insurance prinivil canada companies only viagra sublingual without a perscription estro with paypal payment propranolol fda approved to buy without prescription benicar medication for high blood pressure fast calcium carbonate delivery pastillas cialis efectos most reliable place to buy zoloft online canadian pharmacy allegra is generic clomifene effective purchase disulfiramum on line in the uk natural supplement loc:fr cheap generic isoniazid oracion de sanacion con el padre chelo levitra 20 mg in uk order lasilix on line uk meclizine dosage for cats premarin without a prescription from uk diovan discounted glaucoma medications alphagan order sinequan from uk without prescription is requip a prescription drug order erexin v online without rx etodolac for sale philippines canadian actos purchase vistaril on line in usa cymbalta 100mg cheap albuterol inhaler order duloxetine dosage and administration coreg online order gabapentine buy australia how to buy benfotiamine in london buy generic paxil no prescription compazine to purchase without a prescription is there anything over the counter like viagra what is diovan medication used for side effects in dogs taking prednisone how to order styplon online buy confido have no prescription tenormin pills drugstore vistaril pills buy online purchase nootropil in canada best unisom prices buyers of clozaril canada order serevent from usa without prescription maxaman canada where do i buspar in canada naprosyn over counter australia buy mobicarte orange france buy bactroban online canada buy plendil without a subscription buying silagra ditropan in usa capoten maximum dosage indian allegra costa jewels prednisone pack directions celexa generic release date where to buy viagra no prescription my minocin coupons abilify prescription only seroflo roche precio argentina buy bupron online thru paypals generic for ventolin how to get acticin where to buy dulcolax keflex alcohol side effects what is the drug keflex used for buy pilex australia atomoxetine strattera dosage buy renova tablets mexico how to get nicotinell drug a good web page to buy abilify with no script does erythromycin topical gel work for acne buy azitromicina mg mircette for sale australia generic zyrtec safe dosering av kamagra bupropion xl shortage trazodone shortage uk 2013 buy bactrim online from australia dostinex online pharmacy caverta 50 mg side effects indian generics online oestrogel generic for phenergan dm is mail order nizoral safe cytotec available in philippines can a healthy male use viagra buy actoplus singapore propecia finasteride cost buy parlodel online amazon liponexol 50mg tablets buy paroxetine 10mg buy dipyridamole generic flonase trusted online drug stores in canada aceon pas cher italie how does viagra work on young men prednisona buy australia quiero comprar cytotec triderm krem bez recepty actoplus met discount no prescription canada buy duphalac without prescription nitroglycerin tablets during heart attack alesse online ordering buy claritin with paypal where can i find over the counter viagra cheap femara buy online duprost from australia where can i buy tretinoin 0,05 mg purchase acivir pills 3 mg best price for real l thyroxine levitra super active 100 retino a cream 0 05 canadian pharmacy buy ovral l in singapore comprar reglan original capoten on line desyrel side effects hair loss taking thyroid medication every other day brahmi to buy in australia where do i zydis in mexico lansoprazol trusted online drug stores in canada can you buy alli at walmart orlistat why has thyroxin been discontinued buy trial erection packs 3 mg online malegra dxt fast uk elavil sleeping pills cheapest cymbalta to buy how much is actonel tablets crush zyvox tablets aldactone brand order meclizine over the counter vs. prescription kamagra oral jelly boots steel erection blue pills purchase indocin in australia what is amlodipine diltiazem lowest price buy unique hoodia in australia azulfidine over the counter med cab levaquin order kelnor online no prescription with a amex order generic lisinopril what is the cost for voltaren gel how to take unisom and b6 plavic for sale leukeran usa pharmacy what is tablet hytrin comprar voveran sr online anafranil india companies only can you buy l thyroxine himcocid for sale philippines dilantin maximum daily dose prograf 100mg cheap alfa flucon from mexico where do i fasigyn in mexico mupirocin ointment over the counter bystolic canada head office lotrel tablets price what does omnicef ordering medication alesse mg anti malaria pills doxycycline over the counter drugs similar to torsemide viagra jelly online australia stieva a for men in usa betnovate cream prescription only buy generic predalone online with prescription micronase 10 mg cost drug classification of ampicillin where can i buy metronidazole for dogs canada pharmacies online that sell sominex oral prednisone side effects in children pet meds no rx required i pill didronel website buy ivenox online australia no prescription buy carbozyne tablets canada order erection packs 1 online no prescription with a echeck how to by trial erection packs 2 online dose maxima de ginseng hospital pharmacy technician association ireland what is lansoprazol used for buy viagra in england buy retino a cream 0 05 discount discount colchicine from usa avodart uk colchicina without a prescription from canada buy generic inderal online no prescription skelaxin shop net generic antabuse buy canada liv clothing sale retin a cost in canada discount maxalt clozaril daily use reviews order zestoretic online no presctiption side effects of zovirax cream etodolac capsules 300mg buy triamterene tablets generic zyrtec reviews my grifulvin v coupons medicine actoplus met where to buy rogaine 5 with mastercard where do i atorlip 10 in mexico half price atorlip 5 prednisone best price astelin canada sale micardis drugs online purchases citalopram generic india combivent birth control online uk beat way to order dapoxetine purchase generic tadalis disulphiram pharmacy order benzac next day quibron t online forum to buy reminyl in uk buy seroquel online usa ophthacare sold over counter post cycle therapy fluoxetine cilest generic australia cheapest isoptin tablets uk prednisone over the counter drug proscar drug category how long does it take for voltaren gel to take effect current price epivir hbv new allies wow what is norvasc for buying propecia in the uk claritin anti allergy mattress protector reviews buy pilex online india what is tamoxifen citrate tablets for valtrex tablets online celexa medication side effects effectiveness lipitor topped worldwide drug sales in 2010 bactrim without a prescription from mexico artane generic release date trazodone class of medication apo furosemida for sale mixing paroxetine and alcohol buy kamagra gold paypal accepted long term side effects of atarax buy cheap roxithromycin pills over counter levothyroxin best new ed drugs to buy amoxil in uk what is the generic name for cytotec celebrex coupon code ordering viagra jelly pink viagra for men