can you buy atrovent online pyridium dose mg propecia online us pharmacy buy fincar online uk lexapro schedule ii drug prescriptions canada cheaper pharmacy technician online college courses aldactone pas cher what is allegra d 24 hour used for flovent for cats asthma sertralina para que serve esse remedio existe viagra generico mexico advair diskus tablets online is nizagara the same as viagra ceftin dose for lyme disease can you legally buy prescription drugs from canada metformin hydrochloride tablets ip 500 mg side effects dosage of strattera by weight ditropan drug class buy propecia online from australia celebrex online overnight shipping zoloft 2 weeks now buy bupron sr 80 mg online ordering skelaxin northern gulf of mexico alliance safe cialis no prescription plavix sales in canada ortho tri cyclen generic brands frequency of albuterol nebulizer treatments diarex limited india tramadol side effects in cats cialis tadalafil comprare flovent dosage for dogs buy cialis jelly pills online does taking paxil cause weight gain cialis commercial song basement adalat xl 30 mg generic where can i buy biaxin online without a prescription cialis sale canada acheter nizoral en ligne purchase forzest uroxatral drug classification can you get high from ranitidine viagra levitra dose comparison imitrex nasal spray carbozyne buy canada how to order phenamax online sarafem 10 mg for pms original propranolol online where can i get some lotrisone levothyroxine vs synthroid side effects zetia generic date cheapest phexin blopress generic 2013 drugs information on fluoxetine medication how to import vytorin difference between propecia 1mg or 5 mg lamotrigine paypal overnight shipping how to purchase lisinopril online spc meloxicam injection fosamax plus d coupons buy sinequan quick lawsuit against trazodone is generic levitra super active available in usa buspar online mexico can i buy ventolin over the counter in ireland generic moduretic us periactin drug facts lowest olanzapine dose advair diskus online in uk xenical shipping overseas purchase generic amaryl colchicine without prescriptions cheapest lotrisone prices online save best generic evista review lisinopril prices usa genuine didronel best price kytril 40 mg vidal glucophage lowest price efectos secundarios dostinex 0.5 mg worldwide pharmacy lisinopril cialis jelly fda approved to buy without prescription do you need rx vytorin buy inderal online in usa valtrex tablets 500mg price acheter furosemide en ligne non prescription acyclovir for sale buy allegra lowest price where to buy periactin online uk overseas pharmacy no prescription kamagra oral jelly buy ventolin without subscription where to find lithium orotate myambutol dose what is carafate drug class legal buy elavil online canada buy cardura line what types of ortho tri-cyclen are there how to purchase prilosec online erectile dysfunction medication online purchasing maxalt online uk safe buy cytoxan online buy liv from mexico online where to buy hytrin ointment meclizine 100 mg xalatan dosage instructions vpxl order in the us buy atorlip-5 online cheap flagyl pills cats arthritis knee surgery brand revia for sale pharmacies canada vpxl perscription how to take tegretol viagra medicine name side effects clomid purchase diflucan uk nexium over counter prescription buy voveran sr in india online lasix on line no script zovirax dosage too high buy abilify 5mg canada pharmacy where to buy lariam ointment amoxil discount code buy decadron discount generic lipothin buy canada discount amaryl of canada ciprofloxacin side effects elderly order nj rx pads torsemide overnight shipping cheap actoplus met cost canadian craigslist leeds england florida allopurinol buy procardia visa viagra originale costo actos uk buy without a transcript buy allegra lortab vs vicodin es cleocin online forum buy ampicillin online from uk keppra dose range tinidazole usa sale generic name for cialis super active crestor tablets 20mg canada drug pharmacy free shipping lamictal price walgreens kamagra oral jelly medication where to buy bentyl dose range legitimate canadian pharmicies actonel tablets for sale side effects of blopress purchase clonidine 0.3 mg crestor drug in uk pharmacy buy viagra plus online at canada pharmacy taking propranolol for migraines flagyl er tablets for sale buy acticin overseas order sumycin pill brand cialis delivered to your home free cialis without prescription costco opening times aberdeen dulcolax online order half price pletal pharmacies prescription buy cheap arimidex topamax pharmacy mail order levitra brand for sale cheapest suprax to buy azithromycin dosage for adults sinusitis bupropion hcl sr coupons confido tablets online india generic name for viagra sublingual donde puedo comprar pastillas cytotec en guadalajara blopress medication buying erythromycin from canada no prescription there generic form differin what does beconase aq misa de sanacion con el padre chelo i want to pay some cleocin methylprednisolone dosage dogs does cipro decrease the effectiveness of birth control pills hydrocortisone injection tennis elbow lipitor online order best generic trazodone sites over the counter minipress generic viagra jelly buy canada where can i get ginseng tea best water pills lose weight generic name for adalat xl promethazine pills 25 mg street value what does methotrexate 2.5 mg look like betnovate n cream sale generic drug for minocycline rihanna s and m buy nizoral cream walgreens strattera cheap online atenolol dosage forms nimotop order canada tegretol purchase in canada no prescription marmot lithium sleeping bag best price cheapest place to buy keflex cialis viagra levitra sale lowest fast micronase delivery buy chloramphenicol online safely ordering lady era buy eldepryl without rx where to get isoptin pct side effects of avapro pet medications+no prescription needed zyrtec how to buy oxytrol prescription coupon fosamax plus costco ranitidine generic medication actoplus met 40mg lipitor atorvastatin calcium what does generic augmentin look like generic name for lanoxin does ranitidine affect birth control pills buy norvasc 10 mg lynoral shoppers drug mart buy voltaren online india singulair asthma medication side effects children prescription medicine for chronic diarrhea nimotop online ciprofloxacin side effects uk overnight erection packs 1 drugs online comprar avalide original en madrid quiero comprar cialis soft is it ok to mix cialis and viagra medrol dose pack and viagra rosuvastatin calcium reviews prevacid dose for children where to terramycin what is the generic drug for synthroid tinidazole tablets wiki list of tesco stores selling vasotec does viagra require a prescription online himcolin purchase zovirax mg tablet what is allicin max accutane prices in south africa colchicine overnight shipping cheap voltaren sr 75mg tablets depakote clindamycin gel why is there a shortage of voltaren cheap clomid pills acheter pas cher micardis where can i get retino-a cream 0,025 cheap ciproflaxin metformin sr tablets side effects indian risperdal order requip overnight order no prescription buy arimidex online how to purchase viagra plus online what is the best antibiotic for e coli uti can you take periactin daily is tofranil available over the counter legal to buy lotrisone what is purim for kids cialis professional canadian online buy geriforte syrup online reviews purchase micronase cheap lexapro canada avail buy sominex 100 order trial erection packs 3 online what is bactrim mg used to treat mobic 15 mg twice a day cheap pyridium united support services bedford va tretinoin 0,025 pharmacy order cytotec legal in england carafate other uses price increase cordarone generic celebrex alternatives celebrex what happens when you overdose on anti anxiety pills motilium from china street value for trazodone 100 mg medicament cialis 20mg prix canadian prescription drugs viagra olmesartan is generic entocort available in usa lotrisone australia buy bupron sr in india online is mail order clozaril safe alli pill buy buy zithromax now frumil without prescriptions buy lamisil paypal flagyl er now co uk what does the yasmin pill do safe buy allopurinol online Purchase citalopram 20mg tablets free coupon for celebrex aciphex com pdf aciphex coupon pdf tricor medicine side effects how long does it take torsemide to work baclofen wanted online review can i order benadryl no prescription in the usa overnight line paroxetine online purchase elimite order ampicillin no rx canadian pharmacy buy finast hong kong can buy cafergot online benadryl 50 mg capsules is generic effexor xr available in usa legal buy bactroban online canada coreg western australia cheap prednisolone tablets in uk bipolar medication lithium side effects top 10 online alphagan sites fast diclofenac gel deleviery pharmacy mexico strattera ginseng spa massage salem ct proscar sale uk unisom pregnancy drug class generic from fertomid pregnancy success stories using clomid cheap citalopram order lexapro online acheter livre d;or pas cher best place to buy zantac in usa adalat pharmacy online dulcolax suppositories cheap forzest roche precio argentina buy cialis jelly 50 sildenafil citrate tablets ip 100mg que es el omifin para hombres atacand online coupon code generic allopurinol zyloprim drug diovan hct medication side effects over the counter toradol buy 0.1 mg clonidine online voltaren gel online pharmacy toll can you buy zocor in ireland avapro online in usa benicar for sale online buy nexium online from mexico buy sarafem online overnight buy ditropan singapore strattera online pharmacy online no prescription cephalexin forzest ranbaxy review rosuvastatin 40 mg canadian online pharmacy for triamterene what does chloroquine low price colchicine uk worldwide pharmacy glucophage erection packs 3 purchase can you get allegra over the counter proventil tablets from buy buy minocycline pills online mexican pharmacy no prescription coumadin remeron online order order atacand plus online paxil 20 mg tablet allopurinol tablets 100 mg follistim better than clomid generic viagra overseas purple pharmacy mexico online can you only get glucotrol xl on prescription best price for real valtrex can diflucan make you gain weight craigslist used boats new york order lukol cheap can viagra maintain an erection after ejaculation generic uk paypal albenza natural medication for anxiety and stress cheap brahmi oil generic ginette-35 in usa viagra super active shortage vente de singulair au quebec metformin 500 mg price cvs overnight generic diclofenac how to get costco membership alphagan for sale buy wellbutrin sr online usa cialis difference viagra vs levitra which is better celexa side effects fatigue no prescription strattera can you buy alligator snapping turtles online sale of buspar pyridium discounted provera online ordering revia australia estrace usa generic lithium batteries review viagra and high blood pressure stroke is there a generic seroquel xr tretinoin 0,025 over the counter can i make alavert ketoconazole tablets uk can you order pills online abilify without a prescription from uk does viagra work on women too gyne-lotrimin from usa pharmacy how to get nizagara on line uses of ampicillin and cloxacillin capsules can you buy xenical over counter australia best generic triamterene sites lotrisone best price can you buy apcalis sx in ireland icd-9 code for neurontin brand levitra mg no prescription buy motilium 80 mg online cheapest place to buy tadalis sx side effects of suprax antibiotic list of tesco stores selling geriforte syrup finpecia italiano genuine tadapox best price finax roche precio argentina flagyl uk companies only side effects of proventil is there a generic for pravachol online pharmacies no rx reviews comprar revia pela internet trandate tablets for purchase ridgeland discount drugs duphalac for men sale in uk bad side effects of acai berry pills risperdal drug in canada pharmacy ranitidine order online no prescription lloyds pharmacy allergy reliever reviews periactin drug store allergies lamisil coupons 2011 dosing for jr. strength acetaminophen rapid tabs buy zenegra from india buy aspirin boots actos drugs use how to use synthroid for weight loss ordering glucophage buy estrace online from usa how old do you have to be to buy promethazine erexor side effects uk arava hostel eilat reviews diflucan boots uk how long does it take for amitriptyline to work for sleep best sites order viagra phenergan without insurance maxalt dose buy alphagan 200 cipro 1000 side effects bupropion 75mg tablet skelaxin pas cher how much does generic lipitor cost without insurance pet meds india costco pharmacy cefixime price what else is prilosec used for different types of viagra prescription diflucan side effects haridra mg buy lisinopril medication overnight delivery tadalafil 20mg prices western drug aleve my elimite coupons arjuna online forum evecare next day shipping levlen usa sale buy levothyroxine sodium uk buy topamax without prescription how long does it take for bentyl to leave your system digoxin price india actos uk boots acheter du clomid sans ordonnance united solutions technical support buy vpxl boots buy gasex perth australia average price for viagra best way to take cytotec for abortion zantac maximum dosage flonase tablets for sale zaditor to buy in england mail order amaryl online pariet ordering no prescription atorlip-20 online forum can you buy cozaar losartan potassium tretinoin 0,025 spain cheap voveran uk procardia 20mg tab price comparison viagra cialis levitra does code red 7 really work cost of valtrex vs valacyclovir indocin dosage pregnancy medicare drug coverage viagra vpxl non perscription countries coversyl arginine 10mg side effects viagra super active on line in the mexico generic prinivil switzerland nitrofurantoin no prescription reviews buy zithromax online overnight overnight hydrochlorothiazide depakote generic name buy propranolol online indian allies of the french were hong kong pharmacy online sale alli what is cardizem prescribed for how many pills does it take to cure chlamydia buy generic sumycin online buying viagra oline frome mexico ginseng indiana dnr imiquimod over the counter uk overseas pharmacy no prescription mestinon para que sirve el clorhidrato de sertralina phexin canadian pharmacy canadian pharmacy lanoxin where to get clomid for pct paroxetine online prices proscar 5mg 10 off drugstore femara for fertility dosage best drugstore foundation 2013 uk levitra samples pack brand viagra where can i buy it lisinopril canadian source get gyne-lotrimin toronto med cab olanzapine yasmin fast uk Purchase medrol 4mg dipyridamole online without prescription natural alternatives to doxycycline for acne alli medicine children glycomet discount is singulair now generic what does it mean if nitroglycerin works how to buy things on amazon with paypal retin a no prescription needed-canada valtrex for purchase avapro hct side effects canadian larazapan pharmacies amoxil online cipro on line no script average street price for xanax bars order animal antibiotics how to get armidex online cheap buy amoxil what is viramune made of betnovate cream over counter where to buy cheap generic l-tryptophan sarafem free shipping suppliers of imitrex in us can i make stromectol bupron sr tablets for sale american drug stores pharmacy sale provera positive zoloft reviews non generic buy alphagan brimonidine lloyds pharmacy online doctor reviews carbozyne from canada can buy viagra store ordering brafix famvir medicine online tinidazole lowest price best site for lipitor dapoxetine 100 can you buy bactroban over counter oxytrol canada overnight delivery where could i buy valtrex without prescription yasmin online bestellen viagra supplier in uk orlistat pills ebay fluoxetine to buy in australia suprax wanted online review zyprexa online usa no prescription rimonabant reviews 2012 where can i buy mentats in fallout 3 buy genuine lopressor uk robaxin 100mg buy order viagra online australia discount buy genuine combivent uk viagra en suisse gratuit what is nitrofurantoin mono/mac 100mg caps used for finpecia from the uk order cialis soft medication by mail buy topamax without a script canadian alliance terminals calgary ampicillin tablets buy toprol online without a prescription brand viagra without a prescription from india can you buy estrogen pills what is seroquel xr used to treat top 10 online amantadine sites fastest cleocin gel uk delivery buy indocin 40 apcalis kamagra jelly price buster methocarbamol canada no prescription purchase generic confido canadian online pharmacy for lipothin cheap living options in london is xanax better than zoloft zofran precio mexico ranitidine shop cheap genuine floxin online fincar with paypal payment carafate suspension online order finast overnight generic flonase in usa levitra super active without a script buy dostinex no prescription online cheap dostinex cod acticin 100mg cheep buy bupropion xl 150 mg claritin anti allergen comforter reviews carafate discount medications ginseng coupons zanaflex tizanidine how much is benzac tablets etodolac spain kegunaan salep elocon mometasone furoate buy lipothin perth australia cialis promise program phone number is bactrim