maxaman cheap uk flovent generic uk buy tamoxifen pills can you buy lamisil over the counter in canada antifungals buy brafix perth australia what is diclofenac sod 75 mg used for best price nizoral shampoo amitriptyline discount code colchicina canada no prescription cialis sublingual online pharmacies with out prescription cheap generic valtrex levoxyl no script pharmacy buy drugs clopidogrelum purchase flomax cheap lincocin shop net flonase no prescription compare prices where do i zetia in canada buying hoodia in south africa synthroid online bestellen prescription aciphex online yasmin overseas buy permethrinum without rx key pred without a prescription from canada vytorin patient reviews taking clomid cycle days 5 9 trileptal without prescription pills will medrol dose pack cause weight gain buy prednisone online without a prescription ranitidine hcl oral tablet 300 mg us pharmacy online nootropil buy januvia with no script prandin pas cher how long to take metformin for pcos minocin acne dose differin generic for buy betoptic australia fucidin 2 cream uk buy generic abana drugs wellbutrin drug in usa pharmacy how long does it take for protonix to work generic lipothin viagra pago por paypal what kind of pill is orlistat 60 walgreens online pharmacy prices buy anastrozolo pills in the india metoclopramide medication online inhouse pharmacy vanuatu max dose of triamterene key pred limited india maxalt maximum daily dose motrin online from uk etabus with prescription when will lexapro have a generic order revatio online best brand viagra prices discount pill benfotiamine dose neuropathy can you buy crestor buy plavix online from canada cheap beconase aq buy online anything better than alli propranolol birth control online canada aldactone bodybuilding women estrace canada prescription online no prescription uk for doxi 1 buy maxaman online australia no prescription flagyl generic australia cheap doxazosin no prescription speman best price order oracea from mexico without prescription where to find viagra in nyc lasix tablets uses purchase ovral l in australia predalone cheap uk cheap vagifem pills buy kamagra ajanta pharm no prescription needed kamagra prednisone for cats medication lotrisone pills buy online order clomid from india without prescription buy trental online from mexico order clavamox on line canada nordette online purchase buy acai online from uk suprax without a prescription from india prevacid generic solutab how to take tadalafil tablets buy benfotiamine pills solu medrol package insert order lanoxin online no prescription with a echeck alli weight loss program coupons western drug astelin blopress barato cheap zantac 150 ditropan shortage 2012 buy rosuvastatin with e check usa buy novo digoxin without prescription buy lozol no prescription famvir canada prescription tetracycline side effects anxiety naprosyn 500mg antabuse effect antibiotics best place to buy furosemide in canada stieva a online from india generic pills for nitroglycerin order femara from what does flovent do grifulvin v overnight nolva or arimidex for gyno viagra tablets in india can buy sustiva online what does levaquin look like nordette to buy from europe buy keftab tablets australia florinef mexico no prescription where to buy xenical tablets revatio iv pfizer flucazole india companies only what is zithromax for dogs xeloda and alcohol can you buy plavix resources for compazine is advair diskus a prescription drug acheter tricorne cuir buy strattera capsules where can i buy metronidazole flagyl prozac birth control online india is generic metformin as good as glucophage lisinopril 20 mg used can you buy singulair cheap montelukast does pomegranate juice boost testosterone where is yasmine bleeth 2012 is bystolic a prescription drug purchase glucofage in uk buy shallaki online pharmacy pyridium mexico companies only anastrozolo lawsuit reviews on yagara lov cost diabecon fasigyne brands india generic bupron cost bactrim order online without a prescription celexa weight gain side effects garden greens acaicleanse 48 hour acai berry detox liquid reviews generic curacne uk paypal buy otc drugs online cheapest maxaman tablets uk what is voveran sr pills used for order anafranil online uk what are mobic tablets used for lipitor price comparison uk order caffeine ergotamine without prescription zofran on line purchase cheap actos 20 mg femara for infertility 2012 revatio generic india where country is rita ora from fda approved online pharmacy coumadin prices usa disulfiramum cheap india pharmacy best cialis soft prices 20mg cipla best place to buy yaz in canada is it safe to order detrol purchase allopurinol in us levothroid uk sale canadian pharmacy carbozyne how to buy maxalt buy viagra online boots counter buy betapace pills where can i purchase eldepryl pharmacy mexico viagra super active best place to buy cymbalta in uk buy online legal antibiotics without can you buy clavamox over the counter in germany pulmicort usa pharmacy long term benadryl use in dogs gout treatment colchicine or allopurinol all natural fertility pills capoten pill shortage ordering confido uk lamictal shop net phenergan dose iv top 10 online imitrex sites prescription drug sales database buyers of synthroid canada use viagra and cialis together is the generic for synthroid as effective as synthroid viagra 100 mg precio mexico online pharmacy almetec what does diakof cytotec with no rx buy glucofage online without prescription ondansetrona birth control online uk buy brand salbutamol maxaman cheapest rate losartan hydrochlorothiazide spc cheap keppra no prescription purchase rythmol sr on line in usa can order cozaar canada clopidogrelum without script buy acai juice uk why has aldactone been discontinued celexa 40mg tablets buy zestril in uk aripiprazola tablets online what is neurontin used for anxiety best place to buy periactin in mexico purchase toprol xl on line in canada actoplus generic wikipedia drugs is it legal to order drugs from mexico buy januvia pills in the us can i buy betnovate in canada plendil germany drinking alcohol accutane side effects us pharmacies online that sell prednisone levitra overnight prescription luvox from canada without rx buspar 100mg tablet zestoretic canada no prescription where to buy vardenafilum online canada snovitra super power brands india buy levlen tablets buy lotensin in usa generic retin a 0,025 india zetia drug store online no prescription zyrtec sale buy erection packs 1 online from mexico yasmin pills philippines cheapest synthroid tablets uk ropinirole extended release tablets buy generic hoodia with bonus bupropion drug in mexico pharmacy lisinopril 100mg tablet vytorin without a perscription buy propecia tablets australia buy prednisolone online from uk acquistare medrol in italia alli coupons december 2012 tadalis sx tablets purchase on line tenormin uk no prescription best place to buy ampicillin without a prescription buy sodium diclofenac online triamterene generic uk buy detrol tablets mexico cozaar combination i want to pay some kelnor online apo furosemida with no prescription buy lipitor astrailia sarafem from canada danazol mg buy best place to order arimidex in us best place to buy anafranil in australia buy dilantin online us no prescription to buy diarex zestril drugs online purchases cheap atarax uk xeloda roche side effects cheap erection packs 2 free delivery how long does it take for risperdal to work in children azithromycin side effects in women lisinopril 20 mg sale buy flagyl er inhaler canada where do i rythmol in usa new weight loss drug topamax original liv 52 online lisinopril hctz 20 12.5 mg tablets side effects buy plavix boots celebrex online legally flunil india sale where do i endep in australia indian pharmacy thyroxine buy bactrim astrailia buy amaryl hong kong cheap brand name adalat cordarone without purchase eldepryl in usa over the counter diclofenac potassium minoxidil 10mg tablets tofranil max dose trihexyphenidyl hydrochloride where to get minocin pct almetec tablets buy clomiphene tablets fertility seasonique tablets from buy blopress no prescription canada chloroquine uk next day delivery finasteride 5 mg brr best price for lioresal what are the side effects of long term use of coumadin where can i get baridium from percocet canada sale thyroxin no rx cheap generic viagra in canada calan discount code how to buy ashwagandha elocom online pay paypal luvox medication side effects why no generic for premarin innopran xl drug in canada pharmacy levitra plus bonus pills generic dostinex 0.5 mg cheap canadian cialis no prescription where to buy wigraine online canada abilify with wellbutrin reviews how to order etabus rocaltrol shopping viagra soft cheap australia pharmacy aciclovir pharmacy order brafix uk online accutane treatment for acne doxazosin for purchase without a prescription buy alli cheap online generico do amoxil bd 400 acheter pas cher prednisone comprar lotrel en argentina cost of avapro 150 mg max daily dose viagra bactrim dose for mrsa skin infection cialis jelly sublingual dosage effexxor no script fast diltiazem delivery order l thyroxine from usa without prescription canadian drug company propranolol caprysin mg tablet uk version of venlor cefadroxil drug class purchase reglan pills 5 mg abilify bipolar artane tablets 150 mg safe cipralex no prescription mircette online pay paypal acticin without a prescription from canada aripiprazole abilify dosage prednisone prices usa is generic moduretic effective side effects of crestor 10 mg purchase depakote lowest price buy salvent online overnight delivery can you buy voveran over the counter atrovent nasal spray side effects prednisolone in india buy atomoxetin online india where can i get toprol xl from buy otomax in ireland accuran with no rx hoodia billig kaufen doxycycline barato best place to buy klipal codeine metronidazol buy india generic microzide canada buy florinef 20 buy allegra with drugs fexofenadine ordering zyvox canada glucophage free shipping best pills get high colchicine over counter uk buy revia fast shipping what drug category is amoxycillin what symptoms does lexapro treat overseas pharmacy no prescription himcolin can you get lynoral buy tadapox online in usa pharmacy has best price ephedraxin where to buy vagifem online uk suppliers of pilex in us what does cytotec look like buy retino a cream 0,05 online no prescription canada back pain medication voltaren levitra plus capsules overseas pharmacy no prescription tofranil levitra shopping purchase generic lamisil prilosec on line in the uk buy kamagra soft online pharmacy order norvasc online i pill atomoxetin website where could i buy synthroid without prescription clavamox online from usa fake viagra side effects voveran ordering online pharmacy femara canada online no prescription pantoprazole dose dramamine maximum dosage brand amoxil uk next day delivery brand name v gel online buy toprol xl online canada metocarbamol no prescription voltaren 50 mg tabletten cleocin online phone in order for ceftin para que se usa el medicamento bactroban tegretol retard maximum dosage flonase coupons cabgolin for sale uk best online pharmacy generic cabaser lopressor online orders how to buy v gel in canada can i buy oracea in canada buy cheap hydrochlorothiazide using pay pal flunil from mexico hytrin 5 mg 30 tablet indian accutane online where is benadryl sold ibuprofen 400mg boots mometasona buy mexico buy brafix usa maxalt prescription canada albuterol proventil ventolin side effects long time side effects wigraine roaccutan with prescription will levothroid cause weight loss chloramphenicol salep cipro xr 1000 mg 3 comprimidos zocor without a prescription buying levitra plus for dogs side effects of cymbalta 60 mg use arzomicin coupon online my movalis coupons pyridium without rx i want to pay some caffeine ergotamine cheapest pravachol paypal prescription allopurinol gout uric acid yasmin mg tablet zyprexa weight gain anorexia safe to buy generic protonix from usa buy cheap bentyl online prescription provera to purchase without a prescription cialis vs viagra en espanol levitra prednisone dosage for dogs allergic reaction amlodipin uk brand name carafate price at walmart does accutane work for everyone endep from china mail order generic aripiprazola quickest bupropion prescription drugs prescription drug zyloprim risperdal over the counter drugs luvox shoppers drug mart viagra super active in croatia buy singulair online from australia famciclovir tablets online clonidine for men in usa buy canada no prescription for viagra plus what drug category is medazole best generic premarin review cialis sublingual cheap mexico pharmacy long time side effects ortho tri cyclen fluss 40 birth control online us manforce viagra xenical canada cost amlodipine besylate tabs 5 mg non prescription diovan pharmacy how to buy zantac clomifene online canadian ceftin tablets for sale what are the side effects of metoclopramide fine brevetto viagra where to buy levothyroxine online in uk generic novo digoxin express canada brand cialis online pay paypal where to buy fluoxetine online mexico zestril without prescrip calcium carbonate tablets sale lexapro 10mg comprar bactrim ds alternative medicine femara buy canada use amaryl coupon online ordering proventil best site to buy acivir pills pravachol 40 mg tab diovan sales 2008 billion safe depakine chrono no prescription genuine medrol best price do i need a prescription for prednisone buy ranitidine online no prescription us where do i bactroban in usa seroflo direct pharmacy where to buy serophene drugs online generic uk paypal atrovent eldepryl no prescription compare prices overseas pharmacy no prescription wellbutrin sr what kind of medicine is mobic tylenol and motrin for babies where is ambrose alli university located kytril discontinued lipothin 20 mg what is chloramphenicol eye drops used to treat estrace best price buying gyne lotrimin in manchester 5 mg cialis order online where are the parietal cells in the stomach strattera prescription program motilium free shipping drugs similar to metformin lexapro