legal in uk buy combivent mexican pharmacies kytril tablets side effects ditropan xl drug class what are the side effects of reglan in dogs is there any medication for anxiety over the counter caverta tablets for sale lortab 7.5 325 cheap no rx buy generic accutane promethazine mail order professional store guaranteed order viagra online list of top 10 pharmacy college in india adverse effects of hydrochlorothiazide esidrix order lotensin in levlen canada online no prescription liposafe pills baclofen overdose emedicine online proventil india etodolac tablets from buy uses of doxycycline medication over counter retino-a cream 0,025 medicine cardura 4 mg no rx antabuse online order lisinopril online no prescription with a mastercard where to buy v-gel azithromycin tablets 250mg alcohol ceftin with no rx antibiotics where to buy online uk differenze tra viagra cialis levitra priligy 30mg x 3 tablets sinemet no prescription canada over counter nitroglycerin ointment mirapex reviews rls risperdal prices usa best generic lithium review cheapest augmenting path algorithm i pill website glass generic lipitor salbutamol ventolin syrup dosage is valtrex available in india suprax online pharmacy uk what is bystolic 5 mg used for sialis propecia generic uk buying betnovate for dogs can you buy viagra over the counter in england into order erection packs 3 bonus viagra cefixime tablets is used for what order arimidex medication by mail top 10 online viagra sites get alli las vegas is prevacid better than zantac for babies resources for sumycin generic luvox uk paypal top pharmacy stores in india buy crestor pills in the us can you buy hyzaar online drugs order zyprexa pill clomid success stories over 40 buy ampicillin low cheap price what does aspiring actress mean buy zelnorm tegaserod streama filmer online gratis what is cymbalta indicated for priligy dapoxetine price best price for real rosuvastatin low cost overnight aspirin abana prix en pharmacie en france reputable online pharmacy modafinil order prevacid without prescription over counter tenormin orlistat uk boots generic of wellbutrin sr how to buy fosamax alli from canadian pharmacy indinavir canada overnight delivery do people abuse prednisone how to apply estrace cream pills rx pharmacy exam net index london women seeking men classifieds craigslist wellbutrin 100mg buy apartments for rent in new york city manhattan craigslist generic name alphagan p mexican pharmacy no prescription aciclovir ranbaxy generic diovan premarin prescription coupon ephedraxin pills drugstore viagra soft without apcalis sx to buy in england buy estrace cream zetia sublingual dosage order propecia online is florinef a prescription drug generic avapro 300mg alesse lawsuits buy shatavari where to purchase phenamax medrol tablets what is it used for hytrin capsules comprar clomid on line suprax 400 mg online promethazine pharmacy coupons lisinopril delivery london what is metformin used for during pregnancy buy antivert online from usa cheap accutane canada cyklokapron mail order buy kamagra in australia atacand 100mg cheep side effects of korean panax ginseng what works better viagra or levtira bupropion hcl contraindications buy uk canadian altace online ordering prometrium here in canada levitra pas cher paris prinivil tablets from buy buy viagra online with mastercard pariet 20 mg wiki cheap generic benfotiamine top canadian pharmaceutical companies cefixime drugs online purchases where purchase zanaflex generic forzest buy canada buy levitra online no prescription pill tegibs 6 tegaserod maleate keppra on line purchase where to buy levothyroxine online in uk drugstore why has proventil been discontinued india terramycin price cheap genuine female viagra online nizagara mexico companies only where purchase cefadroxil torsemide uses medication what is meclizine hydrochloride used for revatio purchase in canada no prescription advair diskus prices usa finast canada overnight delivery metoclopramide indian brands can you buy chloroquine looking counter can you buy over the counter get viagra ipratropium bromide albuterol sulfate dosage protonix mg usa best price for real proscar are all active birth control pills the same dose getting a viagra prescription online propranolol new zealand pamelor generic for seroquel xr harmful effects performance enhancement drugs use gyne-lotrimin coupon online acquistare florinef in italia deltasone mg price lexapro generic for anxiety amantadine 1000 mg capsules rare isoptin mg canada feldene next day singulair italiano prednisone over the couter zestril for sale roxithromycin medication walmart pharmacy price celebrex top 10 cefixime brands in india atacand plus maximum dosage do you need rx mentat terramycin generic vantin dosage better than diabecon fexofenadine hydrochloride and pregnancy optum rx medicare part d formulary zovirax cream price philippines bupropion price increase what are the side effects of taking ranitidine does ginseng affect birth control pills omnicef for sale uk order accutane online bonus pills isotretinoin acticin online no prescription where can lithium be found on earth keppra comprar brasil skelaxin buy online ireland zithromax reviews chlamydia prednisone 20 mg daily side effects were can i buy acutne cost of cleocin gel order revia cheap kytril 50mg tablets viagra no email cabgolin generic reviews low cost blopress tapering low dose prednisone ra cialis professional tablets 150 mg betnovate cream weight gain online pharmacy no prescription needed betapace brand toradol for sale buying prescription drugs without insurance trental 600 costo done with accutane now what buy alesse 22 trimix tables download etodolac order canada vente de brahmi au quebec best place buy relafen pct dilaudid hydromorphone rectal where to get prazosin pct neurontin 600 mg 50 c,entikli film tablet uroxatral medicine children 40 mg levitra online prednisolone max dose what kind of drug is carafate buy abana 10 10mg can buy water pills over counter how much is paxil without insurance equivalent dose esomeprazole omeprazole celexa heart lawsuit florinef discounts codes how to use lasix for bodybuilding retin-a 0,05 on line india revatio price buy styplon visa tenormin generic release date florinef australia nolvadex lowest price online where to get cialis in malaysia buy terramycin uk unicure remedies private limited amsterdam pharmacy manhattan generic cialis release date cialis super active dosage buy zyban online from usa lawsuit against strattera abortion pills online for sale mexico pharmacies online that sell cymbalta beat way to order pravachol aricept evess 10 mg 28 agizda dagilan tablet aciphex ships from india erythromycin tablets dosage for acne the online drugstore purim ic doxycycline hyc side effects average price viagra uk best pills for long erection online clinic co uk viagra where can i get cialis in bangkok buy fincar from canada dapoxetine tablets on line to buy indian generics online dulcolax decadron prescription comprar revista hola online propecia sales 2009 what is the drug effexor xr used for is it illegal to order generic colospa innopran xl no prescription canada how to purchase rumalaya forte online how does viagra work blood flow is mail order flovent safe canadian alliance party stephen harper leader tadapox for men sale in uk buy cialis 200 order trazodone 120 mg order hydrochlorothiazide pill hyaluronic acid next day buy dramamine in australia cozaar tablets 100 mg birth control pills buy alesse online danazol 100 mg cap how much clomid and nolvadex for pct what is diclofenac sodium for micardis hct where geriforte syrup levlen on line no script aspirin drug class what does astelin nasal spray do azelastine buy medrol pills in the mexico erectalis 20 mg (generic cialis) tadacip/ kamagra-plus where can i get kamagra oral jelly sumycin next day shipping purim india olanzapine cheap coversyl 5mg dosage how to buy propranolol in london clozaril on line in the canada buy levitra in arizona buy zyprexa patch bactroban generic cost dutas on line purchase artane direct pharmacy where can i get diabecon pills alesse visa lioresal discounts codes find viagra coupons levitra online order do i need a prescription for mestinon indocin buy canada over the counter equivalent to celexa flonase online coupon code levitra buy uk online current price famvir voltaren gel precio mexico mentat ds syrup perth australia why has erexin-v been discontinued paxil pharmacy coupons yasmin price australia abilify generic release date keftab delivery uk levitra generico professional serophene for dogs buy pharmacy express viagra comprar levitra plus original buy paxil pills cheap himplasia pills buy tamoxifen pills online how long does it take for liquid cialis to work what is erythromycin ethylsuccinate used for erexor over counter uk what is beconase aq for cheap liverpool apartments to rent for weekend paxil reviews panic disorder lov cost famvir voveran sr medicine online buy antabuse tablets online lotrisone free shipping cymbalta 20 mg vs 30 mg benicar 20 mg tablet biaxin generico online legal to buy vytorin long term side effects of retin-a 0,025 safe cephalexin no prescription dutasteride buy canada no prescriptio allegra tablet sale trial erection packs 2 pharmacy where to triamterene bupropion uk next day delivery imitrex discounts over the counter prevacid for children order oxybutynine uk canadian casodex prescription coupon retin-a 0,025 tablets doxycycline hyclate dose for syphilis abilify side effects children discount desyrel mg can order tadalis sx online lamictal overnight delivery where to buy cialis jelly in canada safely what is cozaar medication for high blood pressure alesse wyeth low dose oral contraceptive como combatir la disfuncion erectil psicologica costco pharmacy midamor price bupropion discount coupons simvastatin 40 mg review can you buy allegra in ireland is it safe to buy prescription drugs from mexico lipitor dosage zoloft uk name buy prednisolone online no prescription uk elavil medicinenet avapro 75 mg tablet quiero comprar viagra por internet methotrexate generico italiano allopurinol prescription drug information finasteride drug classification order fucidin from canada without prescription sumycin 40 mg pharmacy buy antibiotics for chlamydia low cost dilantin order abilify 5 mg online cozaar mims sale benemid i want to order viagra online tadalafil cheapest online albendazole drugs for sale long time side effects aleve my viagra super active coupons viagra over the counter boots many order nizagara overnight prednisone side effects prednisone and alcohol liquid tadacip review health canada actos how to use lasix for weight loss online pharmacy wellbutrin sr where can i get tetracycline buy betapace in uk how much does acai berry pills cost allopurinol side effects uk hyzaar forte 100 25 silagra sildenafil citrate buy zetia greece eldepryl over the couter purim prescription coupon what does cardura look like viagra plus without a prescription safe femara no prescription sildenafil citrate medication treat ann summers drugs asthma inhalers sale uk wellbutrin lawsuit anacin tablet india low price acivir pills uk donde puedo comprar aciclovir crema there generic drug benicar hct seroquel xr 150 mg price mevacor prices usa cefixime low dose birth control cipro comprar doxycycline mg mexico cheap vpxl no prescription combivent dosage recommended hytrin for sale buy vermox for daily use order tegretol canada atarax without prescription canada valtrex and birth control pills plavix manufacturer assistance buy endep online from usa hydrochlorothiazide with no perscription femara uk is viagra plus available over the counter dostinex roche precio argentina lasix reviews lithium metal cost per gram med cab ciplox beat way to order cialis super active lipitor competitors baclofen dosage too high where to buy cheap generic claritin bactrim birth control online australia avodart on line in the india over counter triamterene herbal viagra does it work tetracycline dosage acne cheap bystolic chloroquine online pharmacy uk amaryl best price billig ginette-35 online kaufen clomid without prescription canada google image search generic lariam in usa cephalexin capsules cheap generic viagra co uk kamagra oral jelly 100mg online pharmacy without prescription retin a 0.1 to buy midamor in uk pavitra rishta desi tashan 30 jan 2013 isoptin looking for coumadin precio mexico xenical drugs orlistat alli hay algun tipo viagra para mujeres misoprostol cytotec in italia how to buy femara in london buy ampicillin lowest purinethol max dose what is levaquin tablets used for buy florinef tablets online canada cozaar 50 mg luvox dose for ocd viagra soft online order fluoxetine shopping exelon generation kennett square pa lasix medicine lamisil italiano indocin usa cvs prices can i make urispas yagara canada online no prescription order tegretol online uk cheap genuine lopid online weakest to strongest akatsuki members what is aygestin 5 mg 10 oder 20 mg levitra femara drug in mexico pharmacy my vpxl coupons discount benicar 20mg crestor tablets buy actos medicine online best price for real decadron levlen to buy from europe order lisinopril no prescription bactrim brands india erexin price how long does it take for medrol dose pack to start working purchase haldol pills buy synthroid 75 mcg trazodone 150 mg tablet picture generic mycelex-g buy canada robaxin canada online no prescription adalat delivery next day generic accutane canada pharmacy no prescription top drugstore mascaras 2012 gasex dosage too high how much illegal drugs come from mexico cordarone prices at costco what does dipyridamole torsemide for sale uk clomid mg order avapro generic name name atarax noprescrition needed usa online pharmacy buy cialis super active paypal where to buy zoloft pramipexole restless legs dose help buying nexium india pharmacies online that sell lipitor buy hytrin online us no prescription toprol xl buy canada fucidin ointment australia betapace 100 how much does walgreens pay per hour in texas seroxat 10mg side effects can you buy rocaltrol online drugs order promethazine online in usa lowest priced famvir ephedraxin coupons no prescription zoloft canada buy crestor 200 cheap kamagra oral jelly india ajanta pharma lamictal where can i buy it viagra super active usa no prescription can order diamox canada kamagra gold how to buy anafranil delivery hydrochlorothiazide no prescription compare prices what is the medicine suprax for where can i buy propecia in uk canada drugs synthroid with prescription celexa reviews for ocd can wellbutrin tablets be split bactrim generico italiano comprar levitra 10 mg sildenafil dose in neonates can i buy cialis from canada buy femara 10 fincar overnight pharmacy elocom plyn ulotka what is aciphex 20 mg for how to get isoptin in australia online aspirin purchase cleocin gel canada no prescription keflex side effects weight gain canadian pharmacies online no prescription can you get danazol over the counter can you buy hydroxychloroquine fast worldwide shipping liv phone orders celebrex canada companies only viagra dosage recommended 12.5 cialis 2.5 mg buy sinequan without a script 118 118 advert buy nitroglycerin 5 zerit weight gain buy canada no prescription for levitra super active no prescription buy adalat online fertomid generic reviews trental price kamagra gold prix en pharmacie en france zyrtec over counter drug cheapest aciclovir in the uk aqua band songs free download atorlip non generic rumalaya liniment buy canada generic vytorin overnite shipping zyban nhs stop smoking best site to buy imitrex budesonide entocort side effects can you buy doxycycline over the counter in south africa how long does it take for zyprexa to leave the body cafergot tablets online benadryl 100 ct why is there a shortage of caverta buy wellbutrin australia can aricept get you high cheap levitra india can you get rechargeable lithium aa batteries atarax doctors online levitra professional in the uk now how to use brand cialis where can i purchase aspirin forzest sale buy cialis chloroquine shipping overseas efeitos colaterais da sertralina 100 mg sarafem where to purchase can you get a rash from levaquin compare prices acivir pills permethrin 5 dermal cream over the counter buy pyridium without a prescription from canadian pharmacy buy medrol 10 pulmicort respules discount missed 3 ortho tri cyclen pills over counter pravachol buy ginette-35 pills online buying cipro in manchester leading pharmaceutical companies in india 2011 buy clozaril tablets mexico are allies good or bad buy generic xenical india safe colchicine no precription where to buy cialis ointment singulair paediatric 4mg diclofenac 75mg buy online without prescription atacand 32 mg prices buy kamagra capsules very cheap aricept stieva-a cream pantip generic cystone for sale on line minocycline 100mg capsules acne where to buy femara online mexico zyvox mail order what does the medicine cephalexin do can you buy luvox over the counter prescription solutions prior auth forms buy suprax cephalosporin allergic paroxetine over counter drug to buy geriforte syrup in uk zoloft dosages for anxiety oder mg tablets of zovirax health canada styplon how to get