brand order phenamax overnight pharmacy 365 pills online pharmacy proventil online from uk cheap lexapro pills singulair no prescription overnight delivery indian lotensin metformin pills sweat meclizine side effects blood pressure what is cyklokapron made of viagra in uae price can i get bystolic over the counter celebrex nz cost costco pharmacy amoxicilina price zyban over the counter uk asacol hd maximum dosage buy grifulvin v in india online buy viagra super active 5 pharmacy buy drugs acticin cheap diclofenac sale uk aricept side effects weight gain lipitor discount ecard pfizer buy accuran online from india safe place order triamterene raloxifeno shopping colchicine 5mg tablets efek samping obat lipitor 20 mg buy amoxycillin xr without prescription viagra coupons rebates albenza tablets uk non generic aceon online compazine canadian online overnight pharmacy zoloft discounts coupons disulphiram online canada order carvedilolo without rx lopid usa no prescription caprysin india viamedic amaryl women buy prevacid phone orders adalat usage buy neurontin online india no prescription buy cheap cealis using pay pal prograf global sales curacne fast mexico dutas paypal safe to buy generic colchicine from uk is generic alti doxycycline effective buy torsemide 20 cardura birth control online us propecia asia how long does depakote take to work for migraines buy protonix xr without prescription what is asacol ec 400 mg used for why has keflex been discontinued generic disulfiramo no prescription nimotop for sale usa prednisolone no prescription overnight delivery purchase cardizem on line in mexico how to buy viagra super active top 10 pharmaceutical companies india nitrofurantoin tablets 50mg side effects buy aygestin online no prescription us canadian benzac tablet buy vasotec patch aetna mail order medications buy grifulvin v online no prescription united states buy indocin pills in the india azithromycin india ban comprar stromectol original en madrid legal to buy lasix otomax buy online mexico atacand online pharmacy uk no rx benemid online boots chemist pharmacy viagra order rogaine 2 online cost of isoniazid buy actos online in the united states without a prescription how to use arimidex for gyno what is famvir 250 mg used for apo naproxen alcohol buy aciphex 25 mg quetiapinum no prescription needed ordering isoptin canada cialis tabletas 5 mg how to order cleocin gel cefixime where to get pilex uk where could i buy retin a 0,05 without prescription baclofen in italia accuran from india purchase metronidazole in usa i want to buy viagra using paypal mexican pharmacy no prescription prednisone buy cordarone 200 how much metformin to get pregnant safe cardura no prescription where can i get some otomax zyrtec cheap uk pharmacy micardis woldwide shipping buy diclofenac gel 15mg online plavix generico italiano seroflo drugstore com pricing buy astelin online mexico no prescription isoptin cost in canada methotrexate roche precio argentina buy artane mg online pastillas para adelgazar disgrasil tamoxifen class action lawsuit zovirax online bestellen non prescription retino a cream 0,025 where to buy dostinex ointment naprosyn generic inderal maximum dosage where do i kelnor in india buy viagra overseas buy hydroxyzine 10mg billig bisoprololi fumaras online kaufen doxycycline hyclate 50 mg tablets coversyl side effects dry cough diovan cheap canada pharmacy generic drug ditropan xl generic cialis jelly buy canada fosamax overnight no rx is generic dilantin available in usa danazol mg tablet glucofage price india panmycin 100mg cheap what does biaxin look like minipress pills sweat bayer india annual report 2012 clorfenamina compuesta alcohol entocort enema administration renova pas cher tricor canadian pharmacy do doctors give pain meds for uti requip in the uk when to take alli diet pill buy zyban without precription side effects of taking albendazole albuterol buy no prescription buy voltaren with paypal doksazosin lek mexico no prescription flagyl er purchase propranolol use in pregnancy buy allegra using paypal ciprofloksacin cheap uk pharmacy buy olanzapine without a subscription can u buy voltaren over counter zentel us companies only canadian pharmacy venlor thyroxine binding globulin pregnancy ponstel without a perscription no prescription dostinex order amoxycillin from canada without prescription bactroban uses acne fluticanose brands india atepros dosage carafate doctors online lincocin maximum dosage serpina uk companies only buy zestril with a mastercard what happens when you increase your dose of zoloft buspar prescription medication entocort generic equivalent buy retino a cream 0,05 online no prescription uk generic oratane usa pharmacy ginette 35 online in uk propecia medication cost how to purchase isoniazid online viagra online in ireland what does atarax container store where do i retin a 0,025 in usa side effects of ciprodex cramps during ovulation on clomid express shipping grifulvin v atrovent dose ems beconase aq capsules pharmacies cod buy biaxin lasuna india where to buy liv 52 online usa buy singulair without a subscription get lotrel toronto cheap genuine disulphiram online motrin migraine reviews alti doxycycline order radiolucent stones indinavir mobic 15 mg tablet b 1 generic suhagra in usa online pharmacy uk benfotiamine clavamox to buy in the usa without a prescription cheap motrin no prescription celebrex and birth control pills erythromycin drugstore com india pharmacies online that sell suprax buy ranitidine tablets us is generic terramycin effective discount carvedilolo mg low cost valtrex buy online wellbutrin generic is plavix generic in canada discount shallaki of canada lamisil mg usa buy cheap tinidazole pills norvasc birth control online uk buy asacol 100 buy bisoprololi fumaras mg online reminyl from usa pharmacy generic rosuvastatin in usa mentax online mexico buy generic dilantin online no prescription brand viagra canada overnight delivery what does cardizem do aciclovir buy online mexico buying brand levitra celexa cost in canada selegiline uk buy generic acticin in usa valtrex max dose how to buy toprol xl in canada celadrin usa pharmacy adalat from canada without rx rogaine 2 cheap uk order nizagara without prescription discount pyridium from canada max dose bupropion xl trial erection packs 2 canada online no prescription elimite mg india levaquin shop net dapoxetine roche precio argentina janumet online in usa www.24hourcanadapharmacy canadian healthcare online pharmacy complaints genuine cialis ampicillin discount voucher free trial viagra coupons where do i estrace in india side effects from synthroid 75 mcg can you buy trial erection packs 3 ditropan mg usa price increase exelon levitra with no subscription what is a good replacement for singulair acheter baclofene sur internet se necesita receta medica para comprar viagra en mexico purchasing toprol online uk amantadine canada drug store purchase retino a cream online metoclopramide overnight pharmacy discount brand ventolin buy buy online uk cheap lamisil eye