aristocort in australia how much does diovan hct cost order dostinex from cleocin shelf life viagra super active+ 100mg pills minipress prix en pharmacie en france purchase tretinoin ms pharmacy in canada universities abc pharmacy san francisco puerto rico rosuvastatin side effects long term use how to import chloroquine allegra pills drugstore cheap genuine phexin online turkish pharmacy companies buy over the counter tulasi online sale alphagan online order nolvadex clomid quiero comprar nitroglycerin nexium over counter acheter speman fosamax alternative drugs buy alli diet pills toronto tesco pharmacy online malarone can you buy lasix over the counter in germany how to take levlen mg diamox without prescription canada cheap drugs online pharmacy buy naprosyn tablets usa diltiazem prix en pharmacie en france ranitidine pills generic ashwagandha buy canada ephedraxin tablets us online minoxidil 10 mg without a script order depakote online zovirax drug in usa pharmacy how to import levitra non prescription luvox zyrtec discontinued doxycycline hyclate buy online what is the difference in lamictal and lamictal xr free zyprexa coupons where to buy buspar ointment canada and bactrim buy aleve astrailia benadryl dose for dogs fireworks serpina prescription coupon what is antivert used for generic retin-a 0,05 for sale on line florida maxalt buy cipro xr online chewable viagra mexico famvir 500mg price buy clomid patch where to get zofran pct cialis no prescription india cheap caverta uk comprar penegra portugal brand name coumadin vs generic warfarin generic requip cost methotrexate pills dosage dosage of ivermectin for horses best pharmacy to order sominex duo boots promo code 2012 propranolol beta blockers for anxiety to buy hyaluronic acid in uk buy drugs canada no prescription ambien 10mg trip cialis professional australia pharmacy stilnox sleeping tablets addiction what does zyrtec d treat order generic dutas can u get diflucan over the counter where can i buy ashwagandha european association of faculties of pharmacy members mentax reviews for men voltaren overnight where to buy zanaflex mg adalat tablets side effects what is champix used for canadian association of chain drug stores toronto valtrex discount no prescription cheap genuine finast online buy viagra from europe suhagra 100 rx canada what does benzac how to use clomid effectively mexican pharmacies that ship to us drugs what is tegretol tablets for how to use zovirax for genital herpes what is rumalaya gel tablets buy sibutramine hydrochloride can you buy aciclovir tablets over the counter generic order bystolic lowest price flagyl er free shipping compare prices aciclovir buy aricept visa best site get fml forte neurontin tablets used order motrin online in usa how much valtrex to take for cold sores can you get high off paroxetine hydrochloride 20 mg pariet without a prescription from india online innopran xl purchase order metoclopramide lowest price acheter tricorne jack sparrow purim over counter what is prazosin hydrochloride buy zofran odt canada cheapest blopress tablets uk albendazole from india ranitidine 150 mg reviews is there a generic for lexapro purchase here cheapest malegra fxt sildenafil fluoxetine tadalafil quick delivery vermox low cost pioglitazone and bladder cancer 2012 furosemide retail price reviews forum alli weight loss buyers of zaditor canada natural replacement cialis lopid package insert how to get acai on line zyban spc cheap generic venlor uti medication ampicillin remeron where to buy in canada clozaril prescription assistance purchase ranitidine online where to buy zoloft 25 nitroglycerin in the uk norvasc sale prescription kytril low dose birth control side effects of duetact overnight viagra delivery us dog medication without prescriptions cheap micardis hct lisinopril no prescription online what does prednisolone tablets treat celadrin what does paxil do erythromycin side effects hunger lamisil generic india cheap weight gain pills for women birth control pills avalide purchasing retin-a 0,05 online uk nombre generico de vytorin celebrex usage and dosage noroxin tablet sale lloyds pharmacy online calculator sale midamor buy minocin mr online citalopram from europe what is flagyl prescribed for in dogs cheap trimox 40 mg claritin generic 2013 drugs diflucan for purchase depakote prices walmart ic diclofenac sod ec 75 mg what is it for cheapest cefixime what is zofran 4mg used for where to get eulexin urispas where to get lov cost keftab liquid evecare review is it legal to buy prescriptions from canada online is there a drug comparative to nolvadex india pharmacy cialis 75mg aspirin australia propranolol online no prescription canadian pharmaceuticals buy prozac overnight cialis daily use packaging what category of drug is celebrex safe place order alli online atrovent india propecia online without rx best place buy norvasc purchase neurontin 300mg online is it safe to take 100mg of viagra sky pharmacy brooklyn ny buy acticin online overnight geriforte tablets side effects clozaril medication online speman how to buy celebrex commercial location bike frumil over counter viagra super active birth control online australia printable alli coupons 2012 zofran with american express india asacol price order clonidine online no prescription viagra online usa maximum daily dose of capoten what is tadalafil tablets super active sale levitra cheap online cialis what is the generic for wellbutrin ranitidine reviews and dosage buy jelly australia kamagra pills celexa generic cost best alesse prices safe lithium buy cordarone injection action finasteride 5 mg picture where to buy north american ginseng top 10 online celadrin sites what kind of infections does ciprofloxacin treat cipla company profile wikipedia best place to buy vasodilan diovan india sale american heart association guidelines for nitroglycerin buy adalat hong kong clozaril order what is the drug meclizine used for medicine atarax syrup buy bupropion xl no prescription homeopathic treatment for arthritis in fingers avandamet generic available levitra patient information leaflet order female cialis online with visa valtrex no prescription cheap roxithromycin hair loss asacol online meds mentax where to get is diflucan legal in uk buy duphalac online from usa canadian online pharmacy for betapace how to buy dostinex kamagra sildenafil citrate nebenwirkungen can you get topamax over the counter decadron iv dose for nausea cheap cities to live in india viagra without prescriptions legal buy bentyl lowest price online cheap buy abilify generic from where to buy viagra in pakistan acheter furosemide sans ordonnance best place to buy bactroban what is nexium 40 mg esomeprazole for medrol 4mg dose pack dosage metoclopramide for discount where to buy lipitor in uk is keppra available over the counter ranitidine generic form us online pharmacy no prescription carbozyne cialis brand name sale auk adalat online movie wellbutrin limited india duetact generic buy chloromycetin pills online purchase cialis lowest price can you order erexor cheap alphagan p drug can you buy requip over the counter generic alli overnite shipping buy keppra xr online reviews of estrace cream diakof canada prescription clozaril comprar buyers of strattera canada differin cream reviews novartis diovan sales billion canada drugs torsemide with prescription order seroquel 200mg order acai berry weight loss pills can i get pregnant while on prednisone buying wellbutrin cheap metformin tablets pharmacies what s.t.d is metronidazole 500mg used for purchase synthroid no prescription retino-a cream 0,05 next day clindamycin acne reviews over counter finpecia maximum safe dose of zantac pfizer vrg 100 pill actonel now buying viagra sublingual in manchester buy dostinex perth australia overnight pharmacy order deltasone canadian clozaril ordering can you get high off snorting trazodone motrin suppliers overseas over counter duetact periactin for itchy dogs dostinex generic cheap costs safe place order imuran buy proscar 5mg get silagra las vegas what is voveran sr 100 used for buy dapoxetine 100mg online buy viagra jelly greece cheapest viagra online pictures of famvir pills fincar buy on line top 5 drugstore concealers order propecia online no presctiption is mail order ralista safe aciclovir discount overnight there generic keflex what is the national socialist movement tegretol and birth control pills buy periactins online adalat la 20 mg tablets kamagra online canada can buy phenergan online order tenormin on line uk speman cost canadian diclofenac sod max dose how to buy hyzaar diflucan fluconazole kegunaan what is the cost of 1 gram of lithium elocom krem srbija prednisone italiano canada buy mexitil without prescription xenical dosage directions nolvadex / tamoxifen buy which uk site to buy cafergot adidas torsion allegra solebox where to buy cheap generic cyklokapron reverse google image search cialis sales 2012 buy kamagra soft no prescription withdrawal from paroxetine duration of symptoms finast roche precio argentina what are the side effects of citalopram withdrawal buying prescription drugs abroad uk to buy voltaren in uk worx gt 24 volt lithium reviews prednisone side effects moon face haldol decanoate shortage where to buy live fish food what does the cialis commercial mean baclofen dose for anxiety shuddha guggulu generico italiano stromectol tablets for purchase cialis 5 mg tablet ordering doxazosin here in canada where can i buy xeloda in canada us online pharmacy no prescription ophthacare differin drug in mexico pharmacy finasteride dosage form is xyzal better than zyrtec generic suprax in usa what is maxalt 10 mg used for exelon 3 mg price donde comprar lioresal find walgreens drugstore allegra echeck online generic viagra super active healthy weight man generic lipitor australia duphalac maximum dose best online pharmacy generic apcalis sx maxalt lingua 10mg tabletten como puedo comprar cytotec en venezuela can i order diclofenac no prescription in the usa suhagra generic reviews dosage of suprax for uti urispas online pay paypal order ranitidine 300 mg how much is tegretol without insurance colchicine compounding pharmacy best site to buy septilin buy acai powder australia tetracycline generic manufacturer furosemide no prescription compare prices my betoptic coupons jagged alliance pre order himplasia brands india order crestor cheap generic ciprofloxacin price arimidex steroid reviews what is trazodone used for buy unisom pills online methotrexate phone orders buy menosan online pharmacy ginseng order ortho tri-cyclen lawsuit macquarie discount pharmacy act comprar zithromax original where to buy metformin 500 citalopram suppositories buy nizoral best online non prescription pharmacy where can i buy norvasc sweet rx pharmacy software where to benadryl zyrtec online sales buy acticin permethrin pharmacy low cost alphagan prescription buy retino-a cream 0,025 mg online plendil for sale online depo medrol onde comprar buying levitra plus from canada no prescription calcium carbonate prices at costco online pharmacy atorlip-10 erexin-v dose canadain rx haldol decanoate 50 mg buy viagra india no prescription paypal zithromax chlamydia treatment alcohol propecia singapore extended use of prednisone in dogs provera 10mg for 5 days suprax 400mg dosage alli orlistat cheap how to buy cialis online in canada uroxatral for sale australia alli diet pills in canada dosage zithromax to cure gonorrhea pay by check for girl scout cookies side effects of ciprodex otic what does ranitidine do to you cyproheptadine hcl can i get trileptal over the counter buy cholestoplex tablets online saw palmetto with other medications combivent lawsuit canada how to use clomiphene citrate for men how to order ortho tri-cyclen online is there a generic for provera buy antivert for daily use online pharmacy voveran hoodia usa cvs prices glucotrol us companies only discount indocin mg which uk site to buy robaxin perrigo tretinoin cream 0.1 cdlonline ssri how to take endep canadian pharmacy valtrex antiviral herpes zoster vytorin rxlist buy triamcinolone acetonide cream usp 0.5 doxycycline pills online in the uk fucidin h cream reviews styplon generic wikipedia drugs ordering rx drugs online order non generic brand advair diskus how much does trazodone cost on the street levitra professional woldwide shipping lisinopril mg canadian rx levitra professional no prescription canada best price for brand viagra buy lotrisone online no prescription pharmacy buy effexor xr pills in the australia beconase aq overnight pharmacy viagra 100mg buy online buy levothyroxine no prescription uk pharmacy cheap risperdal 40 mg tretinoin uk buy remeron soltab se tomar alcohol eritromicina viagra jellyfish celebrex in the uk now toprol xl where to purchase cheap online pharmacy india can you take asacol daily online canadian pharmacy vipps keppra daily use reviews propranolol er 60 mg prices cialis sublingual sale 5mg tadalafil trimox 100 pharmacy assistant jobs in canada buy metformin boots pharmacy generic mentat in usa donde puedo comprar phenergan order plavix from india cheap prozac without rx what over the counter cough syrup has promethazine in it buy provera without rx acquisto keflex sicuro online buy flovent uk research grade ethionamide pharmacy usa online affordable sildenafil best generic astelin review where can i get retino-a cream 0,05 pills where to get nolvadex alli in stock now atorlip-10 sold over counter why is there a shortage of nootropil amitriptyline generico italiano acai prescription coupon esomeprazole magnesium tablets i.p use serpina coupon online atrovent online overnight etodolac 20mg tab uk pharmacies online that sell propranolol purchase xenical pills generic levitra safe trazodone tablets from buy what kind of medicine is zanaflex montelukast dose children what is the generic of voltaren emulgel tegretol 100mg chewable ditropan pas cher doryx dr 150 mg uses purchase endep can you buy flovent discount 125mcg side effects of phenergan buy flonase hong kong nasal online minomycin india lasix 20mg tablets buy rumalaya online pharmacy blopress medicine children how much inderal does it take to overdose where to buy avodart with echeck buy levitra super active online overnight delivery atarax comprimidos embarazo side effects of hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tablets viagra generic equivalent where to get acai bowls lipothin online cheap shallaki where can i buy it vasotec in the uk diskus sale discount generic advair levitra professional side effects uk seroflo legal us levitra shipping to puerto rico betoptic italiano reglan 100mg cheep voveran no prescription compare prices suprax 200 mg side effects comprar geriforte en argentina haridra maximum dosage indocin 50 mg tid can we trust fosamax online generic zoloft coupons pregnancy success after clomid cefadroxil shelf life mexican online pharmacy medications actos for purchase accutane long term side effects fertility buy pills from canada online cost of finasteride 5mg erectile dysfunction drugs no prescription lopid pharmacy discount epivir-hbv mg secure canadian pharmacy websites dosis recomendada aciclovir 400 mg imuran discount voucher clomid ovulation day 12 cost of cialis daily dose nizoral shampoo buy shatavari pills overnight pharmacy paxil retin a reviews before and after half price lanoxin estrace cream coupon drugstore canada triamterene canada head office vantin price india rayh viagra india buy silagra tablets online
الرئيسية | قضايا ساخنة | العربية في قفص الاتهام | هل جنى سيبويه الفارسي على اللغة العربية؟ مهندس لبناني من خارج الحزب اللغوي يرمي حجراً في مياه النحو العربي الساكنة - رشيد الخيُّون

صفحة شبكة صوت العربية في فيسبوكtwitterقناة شبكة صوت العربية في يوتيوبشبكة صوت العربية في موقع فليكر

هل جنى سيبويه الفارسي على اللغة العربية؟ مهندس لبناني من خارج الحزب اللغوي يرمي حجراً في مياه النحو العربي الساكنة - رشيد الخيُّون طباعة إرسال إلى صديق
تقييم المستخدمين: / 3
الكاتب صوت العربية   
الثلاثاء, 16 سبتمبر 2008 19:21


سنوات وأهالي منطقتنا الريفية يلبون فريضة الصلاة على صوت مؤذن المسجد، غير المختص، وهو يلحن في الشهادة الثانية، فيقول: «أشهد أن محمدٌ رسول الله»، ولم يلتفت إلى لحن المؤذن غير مدرس اللغة العربية الجديد الأديب سالم الدباغ، المعروف بين الوسط الثقافي العراقي، وكان منفياً سياسياً وسط الأهوار، شاهدناه، نحن طلبته، يسرع الخطوات صوب المسجد، ليعلم المؤذن درساً في أن وأخواتها، فقيل له: لا يوجد مؤذن متفرغ بالمنطقة فاستعان الأهالي بمزيد النَدَّاف. عاد الدباغ إلى المدرسة وهي دار سكنه وعمله، على أمل أن المؤذن سمع احتجاجه. والعبرة من هذه الحادثة أن الناس ظلوا يسمعون معنى الأذان لا شكله، فيتوجهون إلى الصلاة من دون أن يعنوا بالمنصوب والمرفوع من كلماته، وببساطة كانوا مؤتلفين مع مؤذنهم النَدَّاف، أما مدرس اللغة العربية المتمرس فوصل لسمعه الشكل قبل المعنى، ليجد في رفع اسم (أن) جناية تعطل الأذان والصلاة. نجد دلالة هذه الحادثة جلية في كتاب «جناية سيبويه .. الرفض التام لما في النحو من أوهام» (دار رياض الريس للكتب والنشر) لزكريا أوزون، وهو المهندس لا اللغوي، داعياً إلى حيوية النحو العربي ونبذ تعقيداته غير المبررة. فاللغة العربية ترد على لسان الناطقين بها، بمختلف اللهجات العراقية، السورية، المغربية أو المصرية وغيرها، لا تعنيهم أُصول النحو العربي بشيء، ولو حصل أن التزموا نطق الكلام بها لكانوا محط سخرية وتندر بعضهم البعض.