drops chloramphenicol over counter over the counter medicine that acts as rogaine 2 flucazole without a script safe to buy generic doxycycline from usa trial erection packs 1 pills online in the australia baclofen without a script where to buy aricept in canada safely purchase stromectol mg order zofran without rx cialis jelly fast usa aldactone for acne reviews best place to order abilify in us buy lanoxin online with mastercard purchase fasigyne on line in australia nizoral 100 cena oracea buy no prescription herbal viagra suppliers albendazole order where to buy zitromax online india generic cefixime india what is reglan used for in cats tofranil australia pharmacy buy actos with no rx generic synthroid paypal buy premarin online with no prescription common side effects of nexium 40 mg buy tamoxifen online safely we need to talk about kevin imdb zofran mg order hydrochlorothiazide thailand seroquel dosage for anxiety cost of mail renagel side effects of naproxen in children femara spain estrace pills and pregnancy side effects of oral medication for ringworm didronel prices cvs lopressor iv push administration generic evista available periactin online pharmacy shipped to canada cheap generic cialis india sildenafil citrate without a prescription my didronel coupons order retino a cream 0 025 comprar uroxatral original safe to buy generic clonidine from canada zoloft shortage 2012 propecia 1 mg 5 mg is voveran sr a prescription drug list of tesco stores selling permethrinum advair diskus over the counter 50mcg buy diamox no prescription safe esperal no prescription rythmol sr without a prescription from australia anxiety medication over the counter ireland can you overdose on robaxin bactrim no prescription online cheap buy genuine lamisil uk purchase retino a cream in mexico aristocort order depakine chrono birth control online australia is pristiq better than celexa caffeine ergotamine over the counter zoloft generic cost walmart ginseng birth control online canada buy januvia mg bupron sr generic canada long term after effects of accutane avapro to buy order olanzapine online no prescription with a amex pharmacies buy allegra cheap buy zentel online us no prescription best price cephalexin order zantac from india without prescription cefixime on line in the uk cerro de la cruz cafayate allegra to buy buy retin a no prescription where to buy dapoxetine forum keftab non perscription countries singulair buy online uk i pill lexapro website order rogaine 5 online no prescription with a echeck is movalis available on line in canada chlamydia order drugs buy amlodipinbesilat mg zebeta from uk daily adalat mirpur fluconazol buy online us zyloprim discounts codes bupropion venlafaxine combination what is paxil for depression buy dostinex mg online levitra bayer 10 mg preis naprosyn women buy lanoxin nombre generico shuddha guggulu canada companies only lanoxin without a prescription from australia gipec aqp org buy viagra cialis levitra how to buy accutane no prescription levaquin online mexico how to use nizoral shampoo for tinea versicolor diclofenac maximum dosage is mail order gabapentine safe over the counter drugs similar to nitroglycerin what if i missed a dose of lamictal flagyl tablets geriforte prescription coupon tizanidinum without rx cytotec misoprostol precio en argentina mambo 36 20 reviews tadalafil tablets mg purchase chloromycetin in usa flucazole lowest price vagifem online india can you order amaryl my inderal coupons quanto costa decadron 0 5 buy relafen paypal celexa 20 mg to 30 mg buy floxin lowest price canada and antara indocin dosage for migraine price increase diclofenac can proscar cause weight gain femara medication breast cancer starlix missed dose ondansetrona delivery london order prinivil online without rx no script leukeran mg effects of taking flagyl and drinking alcohol mexico buy reglan online buy fluoxetine fast shipping pill rx health order otomax products tegretol schedule drug danazol fast usa canada lisinopril tablets online cardizem generic nolva pct after anavar buy extendaquin online from uk is generic viagra available birth control pills lanoxin generic singulair prices buy phenergan pills in the mexico vermox dosage uk pharmacies online that sell almetec buy ophthacare 10 buy nexium with no script buy acivir pills online no prescription usa what are the most common side effects of depo provera cheapest estrofem tablets uk avalide delivery london flonase online forum membership needed click here rythmol sr prices cvs my canadian blog confidex can u buy viagra boots viagra professional for discount para que se usa el nolvadex eurax supplier in uk where to buy feldene with amex purchase tetracycline pills how much is cholestoplex tablets costo del medicamento micardis brahmi now co uk deltasone price diprosone noprescrition needed canada online pharmacy asacol medication on line what drug category is riperdal acheter une recharge mobicarte baclofen 10 mg effects buy online predalone generic canadian glucotrol xl drugs prescription buy micronase online from australia what is doxi 1 used for the sims 3 custom content cheapest toprol xl in the uk entocort for sale philippines ordering vardenafilum research grade wellbutrin medazole no prescription overnight delivery inderal price walmart mexican pharmacy no prescription ciprofloksacin ordering amaryl india generic ciprofloxacin images no prescription needed for motilium compazine no prrescription can i buy diclofenac in canada best place to buy bupron in india lisinopril medicinenet zyrtec available over counter canada billig depakine chrono online kaufen is citalopram available in spain order geriforte online without rx buy trazodone mg acai max dose glucovance delivery london buy sominex pills where do i tegretol in canada lansoprazole 30 mg not working cheap genuine dapoxetine online how to buy erection packs 3 where to get desyrel no prescription sarafem sale cheap v gel mg zantac 150 mg over the counter generic for tricor medication ortho cyclen italiano cheapest flomax in the uk online pharmacies no prescription oxycodone como comprar brand viagra aciphex 20 mg tablet ec eis propranolol online legally buy valaciclovir online from canada minocycline generic pyridium mail order celebrex discount card pfizer mentat buy online mexico india pharmacies online that sell diovan purchasing propecia brand norvasc for sale order neurontin online uk viagra sample pack actos side effects long term use cheapest cleocin gel artane online pharmacy uk buy nitroglycerin online overnight delivery what is levitra professional for proscar prices at costco generic medicine for avodart top 10 online tamoxifen sites flucazole reviews get nordette las vegas prometrium cost cheap suhagra 40 mg lopressor medication side effects discount cozaar himalaya liv 52 for dogs can i buy erexin v in canada nexium india no prescription generic uk paypal viagra plus what drug category is innopran xl early signs pregnancy clomid tadapox buy online canada buy vagifem without prescription menosan sale forum prescription online generic allegra sildenafil online pharmacy methotrexate pregnancy risk astelin pill shortage best generic uroxatral sites pamelor coupons generic cialis tadalafil 20 mg how to buy anastrozolo in canada xenical without prescription pills buy oestrogel mg buy viagra sublingual online no prescription canada quinine sulphate dose how much does a medrol pack cost sale serevent order generic norvasc discount fincar of canada order biaxin on line india how many mg of voltaren to take can you buy alli over the counter diet pills cialis professional discontinued levitra preis 10 mg can you buy penegra thyroxin birth control online mexico cardizem low dose birth control duetact drug schedule tinidazole paypal nimotop on line no script synthroid levothyroxine sodium tablets best price isoptin buy ponstel xr without prescription clomifene usa sale what is lexapro used for and side effects novo digoxin canada low dose naltrexone buy can you still get phenergan safe to buy generic dapoxetine from canada florinef mg india what is isoniazid preventive therapy requip without a prescription colchicina uk next day delivery online no prescription uk for female cialis female viagra for sale in uk what is bupropionum order duphalac without rx levothroid pills buy online doxycycline 50 mg side effects original tetracycline online cymbalta from uk imuran ordering online pharmacy discount januvia where to buy dostinex with visa lipitor cheapest rate order erythromycin uk pharmacy nolvadex for gyno treatment aciphex generic wikipedia drugs lariam to buy in england better than yagara delivery buy aciphex presciption diovan company purchase azurette on line in mexico ivenox fast canada lasix drug interaction types of viagra pills for men flunil from canada without rx buy alavert online overnight delivery is generic actos effective female viagra over the counter usa generic from haridra viagra side effects interactions mestinon tablets 40mg aciphex online in usa common side effects of luvox cr what is the generic drug for depakote buy online kamagra generic roxithromycin doctors online what does diflucan kill duetact shop net how to get geriforte in australia generic pills for differin canada acivir pills tablets online aviane 28 on line in the india what is allegra d good for top 10 online diovan sites can we trust vistaril online robaxin overdose amount order rumalaya gel medication by mail secure tabs online viagra 100mg pyridium ordering no prescription zertalin over the counter uk u.s.a generic viagras acai berry coupon code confido without a prescription from australia buying chloromycetin amitriptyline dosage for sleep aid promethazine over the counter canada cyotec online pharmacy clozaril online without prescription india pharmacies online that sell cialis super active nexium 40mg pret aricept 23 reviews dipyridamole over counter order glucophage no rx canadian pharmacy zitromax cheap australia pharmacy how much does strattera cost in australia research grade depakine chrono trandate from usa pharmacy buy motilium in india online flovent side effects rhinocort aqua nasal spray pregnancy avandamet uk brand name hydromorphone dosage forms cheap pills generic proscar 5mg buy levitra professional online india no prescription buy ceftin online amazon shop order online buy suprax buy lotensin tablets canada order amoxicilina without prescription arimidex sublingual dosage trim active plus slimming pills reviews torsemide fast mexico get lotensin toronto maxalt where to purchase roaccutane lowest price online celebrex from canada without rx viagra generic 2010 how much does zyprexa zydis cost lithium australia companies only cheapest drug erythromycin generic zithromax india buy yasmin tablets canada buy wellbutrin sr online without a prescription viagra professional pills antabuse discount medications do i need a prescription for yasmin purchase propranolol pills cipla pharma company what is sensoril ashwagandha extract comprar movalis original en madrid clonidine uk sale duetact uk online purchase abilify 3mg online sinemet generic cheap costs why is there a shortage of bactrim liquid reglan review buy coumadin no prescription cheap genuine requip online can you get high off luvox cr can you buy serevent over the counter in germany zetia canada no prescription dipyridamole pills procardia order canada buy januvia with paypal sale atrovent generic lozol buy canada accutane prescription information purchase indinavir cheap comprar zertalin original fucidin cream uses nose buy yagara online from usa
الرئيسية | قضايا ساخنة | العربية في قفص الاتهام | هل جنى سيبويه الفارسي على اللغة العربية؟ مهندس لبناني من خارج الحزب اللغوي يرمي حجراً في مياه النحو العربي الساكنة - رشيد الخيُّون

صفحة شبكة صوت العربية في فيسبوكtwitterقناة شبكة صوت العربية في يوتيوبشبكة صوت العربية في موقع فليكر

هل جنى سيبويه الفارسي على اللغة العربية؟ مهندس لبناني من خارج الحزب اللغوي يرمي حجراً في مياه النحو العربي الساكنة - رشيد الخيُّون طباعة إرسال إلى صديق
تقييم المستخدمين: / 3
الكاتب صوت العربية   
الثلاثاء, 16 سبتمبر 2008 19:21


سنوات وأهالي منطقتنا الريفية يلبون فريضة الصلاة على صوت مؤذن المسجد، غير المختص، وهو يلحن في الشهادة الثانية، فيقول: «أشهد أن محمدٌ رسول الله»، ولم يلتفت إلى لحن المؤذن غير مدرس اللغة العربية الجديد الأديب سالم الدباغ، المعروف بين الوسط الثقافي العراقي، وكان منفياً سياسياً وسط الأهوار، شاهدناه، نحن طلبته، يسرع الخطوات صوب المسجد، ليعلم المؤذن درساً في أن وأخواتها، فقيل له: لا يوجد مؤذن متفرغ بالمنطقة فاستعان الأهالي بمزيد النَدَّاف. عاد الدباغ إلى المدرسة وهي دار سكنه وعمله، على أمل أن المؤذن سمع احتجاجه. والعبرة من هذه الحادثة أن الناس ظلوا يسمعون معنى الأذان لا شكله، فيتوجهون إلى الصلاة من دون أن يعنوا بالمنصوب والمرفوع من كلماته، وببساطة كانوا مؤتلفين مع مؤذنهم النَدَّاف، أما مدرس اللغة العربية المتمرس فوصل لسمعه الشكل قبل المعنى، ليجد في رفع اسم (أن) جناية تعطل الأذان والصلاة. نجد دلالة هذه الحادثة جلية في كتاب «جناية سيبويه .. الرفض التام لما في النحو من أوهام» (دار رياض الريس للكتب والنشر) لزكريا أوزون، وهو المهندس لا اللغوي، داعياً إلى حيوية النحو العربي ونبذ تعقيداته غير المبررة. فاللغة العربية ترد على لسان الناطقين بها، بمختلف اللهجات العراقية، السورية، المغربية أو المصرية وغيرها، لا تعنيهم أُصول النحو العربي بشيء، ولو حصل أن التزموا نطق الكلام بها لكانوا محط سخرية وتندر بعضهم البعض.

يعزو أوزون تراجع اللغة العربية، أمام اللغات الأكثر حيوية في العالم، إلى تعقيد ولا منطقية قواعدها، ويسند مشكلات النحو العربي كافة إلى سيبويه الفارسي، الذي تتلمذ على يد اللغوي العربي الخليل بن أحمد الفراهيدي، على حد عبارته أن الذنب ليس ذنب سيبويه في ما وضع من أُصول وقواعد اعتمد فيها على حركة أواخر الكلمات دليلاً، جمعت في كتاب عرف بكتاب سيبويه، ذلك لحاجة أبناء قومه من الفرس وسواهم، وإنما الذنب يتحمله مَنْ جعل هذه القواعد نهجاً في تقويم اللسان العربي. والحقيقة التي يضعها أمامنا مؤرخو النحو العربي أن سيبويه لم يكن مخترعاً لتلك الأُصول، وإنما أخذها من أساتذته العرب، وأخذها هؤلاء من أفواه أهل البادية. ومن المرجح أنه كان واحداً من جماعة ساهمت في تأليف كتاب النحو، الذي عرف باسمه، قال أبو فرج النديم في «الفهرست»: «قرأت بخط أبي العباس ثعلب، اجتمع على صنعة كتاب سيبويه اثنان وأربعون إنساناً منهم سيبويه».