يعزو أوزون تراجع اللغة العربية، أمام اللغات الأكثر حيوية في العالم، إلى تعقيد ولا منطقية قواعدها، ويسند مشكلات النحو العربي كافة إلى سيبويه الفارسي، الذي تتلمذ على يد اللغوي العربي الخليل بن أحمد الفراهيدي، على حد عبارته أن الذنب ليس ذنب سيبويه في ما وضع من أُصول وقواعد اعتمد فيها على حركة أواخر الكلمات دليلاً، جمعت في كتاب عرف بكتاب سيبويه، ذلك لحاجة أبناء قومه من الفرس وسواهم، وإنما الذنب يتحمله مَنْ جعل هذه القواعد نهجاً في تقويم اللسان العربي. والحقيقة التي يضعها أمامنا مؤرخو النحو العربي أن سيبويه لم يكن مخترعاً لتلك الأُصول، وإنما أخذها من أساتذته العرب، وأخذها هؤلاء من أفواه أهل البادية. ومن المرجح أنه كان واحداً من جماعة ساهمت في تأليف كتاب النحو، الذي عرف باسمه، قال أبو فرج النديم في «الفهرست»: «قرأت بخط أبي العباس ثعلب، اجتمع على صنعة كتاب سيبويه اثنان وأربعون إنساناً منهم سيبويه».
يذكر باحث الاجتماع العراقي علي الوردي، وهو أحد الثائرين على أُصول النحو العربي وصاحب معارك حامية الوطيس مع اللغويين والمصححين اللغويين، روايات تأسيس علم النحو العربي وتعقيداته بعيداً عن سيبويه، نوجزها بالآتي: إن الخليفة عمر بن الخطاب رضي الله عنه سمع لحناً في ترتيل القرآن الكريم يؤدي إلى الكفر، فأمر أبا الأسود الدؤلي بوضع قواعد النحو. وفي رواية أن الإمام علي بن أبي طالب رضي الله عنه سمع كثرة اللحن فأمر أبا الأسود بوضع قواعد النحو، بعد أن علمه إياها، وقيل كانت بداية النحو: أن طلب أمير البصرة زياد ابن أبيه من أبي الأسود وضع قواعد تقوّم لفظ أولاده، وقيل أن أبا الأسود اهتدى لقواعد النحو بعد أن سمع كثرة لحن الموالي (المسلمين من غير العرب)، أو بعد انزعاجه من لحن ابنته.
تؤكد الروايات المذكورة، والتي تحققنا منها في كتب «طبقات النحويين» للزبيدي، و«المنتظم» لابن الجوزي، و«المحكم في نقط المصاحف» للداني، دور أبي الأسود (ت69هـ) في وضع النحو العربي قبل زمن سيبويه (179هـ أو نحو ذلك) بحوالي قرن من الزمن. وبالتأكيد أن ما وضعه الدؤلي أو معاصروه من قواعد في النحو لا تصل إلى تعقيدات ومبهمات عصر سيبويه، إلا أن القلق لم يساور سيبويه فحسب وإنما ساور أستاذه الفراهيدي فاستنبط «من علل النحو ما لم يستنبطه أحد»، وان سيبويه صنف كتابه من علم الفراهيدي، واثنى على ذلك اللغوي يونس بن حبيب(طبقات النحويين). وأرى شهرة سيبويه في النحو ونسبته له مثل شهرة قيس بن الملوح وآل عذرة بالغزل وأبي نواس باللهو والمجون.
إن الدعوة إلى تيسير النحو العربي، والتي يدعو إليها صاحب كتاب «جناية سيبويه» ليست جديدة، ولعل أقدمها دعوة ابن مضاء القرطبي (القرن السادس الهجري) في كتابه «الرد على النحاة»، وهو لم يأت في مراجع ومصادر زكريا أوزون. أما في العصر الحاضر فظهر العديد من الداعين إلى تيسير النحو، واتهموا جميعاً بالقصور في هذا العلم، فالقارئ العربي، على حد رأي أوزون، ينظر إلى اللفظ قبل المعنى، فتذهب جزالة المعاني في أخطاء شكلها أي حركات إعرابها ورسمها. من هؤلاء كان إبراهيم مصطفى في كتابه «إحياء النحو»، وأمين الخولي وعبد الستار الجواري، وكما أسلفنا علي الوردي، الذي اضطر أن ينشر مقالات ضد متهميه في تشويه اللغة العربية وقصوره في الإعراب، وبالتالي الطعن في براعته العلمية، وتواطئه مع الغرب وغيرها من التهم. ومما كتبه أحد المتعصبين للنحو العربي باعتباره سمة من سمات الوحدة العربية، وركناً من أركان القومية العربية: «هذه اللغة هي العالم الأمثل بالنسبة لنا نحن العرب.. إذ أن لها أثراً عظيماً في تكوين وصياغة نفسياتنا.. فإن الذين يحاربون لغتنا بسوء إنما يضمرون لنا الأسوأ.. فهم يريدون تبسيط اللغة العربية، ويريدون حذف الكثير منها، ألم يعلم أي من هؤلاء أن لغتنا مقدسة كالصلوات الخمس، فهل يستطيع إنسان أن يترك واحدة منها للسهولة، أو البساطة» (عن الوردي، من بعد الثمانين). لكن ألم يسأل كاتب هذه السطور نفسه في جدوى قواعد وأُصول لا يفقهها العربي؟ وكأن التعقيد النحوي غاية لمن يحرص على التفرد، فلو أصبح في متناول كل ناطق بالعربية لغابت طبقة عرفت قديماً بطبقة اللغويين أو النحويين، وأفلس المعتاشون على تصيد أخطاء الصرف والإعراب.
ومثلما جوبه علي الوردي بالمثالب جوبه الباحث هادي العلوي إثر دعوته وممارسته في الكتابة بأسلوب اليسر النحوي، رأياً منه أن صعوبة النحو تمنع سيولة الأفكار والتعبير عنها، لذا اضطر محررو الدوريات التي استكتبته، أن يعلنوا البراءة من أسلوبه خشية من مثلب القصور في النحو العربي، فهمشت مجلة «مواقف» (العدد 63) مقالته بالآتي: «للأستاذ هادي العلوي وجهة نظر في النحو والصرف والإعراب، وتبعاً لذلك في تهجئة الكلمات وكتابتها، واحتراماً لوجهة نظره هذه، دون أن يعني ذلك تبنياً بالضرورة نحرص على نشر كتاباته بنصها دون تعديل إعرابي، ونرجو قراءنا أن يروا في ما يبدو ظاهرياً أنه خلل إعرابي، على أنه ليس خطأً، وإنما تطبيق عملي لوجهة النظر هذه».
وسيبويه، الذي يحمله زكريا أوزون وزر تعقيد بل تبليد النحو العربي، هو مولى فارسي لبني الحارث، وشاع عن معنى اسمه «رائحة التفاح»، لكن الصحيح (سي بويه) تعني «ثلاثون رائحة»، فهو ذو الثلاثين رائحة، وربما أتت كناية عن جمال مُحيّاه. أشاد المبرد في كتاب سيبويه بالقول: «إذا أراد إنسان أن يُقرأ عليه كتاب سيبويه يقول له: هل ركبت البحر، تعظيماً له واستصعاباً لما فيه»، وقال المازني: «مَنْ أراد أن يعمل كتاباً كبيراً في النحو بعد كتاب سيبويه فليستح» (الفهرست). والكتاب الذي أشاد فيه أساطين العربية واعتبره زكريا أوزون جناية ليس خاصاً بالأعاجم، وإنما تعقيده حال تعقيد علوم الكلام والفلسفة والفقه وغيرها من العلوم الدقيقة، تمحور حولها أساتذة وطلاب، يجدون في تبسيطها ضياعاً لخصوصيتها وبالتالي لسطوتهم وتفردهم، فكان همهم التعالي عن العامة بالعلم الخاص، غير أنها ملأت في وقتها فراغاً، وشغلت أُناساً.
الكتاب بفصوله السبعة: زبدة الكتاب، الكلمات والجمل، الاسم، الأدوات، إعراب الجمل، شواهد وتخريجات نحوية، بين الماضي والحاضر، كان نقداً لا يخلو من السخرية فما ذهب إليه النحاة واللغويين من تعقيد غير معقول. لقد اعتمدوا حركات أواخر الكلمات في خلقهم لهذا العلم، فانشقوا حوله إلى بصريين وكوفيين، يتبع كل منهم الحالة الفكرية السائدة بمصره، فكان البصريون أقرب إلى التفكير العقلي حيث الفكر المعتزلي، بينما تأثر الكوفيون بالنصوص.
دعا مؤلف الكتاب إلى التناسب بين الدلالات والمدلولات في النحو، مثلما ورد تحت عنوان المعارف والنكرات، والجامد والمشتق، فحسب رأيه أن هذا التصنيف «لا يضيف إلا التعقيد والإغراب لقواعد لغتنا، فلا يوجد اسم مشتق، والأسماء هي الأسماء بجميع أنواعها» (ص62)، ونجده يسأل: هل الحنان اسم جامد، وهو العاطفة المتحركة؟ ودعا إلى إلغاء ما عرف بالمصروف والممنوع من الصرف، فهو لا يجد فرقاً بين أن نقول: دعد أو دعداً، هند.. أو هنداً إلخ. ونراه يستغرب تسمية أن وعن ولكن وغيرها من الكلمات بالحروف، مع أنها تتألف من عدة حروف، وكيف تسمى الجملة اسمية من دون التمييز بين ثباتها أو تغيرها، فما الفرق بين الجملتين الآتيتين: «الطفل سعيد»، و «الأرض كروية»، أين تأثير الزمن فيهما، مع أن الجملة الاسمية هي الجملة التي تشير إلى الثبات، وهنا يطالب بإعادة النظر في مفهوم هذه الجملة، من دون أن يأتي بمقترح.
نوافق أوزون على عدم منطقية مسائل عديدة في النحو العربي، إن نظرنا إليها من باب المعنى لا التكوين اللغوي، وصياغة القانون والقياس، منها هل يصح نسبة فعل لفاعل لم يفعله، مثل الغرق والموت وكل ما يفعله القدر في الإنسان، مع أن عبارة «مات حتف أنفه» تفيد مقصداً إعرابياً آخر!، فكأنها تقول: كيف يكون الميت فاعلاً لموته؟ أو الغريق فاعلاً لغرقه؟ وهلم جرا. كذلك الحال، حسب ما ذهب إليه أوزون، في نيابة الفاعل، نحو كُتب الدرسُ، فكيف يحل المفعول به نائباً للفاعل ويأخذ حركة إعرابه بدلالة الفعل المبني للمجهول! وما يلتفت له مؤلف الكتاب القول بالزوائد والمحذوفات، مثل إذا ما، فالنحو وضع قانوناً ملخصه: «ألا أدلك على شيء فيه فائدة: (ما) بعد إذا زائدة»، وهنا يحاول المؤلف إحراج القائمين على النحو العربي عند إعراب الآية «ولا يأب الشهداء إذا ما دعوا»، فيقول لهم: «حاشا لله أن يكون في كلامه زيادة أو حشو فهو الحق وكلماته الحق» (ص23).
ومن جملة ما جعله أوزون نقصاً أو تعقيداً في النحو العربي ما ذهب إليه اللغويون في القول بالمبتدأ الثاني، مع عدم الابتداء فيه، والأخبار المحذوفة المتعلقة بالجار والمجرور، على شاكلة: الطفل في المنزل، فالخبر محذوف تقديره كائن، وما يتعلق بالأفعال الناقصة، فما الفرق بين نام زيد وأمسى زيد، ولماذا يصبح الفعل نام فعلاً تاماً بينما يصبح الفعل أمسى فعلاً ناقصاً؟ وكيف تكون كلمة خلا حرفاً وأداة جر، وفعلاً ماضياً في آن واحد؟
عموماً يأتي كتاب المهندس زكريا أوزون دعوة ملحة من خارج الحزب اللغوي أو الأصولية اللغوية التي تحرص على حماية مملكتها من رياح التغيير، إلى تبسيط النحو، بما يتناسب مع روح العصر ومدارك المعاصرين وتوسع العلوم وسرعة التعلم، مع أن لكل لغة أُصولها وجمالها في التقيد بحدود المعقول والمفهوم منها، وأراه قافزاً على العصور في رده على سؤال، وضعه في الفصل الأول من الكتاب من بين تسعة أسئلة، وهو: هل مفردات أجدادنا العرب القدامى كافية؟ وهل استطاع نتاجهم الأدبي ـ الشعر والنثر ـ أن يعطي صوراً في الوصف تفوق صور اليوم، وهل يمكن لتلك المفردات أن تستوعب جميع المسميات في أيامنا المعاصرة؟ فبطبيعة الحال لا أحد يدعي هذا الكمال في التراث الأدبي وأي تراث، فكل فن أدبي يعبر عن عصره وبأدواته، لكنه لا يفقد الجمالية في العصور التالية، ولا يفقد ذووه العبقرية، ومع ذلك ليس لنا محاكاة معلقة امرئ القيس، بقصائد بدر شاكر السياب وصلاح عبد الصبور، والبيت الذي لم يعجب مؤلف الكتاب «مكر مفر مقبل مدبر معاً/ كجلمود صخر حطه السيل من عل» جماله في مخالفته للواقع، وليس بالضرورة أن يجعل الشاعر الفرس وجلمود الصخر شبه الغراب بالغراب.
كتاب «جناية سيبويه» الذي استغرق (173) صفحة من الحجم الصغير كان بمثابة حجرة في بحيرة النحو العربي الساكنة، كشف عن تعقيدات لا مبرر لها وأوهام من المحذوفات والثواني والنواقص وأشباه الحروف، لكني أجدها مبالغة أن يذهب مؤلفه إلى جعل تعقيد النحو العربي سبباً من سببين رئيسين في عدم انتشار اللغة العربية عالميا.، والسؤال هل انتشرت الانجليزية لسهولة قواعدها، وفيها ما فيها من تعقيد أزمنة الأفعال، والتباين بين المحكي والمكتوب من حروفها؟ وهل حجب تعقيد قواعد اللغة البلغارية، على سبيل المثال، انتشارها، وأن سهولة قواعد الفرنسية ساعدتها على الانتشار؟ وكيف انتشرت العربية أوان الفتوحات الإسلامية، حتى أصبحت لغة امبراطورية لوسعها شاع عن هارون الرشيد أنه قال للسحابة: أينما تمطرين يأتيني خراجك. فبسط اللغات وانتشارها له علاقة بالتفوق العلمي والمدني والاقتصادي والهيمنة السياسية الحضارية لا بالنحو وقواعد اللغة.
* الكتاب: جناية سيبويه
* المؤلف: زكريا أوزون
* الناشر: رياض الريس للكتب والنشر 2002
جريدة الشرق الأوسط : الأربعاء 06 ربيـع الأول 1424 هـ 7 مايو 2003 العدد 8926

Joomla Templates and Joomla Extensions by JoomlaVision.Com
Joomla Templates by Joomlashack