يذكر باحث الاجتماع العراقي علي الوردي، وهو أحد الثائرين على أُصول النحو العربي وصاحب معارك حامية الوطيس مع اللغويين والمصححين اللغويين، روايات تأسيس علم النحو العربي وتعقيداته بعيداً عن سيبويه، نوجزها بالآتي: إن الخليفة عمر بن الخطاب رضي الله عنه سمع لحناً في ترتيل القرآن الكريم يؤدي إلى الكفر، فأمر أبا الأسود الدؤلي بوضع قواعد النحو. وفي رواية أن الإمام علي بن أبي طالب رضي الله عنه سمع كثرة اللحن فأمر أبا الأسود بوضع قواعد النحو، بعد أن علمه إياها، وقيل كانت بداية النحو: أن طلب أمير البصرة زياد ابن أبيه من أبي الأسود وضع قواعد تقوّم لفظ أولاده، وقيل أن أبا الأسود اهتدى لقواعد النحو بعد أن سمع كثرة لحن الموالي (المسلمين من غير العرب)، أو بعد انزعاجه من لحن ابنته.
تؤكد الروايات المذكورة، والتي تحققنا منها في كتب «طبقات النحويين» للزبيدي، و«المنتظم» لابن الجوزي، و«المحكم في نقط المصاحف» للداني، دور أبي الأسود (ت69هـ) في وضع النحو العربي قبل زمن سيبويه (179هـ أو نحو ذلك) بحوالي قرن من الزمن. وبالتأكيد أن ما وضعه الدؤلي أو معاصروه من قواعد في النحو لا تصل إلى تعقيدات ومبهمات عصر سيبويه، إلا أن القلق لم يساور سيبويه فحسب وإنما ساور أستاذه الفراهيدي فاستنبط «من علل النحو ما لم يستنبطه أحد»، وان سيبويه صنف كتابه من علم الفراهيدي، واثنى على ذلك اللغوي يونس بن حبيب(طبقات النحويين). وأرى شهرة سيبويه في النحو ونسبته له مثل شهرة قيس بن الملوح وآل عذرة بالغزل وأبي نواس باللهو والمجون.
إن الدعوة إلى تيسير النحو العربي، والتي يدعو إليها صاحب كتاب «جناية سيبويه» ليست جديدة، ولعل أقدمها دعوة ابن مضاء القرطبي (القرن السادس الهجري) في كتابه «الرد على النحاة»، وهو لم يأت في مراجع ومصادر زكريا أوزون. أما في العصر الحاضر فظهر العديد من الداعين إلى تيسير النحو، واتهموا جميعاً بالقصور في هذا العلم، فالقارئ العربي، على حد رأي أوزون، ينظر إلى اللفظ قبل المعنى، فتذهب جزالة المعاني في أخطاء شكلها أي حركات إعرابها ورسمها. من هؤلاء كان إبراهيم مصطفى في كتابه «إحياء النحو»، وأمين الخولي وعبد الستار الجواري، وكما أسلفنا علي الوردي، الذي اضطر أن ينشر مقالات ضد متهميه في تشويه اللغة العربية وقصوره في الإعراب، وبالتالي الطعن في براعته العلمية، وتواطئه مع الغرب وغيرها من التهم. ومما كتبه أحد المتعصبين للنحو العربي باعتباره سمة من سمات الوحدة العربية، وركناً من أركان القومية العربية: «هذه اللغة هي العالم الأمثل بالنسبة لنا نحن العرب.. إذ أن لها أثراً عظيماً في تكوين وصياغة نفسياتنا.. فإن الذين يحاربون لغتنا بسوء إنما يضمرون لنا الأسوأ.. فهم يريدون تبسيط اللغة العربية، ويريدون حذف الكثير منها، ألم يعلم أي من هؤلاء أن لغتنا مقدسة كالصلوات الخمس، فهل يستطيع إنسان أن يترك واحدة منها للسهولة، أو البساطة» (عن الوردي، من بعد الثمانين). لكن ألم يسأل كاتب هذه السطور نفسه في جدوى قواعد وأُصول لا يفقهها العربي؟ وكأن التعقيد النحوي غاية لمن يحرص على التفرد، فلو أصبح في متناول كل ناطق بالعربية لغابت طبقة عرفت قديماً بطبقة اللغويين أو النحويين، وأفلس المعتاشون على تصيد أخطاء الصرف والإعراب.
ومثلما جوبه علي الوردي بالمثالب جوبه الباحث هادي العلوي إثر دعوته وممارسته في الكتابة بأسلوب اليسر النحوي، رأياً منه أن صعوبة النحو تمنع سيولة الأفكار والتعبير عنها، لذا اضطر محررو الدوريات التي استكتبته، أن يعلنوا البراءة من أسلوبه خشية من مثلب القصور في النحو العربي، فهمشت مجلة «مواقف» (العدد 63) مقالته بالآتي: «للأستاذ هادي العلوي وجهة نظر في النحو والصرف والإعراب، وتبعاً لذلك في تهجئة الكلمات وكتابتها، واحتراماً لوجهة نظره هذه، دون أن يعني ذلك تبنياً بالضرورة نحرص على نشر كتاباته بنصها دون تعديل إعرابي، ونرجو قراءنا أن يروا في ما يبدو ظاهرياً أنه خلل إعرابي، على أنه ليس خطأً، وإنما تطبيق عملي لوجهة النظر هذه».
وسيبويه، الذي يحمله زكريا أوزون وزر تعقيد بل تبليد النحو العربي، هو مولى فارسي لبني الحارث، وشاع عن معنى اسمه «رائحة التفاح»، لكن الصحيح (سي بويه) تعني «ثلاثون رائحة»، فهو ذو الثلاثين رائحة، وربما أتت كناية عن جمال مُحيّاه. أشاد المبرد في كتاب سيبويه بالقول: «إذا أراد إنسان أن يُقرأ عليه كتاب سيبويه يقول له: هل ركبت البحر، تعظيماً له واستصعاباً لما فيه»، وقال المازني: «مَنْ أراد أن يعمل كتاباً كبيراً في النحو بعد كتاب سيبويه فليستح» (الفهرست). والكتاب الذي أشاد فيه أساطين العربية واعتبره زكريا أوزون جناية ليس خاصاً بالأعاجم، وإنما تعقيده حال تعقيد علوم الكلام والفلسفة والفقه وغيرها من العلوم الدقيقة، تمحور حولها أساتذة وطلاب، يجدون في تبسيطها ضياعاً لخصوصيتها وبالتالي لسطوتهم وتفردهم، فكان همهم التعالي عن العامة بالعلم الخاص، غير أنها ملأت في وقتها فراغاً، وشغلت أُناساً.
الكتاب بفصوله السبعة: زبدة الكتاب، الكلمات والجمل، الاسم، الأدوات، إعراب الجمل، شواهد وتخريجات نحوية، بين الماضي والحاضر، كان نقداً لا يخلو من السخرية فما ذهب إليه النحاة واللغويين من تعقيد غير معقول. لقد اعتمدوا حركات أواخر الكلمات في خلقهم لهذا العلم، فانشقوا حوله إلى بصريين وكوفيين، يتبع كل منهم الحالة الفكرية السائدة بمصره، فكان البصريون أقرب إلى التفكير العقلي حيث الفكر المعتزلي، بينما تأثر الكوفيون بالنصوص.
دعا مؤلف الكتاب إلى التناسب بين الدلالات والمدلولات في النحو، مثلما ورد تحت عنوان المعارف والنكرات، والجامد والمشتق، فحسب رأيه أن هذا التصنيف «لا يضيف إلا التعقيد والإغراب لقواعد لغتنا، فلا يوجد اسم مشتق، والأسماء هي الأسماء بجميع أنواعها» (ص62)، ونجده يسأل: هل الحنان اسم جامد، وهو العاطفة المتحركة؟ ودعا إلى إلغاء ما عرف بالمصروف والممنوع من الصرف، فهو لا يجد فرقاً بين أن نقول: دعد أو دعداً، هند.. أو هنداً إلخ. ونراه يستغرب تسمية أن وعن ولكن وغيرها من الكلمات بالحروف، مع أنها تتألف من عدة حروف، وكيف تسمى الجملة اسمية من دون التمييز بين ثباتها أو تغيرها، فما الفرق بين الجملتين الآتيتين: «الطفل سعيد»، و «الأرض كروية»، أين تأثير الزمن فيهما، مع أن الجملة الاسمية هي الجملة التي تشير إلى الثبات، وهنا يطالب بإعادة النظر في مفهوم هذه الجملة، من دون أن يأتي بمقترح.
نوافق أوزون على عدم منطقية مسائل عديدة في النحو العربي، إن نظرنا إليها من باب المعنى لا التكوين اللغوي، وصياغة القانون والقياس، منها هل يصح نسبة فعل لفاعل لم يفعله، مثل الغرق والموت وكل ما يفعله القدر في الإنسان، مع أن عبارة «مات حتف أنفه» تفيد مقصداً إعرابياً آخر!، فكأنها تقول: كيف يكون الميت فاعلاً لموته؟ أو الغريق فاعلاً لغرقه؟ وهلم جرا. كذلك الحال، حسب ما ذهب إليه أوزون، في نيابة الفاعل، نحو كُتب الدرسُ، فكيف يحل المفعول به نائباً للفاعل ويأخذ حركة إعرابه بدلالة الفعل المبني للمجهول! وما يلتفت له مؤلف الكتاب القول بالزوائد والمحذوفات، مثل إذا ما، فالنحو وضع قانوناً ملخصه: «ألا أدلك على شيء فيه فائدة: (ما) بعد إذا زائدة»، وهنا يحاول المؤلف إحراج القائمين على النحو العربي عند إعراب الآية «ولا يأب الشهداء إذا ما دعوا»، فيقول لهم: «حاشا لله أن يكون في كلامه زيادة أو حشو فهو الحق وكلماته الحق» (ص23).
ومن جملة ما جعله أوزون نقصاً أو تعقيداً في النحو العربي ما ذهب إليه اللغويون في القول بالمبتدأ الثاني، مع عدم الابتداء فيه، والأخبار المحذوفة المتعلقة بالجار والمجرور، على شاكلة: الطفل في المنزل، فالخبر محذوف تقديره كائن، وما يتعلق بالأفعال الناقصة، فما الفرق بين نام زيد وأمسى زيد، ولماذا يصبح الفعل نام فعلاً تاماً بينما يصبح الفعل أمسى فعلاً ناقصاً؟ وكيف تكون كلمة خلا حرفاً وأداة جر، وفعلاً ماضياً في آن واحد؟
عموماً يأتي كتاب المهندس زكريا أوزون دعوة ملحة من خارج الحزب اللغوي أو الأصولية اللغوية التي تحرص على حماية مملكتها من رياح التغيير، إلى تبسيط النحو، بما يتناسب مع روح العصر ومدارك المعاصرين وتوسع العلوم وسرعة التعلم، مع أن لكل لغة أُصولها وجمالها في التقيد بحدود المعقول والمفهوم منها، وأراه قافزاً على العصور في رده على سؤال، وضعه في الفصل الأول من الكتاب من بين تسعة أسئلة، وهو: هل مفردات أجدادنا العرب القدامى كافية؟ وهل استطاع نتاجهم الأدبي ـ الشعر والنثر ـ أن يعطي صوراً في الوصف تفوق صور اليوم، وهل يمكن لتلك المفردات أن تستوعب جميع المسميات في أيامنا المعاصرة؟ فبطبيعة الحال لا أحد يدعي هذا الكمال في التراث الأدبي وأي تراث، فكل فن أدبي يعبر عن عصره وبأدواته، لكنه لا يفقد الجمالية في العصور التالية، ولا يفقد ذووه العبقرية، ومع ذلك ليس لنا محاكاة معلقة امرئ القيس، بقصائد بدر شاكر السياب وصلاح عبد الصبور، والبيت الذي لم يعجب مؤلف الكتاب «مكر مفر مقبل مدبر معاً/ كجلمود صخر حطه السيل من عل» جماله في مخالفته للواقع، وليس بالضرورة أن يجعل الشاعر الفرس وجلمود الصخر شبه الغراب بالغراب.
كتاب «جناية سيبويه» الذي استغرق (173) صفحة من الحجم الصغير كان بمثابة حجرة في بحيرة النحو العربي الساكنة، كشف عن تعقيدات لا مبرر لها وأوهام من المحذوفات والثواني والنواقص وأشباه الحروف، لكني أجدها مبالغة أن يذهب مؤلفه إلى جعل تعقيد النحو العربي سبباً من سببين رئيسين في عدم انتشار اللغة العربية عالميا.، والسؤال هل انتشرت الانجليزية لسهولة قواعدها، وفيها ما فيها من تعقيد أزمنة الأفعال، والتباين بين المحكي والمكتوب من حروفها؟ وهل حجب تعقيد قواعد اللغة البلغارية، على سبيل المثال، انتشارها، وأن سهولة قواعد الفرنسية ساعدتها على الانتشار؟ وكيف انتشرت العربية أوان الفتوحات الإسلامية، حتى أصبحت لغة امبراطورية لوسعها شاع عن هارون الرشيد أنه قال للسحابة: أينما تمطرين يأتيني خراجك. فبسط اللغات وانتشارها له علاقة بالتفوق العلمي والمدني والاقتصادي والهيمنة السياسية الحضارية لا بالنحو وقواعد اللغة.
* الكتاب: جناية سيبويه
* المؤلف: زكريا أوزون
* الناشر: رياض الريس للكتب والنشر 2002
جريدة الشرق الأوسط : الأربعاء 06 ربيـع الأول 1424 هـ 7 مايو 2003 العدد 8926

Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack